Be honest, lads: this Crusaders side without Razor's old magic is
Eight titles on the trot doesn't happen because everyone got lucky at the same time, so count me out of the nostalgia sob story π Razor or no Razor, the red and black machine ground teams into dust for years and that's culture, full stop. Anyone arguing it was just one bloke's magic clearly never watched the semi at Addington Danny's shout rounds on. π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
Eight titles on the trot doesn't happen because everyone got lucky at the same time, so count me out of the nostalgia sob story π Razor or no Razor, the red and black machine ground teams into dust for years and that's cβ¦
Culture, full stop? Handy how that argument always skips the years Razor walked in and everything clicked. Eight in a row is the coach plus a once-in-a-generation playing roster, and I'll believe the "machine runs itself" line when this lot go deep without either. Happy to be proved wrong at Addington, but on condition someone shows me a title that doesn't trace back to him.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah Tramping, you're underselling the jersey π₯ I grew up watching them grind sides flat long before Razor took the reins, that red and black mentality was bred into the place. The coach and the roster clicked, sure, but the culture was already there waiting for them... eight in a row just proved it. Get in! ππͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
Anyone who's sat with my spreadsheet over a beer at the Addington knows I keep the round-by-round stuff every year, and the same pattern keeps showing up: the deep runs and the titles cluster exactly where Razor sits in the coaching box. You can talk culture all you like, StandsGuyLegend, and I do think the red and black standards were set long before him, but eight in a row is too neat a run to be an accident of jersey heritage. I could be wrong, but I'd bet at the TAB that if you split the dynasty into pre-Razor and Razor eras, the consistency only shows up once he arrived, which points at coach plus that once-in-a-generation roster Tramping mentioned. The two of them together, feeding off a culture that was already there. That's the honest answer, not any single leg of it.
Funny thing, I was at Lancaster Park back when the whole red and black thing was just blokes turning up and bashing the rest of NZ into submission, no spreadsheet needed. Ruck9's numbers don't surprise me a bit, Razor's years do line up with the silverware, but StandsGuy has a point about the jersey. The young lot never saw those old nights, so they think it all started with eight in a row. Ah well, we'll see how deep this lot go without the old magic π
Been here longer than some have followed.
Ruck9's spreadsheet and I would get along famously, because I keep my own tables every round and the clustering he mentions matches what I see in my columns too. Eight straight with Razor in the box, and the stretch before that still strong but with more wobbles. That's a coach effect you can almost measure.
My caveat though: I sat next to a bloke at the Addington who swore the 2017-2023 years were all Razor, and I had to remind him Read and Whitelock and that front row were the reason the numbers held up at all. Culture was the substrate, Razor was the multiplier, roster was the base. Take any one away and the product drops. Small sample though, one dynasty. π
Numbers > vibes.
Ruck9, remind me of your ROI on that spreadsheet aye? π Razor's fine but the jersey did the heavy lifting, any punter at Addington knows it.
Show me your ROI first π
Nah lads, you're all arguing coach vs jersey when the answer's obviously both π€ Eight straight under Razor doesn't happen if the cupboard's bare, and the cupboard was never bare because the red and black pulls the best young fellas in. Two spreadsheets and still no winner at Addington? Put the TAB multi on it being culture and coach together, that's my call πͺπ₯
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Ha, back in the day I watched Wayne Smith's sides get beaten in finals too, and nobody said the cupboard was bare then π Good as gold, both things matter, but the young lot never saw those Leaney-era wobbles where the jersey couldn't tackle for itself. Razor sorted that. Pub debate settled, sort of.
Seen it all, trust me.
Fair point from John. One thing though: Razor inherited a squad most coaches would kill for. I'll believe the culture argument when someone shows me a title won without it.
Hype isn't an argument.
Queenstown51 has a point and I'll back it, with one wrinkle. Yes, Razor inherited a loaded squad, nobody serious argues that. But a squad most coaches would kill for still has to be coached, and the sample we've got since he left says the pieces alone don't assemble themselves. Context matters here, the same jersey was getting shown up defensively in the lean years John mentioned, so culture alone wasn't tackling anyone either.
My own little ledger says the honest answer sits between GloryDays and Queenstown51: eight in a row needed all three, coach, players, jersey, and take one leg out and the stool wobbles. What would settle it for me is a title won with a rebuild squad, because dynasties get judged on the second wave, not the first. Watching the derby nights down here, I'd say we're about to find out whether that second wave has arrived π
Do the math before you argue.
Honestly I'd put a cheeky NZ$20 on FrontRowArmy's side of this at the TAB, because Razor got dropsies-level talent but he still had to pick, rotate and keep the ego stew from boiling over for eight straight years. Queenstown51, remind me of your ROI on waiting for a title without the squad? π
Any stat can be bent.
Funny how the same squad argument never gets applied to the losing sides with big names. I could be wrong, but coach and culture can't be split this cleanly. Pub still owes me a verdict π
Context beats a bare stat.
Funny how the same squad argument never gets applied to the losing sides with big names. I could be wrong, but coach and culture can't be split this cleanly. Pub still owes me a verdict π
Sounds like you're saying the coach basically has to be a professional personality-shaper, which is honestly wild. Picking between talent and culture is a proper nightmare. I hope the pub has enough pints ready to deal with this mess, lmao π
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
Coached the juniors long enough to know talent without structure just goes sideways every Saturday, tbh. Miss Razor badly π’ ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.