Beauden's best years at the Canes are behind him
Say what you like but Beauden hasn't properly controlled a game from ten since 2022 and we're still pretending that's our best option, laughable really. Any punter putting cash on us while he's starting at first five deserves the ROI they get 🤡. Give the young guns a crack before another derby season goes to waste, or am I the only one seeing this?
Show me your ROI first 😏
The bloke you're calling finished played nearly every minute of last season's back end and still steered us around the park fine enough. If you'd watched him off the bench this year instead of typing, you'd have seen the game management's still there, the legs go, the head doesn't. What's your actual alternative, because "young guns champing" is vibes until a name is attached.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah RotoruaLoyal, head might be there but the body's gone and you can't coach around that 😤 Watched him get caught flat-footed too many times last season, the young guns are champing at the bit and we're just wasting their years, ah well, nowt to do 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
I keep my own table on this and honestly RotoruaLoyal has a point worth diggin a bit deeper into. If you split Beauden's minutes last season, the game management numbers off the bench actually hold up, he steered us fine in that back-end stretch, which suggests the issue is more about load than decline per se. That said, I could be wrong, but the derby tape from the Crusaders and Chiefs matches tells a different story when he starts at ten: the sample is small, sure, but he looked slow off the line against the young Chiefs halves. The nuance between those two data sets is what folk here are arguing past each other on, bench Beauden fine, start the kids. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Back in 2016-17 when he was running games we all saw proper ten play. Define "fine enough" though, RotoruaLoyal. Steering versus controlling are different things.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Scrum10 has it right. Steering and controlling are different jobs. I'll believe the "fine enough" line when I see him dominate a full eighty again.
Hype isn't an argument.
Scrum10's onto it, steering off the bench is worth something, I had him in a multi at 10 off the pine and it landed. But dominating eighty minutes? Haven't seen that since 2022 😭
Value over a big price 💸
Cute that the TAB kept paying you on bench cameos, Supporter_Life 😏 Sure thing, mate, and in reality? I'd rather lose with a hungry young ten learning than win a old head's farewell tour 🤡
Here to argue, not to nod along.
@LockLegend you'd rather lose with a young ten than win? Classic forum bravery, costs nothing to type 😏 Thing is, who's the hungry young ten you reckon is ready? Because word going round up here is the coaching staff aren't convinced yet, and they see him at training every week.
I've got no dog in the fight, but a source who'd know says the plan's been fluid all preseason. Whether that means a handover by June or another season of bench cameos... those who know, know 🤫
Solid source, details in the DMs.
@LockLegend you'd rather lose with a young ten than win? Classic forum bravery, costs nothing to type 😏 Thing is, who's the hungry young ten you reckon is ready? Because word going round up here is the coaching staff are…
@Wing_Fan genuine question from me, still learning this squad depth stuff 😅 if the coaches aren't sold on the young fella at training, does that mean there's actually no one ready, or just no one they trust yet? Would be keen to know who else is even in the mix at ten. Sorry if that's a dumb one 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Why's everyone acting like the young guns are ready? They're champing at the bit behind him, sure, but Beauden off the bench still wins us games 🔥 backing them all day tbh
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Wins us games off the bench, sure, but I put a multi on the Canes -7.5 three weekends back and it didn't land purely because we were sleepwalking through the first fifty at ten 😭 Bankroll says the line moved against us every time Beauden started slow, that's the market telling you something. Give the young gun the reins and she'll be right, I'd rather cash a futures bet on him developing than collect on cameos 🔥
Half of you are betting lines and half are writing farewell speeches 😂 So who actually gets first crack at ten this season, then?
Show me your ROI first 😏
Half of you are betting lines and half are writing farewell speeches 😂 So who actually gets first crack at ten this season, then?
@GloryDays247 Beauden first crack, easy. You just know the coaches back him to start while the young fella learns off the bench 💪 Ah well, nowt to do but wait and see 🔥
Yeah @Tauranga15, you just know they got the vision 💪 But seeing him start every week isn't gonna fix what's wrong, tbh.
In the stands since I was a kid.
@GloryDays247 betting lines crew checking in 😂 Beauden first crack for mine, short priced favourite and I'd take that all day. Worth noting the market barely moved on the Canes' win odds all pre-season, tells you the bookies expect the old head to start too. Golden oldies at the TAB had him first try scorer in a few of my multis last year, landed once, on and forgotten the rest 💸
Up one week, down the next. Classic.