Canterbury 66:19 over Wellington: biggest blowout this season?
Was at that Wellington rout in Chch and my ears are still ringing π₯ but the 25:24 squeak at North Harbour a week later was scarier than the 66:19 blowout tbh. So, question for the thread: Canterbury's rampage or any tight grind one-point escape, which win rate says more about who's stronger? Ah well, nowt to do πͺ
In the stands since I was a kid.
Big margin tells you the ceiling, the one-point escape tells you the floor, and I'd take the floor when judging a side. π
Look at the two metrics side by side. Canterbury's September form has both anyway: 66:19 over Wellington at home and 36:14 away to Waikato show the ceiling, while 25:24 at North Harbour six days later shows they can close out a match when everything wobbles. A rout often says as much about the opponent's state as your own strength, whereas grinding out a win away from Christchurch under pressure is the harder skill to fake. I could be wrong, but if you're asking which result predicts who's stronger overall, I'd weight the Harbour escape higher than the Wellington blowout, simply because surviving a tight one is repeatable and a 47-point margin rarely is. Either way, four wins from four in that stretch, hosting Southland after and Manawatu on 3 October, means the sample is small but it's all green.
Context beats a bare stat.
Nah Tryline, you've got it backwards mate. The Harbour escape is the overrated one, everyone crowing about how "they can win ugly" like that's a personality. One-point dodge away from home just means Harbour dropped their landing. The 66:19 is the actual evidence, and I'd happily take the TAB line on anyone beating that scoreline this season. π
Show me your ROI first π
Show me the numbers over a full season before anyone crowns this lot. Four good weeks in September, sure, but Harbour beat themselves by one point and nobody's played Manawatu yet. Judge the ceiling or the floor all you like, I'd rather see whether they still turn up in late October.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Back in the day we judged sides by their whole campaign, not one hot month. Four good weeks is lovely, but until Manawatu on the 3rd I'm holding my applause π
Seen it all, trust me.
Some folks really appreciate the sheer statement made by the 66:19 demolition of Wellington, which points to a top-tier ceiling for the team. However, the broader consensus seems to favour the emotional impact of the 25:24 escape at North Harbour, suggesting their real strength lies in those clutch wins rather than simply overwhelming opponents.
I keep my own tables π