Bay of Plenty got smashed 26:45 by Tasman
That Tasman score is what's setting the line, and fair enough, 26:45 away is ugly no matter how you spin it. But Harbour only snuck past Otago and lost by one to Canterbury, so I'm not rushing to back either side. Had a crack on BOP off that Hawke's Bay win and got burned in Nelson; lesson taken, I'll wait for the line to settle before putting anything on this.
Trust the home form? I'd trust it about as far as I can throw the Rotorua goalposts after that Nelson trip. I keep my own table each round and the pattern I see is this: the Hawke's Bay win on 19 September was a 32:17 game at home, and the Tasman loss six days later was 26:45 away. Same side, different venue, 19-point swing in margin, that gap smells like a venue effect more than a form collapse. Compare that with Harbour's fortnight: 24:25 at home to Canterbury, then 32:21 at home to Otago. Both their recent games were at North Harbour, so their line of form is essentially a home-only sample. I could be wrong, but if you weight for where each side actually played, the two teams are closer than the Tasman blowout suggests, which is probably why the TAB line sits tight. Small sample though. Three results each. So I'd want a small stake rather than anything heavy either way. Depends how you count venue too; some models split home/away, some lump it. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Rob, your own table proves my point more than yours. Two games, opposite venues, six days apart, that's a sample of nothing. You can't price a line off a fortnight of form.
SweetAs has it right: Harbour lost by a single point to Canterbury and edged Otago 32:21 at home. Where's the evidence they travel? Nobody's shown me a single away result for them. I'll believe it when I see it. If the TAB line is tight, my read is the market knows both sides are thin data sets and it's hedging accordingly. Small stake or pass — value has to come from somewhere, and a two-match window isn't it. Source on Harbour's away form, anyone?
Hype isn't an argument.
Two games is a sample of nothing? Sure thing, mate, and yet you're both happy to price Harbour off the same two. Awkward, that. 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
LockLegend's onto it, you're all pricing Harbour off the same two games you slag Steamers for. 😏 Rob, remind me of your ROI before we trust your magic table?
Show me your ROI first 😏
🤣 LockLegend you menace, you've just blown up everyone's spreadsheet. Genuinely though, that Hawke's Bay win felt good at the time but I put $20 on the Steamers that arvo and watched the Tasman game at work like... mate, fold city. Two games each, nobody knows anything, gonna be a fun night regardless. Hold my pint 🍿
Hold my pint.
KevFan, that Nelson slip got me too, had a few NZ$ on the Steamers that week and learnt quick 😅 I get why the line's tight, Harbour only beat Otago by 11 and lost by a point to Canterbury, so they're not exactly flying either. Maybe I'm wrong, but that two-week swing from the Hawke's Bay win has me scared of the home form more than the Tasman score itself. Anyone actually seen the line move yet? 🤔
New here, soaking it up.
Sorry if this is a dumb question, still learning how lines work 😅 but does the TAB tighten it because everyone's still remembering the Hawke's Bay win? Feels like that 32:17 is doing a lot of heavy lifting, when two weeks later the same team got beaten by 19 in Nelson 🤔
Nick your NZ$ lesson hit home for me too, I nearly chucked the Steamers in a weekend multi before reading this thread, glad I held off. Harbour losing by a single point to Canterbury honestly reads better to me than either Steamers result. Cheers to whoever explained the fortnight swing thing, got it now 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Honestly the fortnight swing is what scares me, one week the Steamers look class against Hawke's Bay at home, next week they're cooked in Nelson 🔥 KevFan's right, those swings mess with your head (and your multi 😭). Harbours form ain't exactly scary either, that Canterbury loss by a point says more to me than the Otago win tbh. You just know our lot never make it easy 💪
You don't abandon your own.
Took a bit of the Harbour line last night for a small NZ$ stake and honestly the tight number suits me fine, Steamers getting that much respect off one home win while Harbour beat Otago properly? Mean value there. Keeping it single though, no way that swing lands on a multi 😭
Value over a big price 💸
Wait, the line's actually favouring the Steamers after that Nelson performance? One decent home game against Hawke's Bay outweighs falling apart after halftime? Show me the numbers, because from where I sit Harbour off a…
@Jackal sorry if this is dumb, but when you say the line suits you, does that mean you backed Harbour giving points? 🤔 Keen to learn this stuff properly before I put any NZ$ on 😅🙏
New here, soaking it up.
Jackal's right, that line's too tight for my liking. Got burnt taking Steamers off one good home game before. NZ$40 gone in 60 minutes 😭 Single only this week.
Value over a big price 💸
@Jackal sorry if this is dumb, but when you say the line suits you, does that mean you backed Harbour giving points? 🤔 Keen to learn this stuff properly before I put any NZ$ on 😅🙏
@PaulOpenside been there mate, chased a Steamers line off one home win a couple seasons back and it didn't land either. This week I'm with Jackal, had a few dollars on Harbour at the tight number, singles only, value over a big price every time. 26:45 in Nelson should've moved that line more than it did 🔥
Value over a big price 💸
@PaulOpenside been there mate, chased a Steamers line off one home win a couple seasons back and it didn't land either. This week I'm with Jackal, had a few dollars on Harbour at the tight number, singles only, value ove…
@CantabNZ857 "value over a big price", define value, because most punters use that word to mean "I had a feeling". Harbour off a win over Otago against a side that folded after halftime in Nelson, the tight number just looks like the market overreacting to one Steamers home game. I'll believe the line's sharp when someone here shows a closing figure worth backing.
Sample first, conclusions after.
@PaulOpenside been there mate, chased a Steamers line off one home win a couple seasons back and it didn't land either. This week I'm with Jackal, had a few dollars on Harbour at the tight number, singles only, value ove…
@RotoruaLoyal fair crack about punters throwing "value" around like a vibe tbh 😅 but I reckon the Steamers at home in Rotorua is a proper factor. Watched them live there a couple seasons back and the crowd dragged them over the line in the last ten - you could feel it from the terrace. That second half in Nelson was ugly, no arguing that, but one bad arvo doesn't kill a side.
Harbour off one win over Otago doesn't scream solid to me either. Tight number probably is the market getting carried away, yeah, so if anything that's an argument for leaving it alone, not hammering Harbour 🔥 backing our lot all day, just not with my NZ$ on a line I don't trust lol
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Wait, the line's actually favouring the Steamers after that Nelson performance? One decent home game against Hawke's Bay outweighs falling apart after halftime? Show me the numbers, because from where I sit Harbour off a proper win over Otago deserves more respect than that. Everyone piling in on the "value" side is usually a sign the value's already gone.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
@PaulOpenside been there mate, chased a Steamers line off one home win a couple seasons back and it didn't land either. This week I'm with Jackal, had a few dollars on Harbour at the tight number, singles only, value ove…
@Scrum10 nah I get your point, that second half in Nelson was rough to watch tbh 😬 but home steam at Rotorua counts for something, always has. Steamers by a bit, just don't ask me for numbers lol 🔥💪
One love, one side ❤️
@Metric_Lab "just don't ask me for numbers" is the whole problem though. Home advantage is real but it's priced into the line already, so you'd need to show Rotorua steam beats the margin the market sets, and nobody here has. I'll believe it when I see a Steamers side that actually plays 80 minutes after what happened in Nelson.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Tramping's got a point, the market knows about Rotorua. But I've got a source telling me the Steamers pack had a big week at training 😏 those who know, know 🤫
Solid source, details in the DMs.
My mate swears he picked the Steamers off a "big week at training" whisper once and won $20 on a multi, then lost $60 finding the next one 🤣 carried on alright there mate.
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿
@Metric_Lab "just don't ask me for numbers" is the whole problem though. Home advantage is real but it's priced into the line already, so you'd need to show Rotorua steam beats the margin the market sets, and nobody here…
@Tramping fair point and I'll cop to being guilty of hand-waving there. The line already carries the Rotorua effect, so a "big week at training" whisper only matters if it moves numbers the market hasn't seen, and those whispers usually have. Been keeping my own tables long enough to know one lucky multi proves nothing, sample size does. Show me the Steamers beating the spread at home across a decent stretch and I'll listen. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.