Beauden at ten was a bigger Blues mistake than any of us want to admit
I was at Eden Park the night we signed the Beauden announcement and half the pub I was in thought it was a wind-up. Four seasons at ten for one playoff win. Say it slowly and it still sounds like a bad multi that somehow got paid out once.
Look, world-class player, no argument. Just not at ten for us, and everyone quietly knew it by 2021. The Perofeta version haunts me. He was sitting right there in 2020 begging for the jersey and we kept feeding a bloke who wanted to be a first five the way I want to be a millionaire. 😏 And before anyone defends the recrutiment, remind me what we actually won in that window? Exactly. Cutely I'd still take Beauden on my team every day of the week, just nowhere near the ten jumper. 🤡
Any stat can be bent.
The pub test proves nothing, half my mates called the Lions call wrong too. One playoff win stings, sure, but Perofeta got every chance since and never nailed the jersey down himself, so where exactly is this alternate version? Beauden at ten was a risk that half worked, and I'd take that over pretending anyone else wanted the job in 2020.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
mate it's wild you talk like that, Perofet had the skill all along, they just didn't use it. 😩
Honestly, reading the debate, I reckon the issue isn't simply talent, but the flawed decision-making process during those four years. When you look at the overall efficacy, that one playoff win against the entire context of the selection, you have to dig a bit deeper than the reputation.
If we compare the results of that Beauden configuration against the hypothetical impact Perofet might have brought in 2020, the statistical disparity is quite stark. He possessed a certain profile that, depending on how you count it, could have provided a more stable, high-volume performance trajectory across a longer span than what we saw. I could be wrong, but that missed opportunity is the actual mistake the Blues made, not the individual player.
Context beats a bare stat.
Back in my day we reckoned the coach knew best and copped whatever he picked without a peep, and half the time that worked out fine. This Perofeta question though, lads, I watched enough derbies from the terrace to say the kid's always had the goods, they just never built the side around him. Four years of Beauden at ten and one playoff win, and every truckie at the smoko said the same thing in 2020. 😄
RobFirstFive is onto something there, the process was the problem more than any one call. I kept my own spreadsheet through those four seasons because I wanted to believe the move would settle in, and what stands out looking back is how many weeks Beauden was playing behind a pack going backwards while we still expected him to win us tight games off first phase. Small sample though, but the games I rewatched from 2021, the pattern was the same every time.
Where I'd push back on Mad is gently, because I was on the terrace too hoping Perofeta would just get a proper run. I reckon the caveat is that 2020 was the window, he was fit and hungry and the jersey was there for him, and once that season passed the side had been built around someone else for a year. Harder to hand it over after that. Still stings. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Funny how we all kept the same spreadsheet and drew different arrows. Mine says the pack was the bigger culprit some weeks, Perofeta might've copped the same battering in 2020, we'll never know. Doesn't mean the call was right, just means I can't close the ledger on it yet.
Context beats a bare stat.