Be honest, Tahs mates: is the Sky blue jersey still the dream gig
Dream gig? Give me a break, half the academy boys are on the first flight north before we've even learned their names π I'd put my TAB multi on it: the jersey's become a doormat for the Brumbies and the boys heading overseas. Laughable really, but keep telling yourselves it's 2005 in here π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
Doormat's a strong word from a bloke who backs it up with a TAB multi and vibes. Which academy boys are we talking about, specifically? Name them. Because every club in the country loses kids to overseas deals at some point, and the ones who actually made the jump from our academy lately went north with senior contracts on the table. That's not a leaky ship, that's a club producing players other unions want to pay for.
Stepping stone cuts both ways anyway. Boys leave, sure, but blokes still come here to finish careers and kids still grow up wanting that sky blue at Allianz. If you've got actual numbers on academy retention dropping year on year, I'll happily eat my words at the pub before the next home game. Until then you're arguing off a feeling, and a feeling's just an excuse for not checking.
Nah every mob loses young fellas north, that's just rugby now π₯ Tahs still fill Allianz and the kids who stay end up in gold one day, can't put a price on that tbh. Scrap it at the pub before kickoff and back them all day πͺ
Funny how ScrumKiwi's the loudest about "half the academy" yet hasn't named a single one of them, eh. Sam's question is the right one, because I've kept my own spreadsheet on departures for a few seasons now and the pattern I see is every franchise losing kids to Japan or Europe at some point. Small sample though, and until someone actually lists names and where they went, the doormat theory is just a TAB multi looking for a payout.
What I'd genuinely argue at the pub is this. Samoa Turnover's point stands, the ones who did move from our setup went north and we know which ones, they were in the papers. The rest of the leak is league, NZ and overseas poaching everyone, Brumbies included. And the kids who stay still end up in gold, which AucklandMate nailed. So the jersey's still the dream gig as far as I can tell, we just remember the departures more than the two hundred blokes who ran out at Allianz without a fuss π
Numbers > vibes.
Back in my day the academy boys bled sky blue for years before anyone waved a yen at them, and half the fun was watching them come through at Allianz. Tighthead's right that every franchise cops it now, but I'll say this much, the ones who stayed and wore the jersey properly, they're the ones the crowd remembers. Names worth learning before the pub debate, eh π
Depends how you count it, really. Losing kids north stings, but until I see the departure table say we're worse than the rest, I'm keeping my seat at Allianz. Pub debate stands.
Context beats a bare stat.