Beauden's best years are behind him and it's time we said it out loud
Right, someone's gotta say it so I will. 2016 was nearly a decade ago and since then it's been injury break, rehab, injury break, and we all clap like it's 2016 again every time he completes 80 minutes. Honest take is his best footy's behind him, and the lads arguing otherwise would lose money at the TAB backing it, which tells you all you really need to know 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Clap like it's 2016? Most of us have been grading him on this decade, mate, and even half-fit Beauden pulls defences apart more than whoever replaces him. I'd take some receipts on these "injury break" seasons though, because a few of those absences were All Black rest windows, not the physio table.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Zoe's right tbh. Two titles, two World Player awards, and you just know he's got one more big night in him... I was there in 2016 and I'll back him all day 🔥💪
One love, one side ❤️
Zoe's got the sharpest point in this whole thread and I'd back her with my own spreadsheet 📊. I keep the minutes table every round, and the thing that jumps out is how many of those "absences" line up with All Black rest windows rather than anything on the physio report. Small sample though, and I'll admit the pattern gets murky once you go back past a couple of seasons, because the club never publishes the reason codes.
GloryDays, the honest version of your argument is simpler than the one you made. Say he's lost a step against fresh Super Pacific defences and I'll nod along, because the last three seasons haven't matched 2016 on any column I track. But dressing it up as a string of injury breaks when half of them were managed rest? That's where you lose me. Patience and honesty aren't the same bet here. I can want both.
Numbers > vibes.
Back in my day we carried our faded stars till the wheels fell off, and nobody whinged. Give him his last lap, I reckon 😉
Funny, I was doing the minutes table last night and both sides of this thread are half right. Tighthead's point about rest windows holds up if you dig a bit deeper, plenty of those gaps line up with All Black scheduling rather than the physio room. But Maul_Mate saw what I saw at the semis too. When he went off, we had no game manager and everyone knew it before the coaches did.
Here's my honest question though. Which Beauden are we actually backing? The 2016 bloke who ran games cold, or the current one who still slices a defence open for twenty minutes and then fades? Depends how you count it, really. If patience means pretending the last three seasons didn't happen, count me out. If honesty means giving him a defined role while he's still got one of the best rugby brains in the country, I'm all ears. Maybe the answer sits somewhere in between and we find out by round eight.
Context beats a bare stat.