Be honest, Highlanders family
2015 side walks this lot, and deep down you all know it π Prime Aaron Smith alone wins the battle of the nines by a mile, this current pack wouldn't see half the ball. Anyone fancy telling me how we beat that lot? Remind me of your ROI on backing this current mob at the TAB, lads? π€‘πΈ
Show me your ROI first π
2015 side walks this lot, and deep down you all know it π Prime Aaron Smith alone wins the battle of the nines by a mile, this current pack wouldn't see half the ball. Anyone fancy telling me how we beat that lot? Remindβ¦
Romanticism through nostalgia goggles. Different era, different competitions - show me the head-to-head or it's just pub talk, mate.
Nah Supporter88, head-to-head means nothing, I was at Forsyth Barr in 2015, that crowd alone would frighten this mob π±πͺ Back the boys π₯
You don't abandon your own.
Sitting there in 2015 I watched Aaron Smith control games the way a conductor runs an orchestra, the box-kick alone would test this current back three all night. I could be wrong, but the scrum and breakdown work from that side is what wins it for me; Smith, Whitelock, Read recycling clean ball meant the opposition pack barely touched it for long stretches. Small sample though. One season of film versus whatever this mob produce across a full year. Depends how you count it, but if you're comparing peak form against current form, the 2015 lot take it comfortably. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Hope it's okay to jump in here, only joined the forum last week π
I was too young to really remember 2015 properly but my dad still goes on about that semi at Forsyth Barr, says the noise when Smith went on one of his box-kick runs was unreal. So RobFirstFive's point about the crowd mattering makes sense to me? Would love if someone explained simply what made that pack so dominant though π cheers
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Skeptic hat on: 2015 had the whole machine peaking, plus a soft draw in the back half of the season. Current side plays a harder weekly grind and still turns up. I'll believe the "smash" talk when I see a proper stat line, Napier - possession? Lineouts? Source on that, or just nostalgia?
Hype isn't an argument.
Queenstown51 asking for a source π mate I've got a bloke close to the set-up, and word going round is the gap's bigger than anyone admits π€« screenshot this
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Queenstown51 wanting a stat line for a feeling, classic π I'd put my TAB winnings on prime Smith making this lot chase shadows all arvo, mate.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Jack your "bloke close to the set-up" is doing a lot of heavy lifting π Show us the stat line or it's pub talk, through thick and thin I'll back the current boys.
You don't abandon your own.
Watching the highlight reels again and the thing that stands out is how fast that 2015 side played, Smith's pass was out before the forward even hit the deck, which is why the pack dominated possession without needing to bully anyone. Fair question whether today's forwards would get a sniff, but I'd want the actual possession and lineout stats before writing off the current boys. Nostalgia makes every old pack look like the 1976 All Blacks.
Sample first, conclusions after.
RotoruaLoyal nailed it, that quickfire pass was everything π
Only thing is, the 2015 pack still had serious grunt, this lot would need more than fast ball.
New here, soaking it up.
Watched that 2015 semi replay with my old man on the weekend and honestly my IT brain just kept thinking "system requirements too high" for this current pack π RotoruaLoyal's point about Smith's pass is the whole argument really - fast ball or no fast ball, someone still has to win the collision. So nah, no verdict from me, I'll be over here eating my cheapest-on-the-roof pie while you blokes argue πΏ
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
RotoruaLoyal nailed it, that quickfire pass was everything π
Only thing is, the 2015 pack still had serious grunt, this lot would need more than fast ball.
@RobbedAgainNightmare finally someone in this thread concedes the collision matters. Nostalgia merchants keep citing Smith's pass like it conjures front-foot ball out of nothing. Nobody had to "win the collision" back then? Whitelock and the boys would like a word. Grunt first, quickfire second, always was.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Funny thing, I had the 2015 side in a TAB multi the other week thinking fast ball alone would cover the line and it didn't land, needed that forward grunt then just like this lot need it now. Smith's pass is worthless off slow possession, simple as. Put $20 on this current pack winning a collision battle and I'd want better odds than that π
Bankroll discipline wins.
Watched that 2015 semi replay with my old man on the weekend and honestly my IT brain just kept thinking "system requirements too high" for this current pack π RotoruaLoyal's point about Smith's pass is the whole argumenβ¦
@JohnNapier1976 "system requirements too high" cracked me up, pretty much sums it. Smith's pass only pays off when the tight five has already done the dirty work, watched enough replays at the pub to know that. KevFan's multi not landing proves the point really, you can't back fast ball alone.
Nah but "system requirements too high" is the funniest way I've heard it put π I coached the juniors Tuesday night and told the big fellas the same thing, first to the ruck wins you the shiny stuff, all the flash backline moves mean nowt if the tight five are going backwards.
Reckon the nostalgia mob forget how much punch those old packs packed in themselves. Fast ball is a reward, not a starting point tbh. Heart says we fix it up front and the rest sorts itself through thick and thin πͺπ₯ ah well, nowt to do but back them at the pub this weekend.
Took the words out of my mouth watching from the pub couch. My old man's been saying it for years, no halfback on earth looks good behind a pack getting shunted. You can have the sharpest pass in the country and it's still slow ball if the tight five are going backwards.
Put a few NZ$ on the Highlanders line in a derby earlier this season and got burned the same way, kept thinking the backs would do something and the forwards got rolled up top. Lesson stuck. Bankroll is everything, so now I check the forwards first before I put anything on them. Barren seasons in the market teach you more than good ones ever will ππΈ
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Took the words out of my mouth watching from the pub couch. My old man's been saying it for years, no halfback on earth looks good behind a pack getting shunted. You can have the sharpest pass in the country and it's stiβ¦
@Maul_Legend your old man's spot on. I keep a running tally of quick tap metres by halfback and it tracks the front five possession stats nearly every round. π
Context beats a bare stat.
@Maul_Legend your old man's spot on. I keep a running tally of quick tap metres by halfback and it tracks the front five possession stats nearly every round. π
@NickBreakdown1982 a bloke with a spreadsheet at a rugby forum, my kind of nerd π honestly tho I unload pallets all day and even I could've told you the forward pack decides whether Smith looks like a superstar or a munted plonker. Keep that tally going mate, curious what it says after our next scrum flogging πΏ
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ