Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:12 pm Log in Sign up
Hawke's Bay

Are we becoming too reliant on the same legends?

club debate Hawke's Bay Supporters Hawke's Bay 12 posts ·70 views ·Posted: 20 Oct 2026, 12:07 pm ·Updated: 11 Nov 2026, 7:30 pm
SC ScrumKiwi Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 241 posts 20 Oct 2026, 12:07 pm
We've been riding the old boys for years and acting shocked when the young forwards go quiet. That drop-off was coming the moment everyone kept pointing at the same legends like they've got another decade in them. Spirit's lovely but legs win games 😏 enjoy the nostalgia lads 🤡
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
SC Scrum10 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 220 posts 20 Oct 2026, 2:02 pm
If we're really going to talk about a "drop-off," then what metric are we basing that on? Just saying the young forwards quiet down isn't analysis; it's just a feeling. Before we start blaming the genetics, show me the numbers comparing their output from last season to the current one, specifically around tackle counts or metre gained.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Reply Quote
DU Dunedin187 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 271 posts 20 Oct 2026, 3:20 pm
Feeling counts too mate 😤 I've watched the juniors at training, the legs are there, they just need game time. Back the young fellas through thick and thin 🔥🙌
Reply Quote
TI Tighthead Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 193 posts 21 Oct 2026, 3:20 am
Honestly, reading through these comments feels like trying to look at a blurry weather forecast and immediately drawing a hard prediction. What we need to do here is stop arguing about 'feelings' versus 'actual data' and instead define precisely what a 'drop-off' looks like when you apply proper metrics to a forward pack. It’s not just about noticing the younger guys are quieter; there’s a nuance here, and the difference between a momentary lull and a genuine decline needs proper quantification. When ScrumKiwi talks about the young forwards going quiet, they’re making an observation of effort, but that’s anecdotal. For me, if I were building a tracker for this team, I'd isolate three key operational metrics. First, tackle completion rate for each player, specifically comparing the percentage of successful hit tackles against total tackles attempted, which often shows a sudden dip when fatigue sets in. Second, the speed and efficacy of breakdown participation.
Numbers > vibes.
Reply Quote
CL ClassicFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 484 posts 21 Oct 2026, 6:46 am
Seen it all before, fellas. Every old Magpie side leaned on the veterans first, the kids grew up watching them. Ah well, we'll see 😄
Hawke's Bay goal celebration
Been here longer than some have followed.
Reply Quote
FR FrontRow_TillIDie Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 150 posts 22 Oct 2026, 1:44 am
Tighthead writing an essay to dodge a simple question, laughable really 😏 Kids look slow because the old boys hog 60 minutes every week. Give the juniors proper Bunnings NPC minutes and watch the legs show up.
Any stat can be bent.
Reply Quote
TR Tryline_Mate Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 640 posts 22 Oct 2026, 8:40 am
What even is the point of this argument really though? Are we just gonna keep arguing about who's better off the field instead of just cheering them on like they belong in Invercargill??? 🔥 They need support from us, tbh, maybe stop pointing fingers and just see the effort ah well, nowt to do. 💪😱
In the stands since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
WE WellingtonNZ Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 46 posts 2 Nov 2026, 3:25 am
@Tryline_Mate I kind of get where you're coming from, but I reckon cheering harder doesn't fix tired legs in the last twenty 🤔 John's got a point that ignoring the cracks won't win big games either. Can both things be true, back the boys AND ask for fresh blood? Still learning this stuff so honest question 😅
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Reply Quote
JO John_Faithful790 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 481 posts 22 Oct 2026, 9:43 am
blind faith won't win the big games, aye. we need to cheer hard, sure, but just ignoring the cracks isn't good rugby.
Seen it all, trust me.
Reply Quote
QU Queenstown51 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 483 posts 22 Oct 2026, 9:08 pm
I feel like we’re arguing two completely different things here. Some of us are talking about history, some are talking about tactics, but the reality on the field is that when the veterans start flagging towards the end of a match, the gap is massive. It’s not just about them having more minutes, it’s about the difference in sustained power when they hit that 60-minute mark. The young forwards just don't seem to have that same grit yet against teams that really push them in the NPC. It would be great to see some of the coaching staff finally give those younger guys the reins in tight situations, because right now they're often trying to keep up with players who’ve been carrying the team for a decade. Maybe the jump isn’t about minutes, maybe it’s about them needing real high-stakes pressure to actually evolve their game.
Hawke's Bay stadium
Hype isn't an argument.
Reply Quote
NI NickBreakdown1982 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 283 posts 22 Oct 2026, 11:17 pm
Been keeping my little spreadsheet going for years now and even I can't settle this one cleanly. Till's point about minutes has some weight in it, because if the young forwards only get scraps off the bench then of course the legs look flat when they finally start. But Queenstown's dead right that the gap late in games is what actually costs us, and that shows up whether you count carries or just watch from the terraces. So where does that leave us? Somewhere in the middle, honestly. The old boys have earned every minute, and the kids need real game time to close that gap. Depends how you count it, I suppose, and I'm happy to keep counting. Season's long, nobody's written off yet. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
NickBreakdown1982 wrote:
Been keeping my little spreadsheet going for years now and even I can't settle this one cleanly. Till's point about minutes has some weight in it, because if the young forwards only get scraps off the bench then of cours…
TU Turnover9 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 56 posts 11 Nov 2026, 7:30 pm
@NickBreakdown1982 this is the first sensible post in the whole thread aye, bench scraps explaining flat legs, who'd have thought 😏 I've thrown a few NZ$ on us choking late in games before and honestly the pattern matched your spreadsheet more than anyone's passion posts. So if the coach reads this, give the young forwards actual minutes and maybe my multi survives past the 60th for once 🤡
Hawke's Bay fans
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.