Crusaders: Are we coasting on past glory, or is this the real
Gonna say the thing nobody in this club wants to hear. We're coasting. Last few seasons we've been living off the names on the team sheet, all the All Blacks labels, and calling that depth. It's not depth when half your backline only shows up fit for test windows.
Meanwhile how many kids from the local club scene have actually forced their way into the 23 lately? Somebody remind me of the last genuine academy product who stuck? Laughable really. I'd put a NZ$20 multi at the TAB on us getting found out before we get found out for real 😏 Honestly, if the answer to that is "wait till next season", that IS the answer.
Any stat can be bent.
Gonna say the thing nobody in this club wants to hear. We're coasting. Last few seasons we've been living off the names on the team sheet, all the All Blacks labels, and calling that depth. It's not depth when half your …
Which seasons exactly are you calling coasting, FrontRow? Name them and name who we supposedly failed to develop, because the pathway stuff sounds like a gut feeling with a jersey on.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah Rotorua's got it, name a young fellar we've rushed lately 🔥 the juniors I coach talk about leaving for a Super spot elsewhere because ours go to the big names first. 🤬
You don't abandon your own.
Fair challenge from Rotorua, but StandsGuy's juniors match what I see in my own spreadsheets. I could be wrong, but the pattern holds across recent seasons: Test-window players anchor the matchday 23, and the academy lads get scraps off the bench, mostly once the result's decided. That's how a pathway quietly becomes a waiting list. Context matters though, I don't have clean minutes-per-under-23 figures in front of me, so treat it as a strong trend rather than gospel.
bloody hell, it sounds like everyone’s got an opinion on the talent pool these days, mate. back in my day we just knew how to win when we walked onto the paddock, and we learned that with a mix of big talent and grit from home, you know what i mean? It’s hard for the young ones to grasp that sustained success isn't always a neat little development pipeline; sometimes you just need that proven winning mentality you can't teach.
bloody hell, it sounds like everyone’s got an opinion on the talent pool these days, mate. back in my day we just knew how to win when we walked onto the paddock, and we learned that with a mix of big talent and grit fro…
@SweetAs_Mad maybe I'm wrong but grit from home only works if the academy lads actually get minutes? Feels like they never get a proper run 🤔
Learn something new every day.
Funny thing, I was updating my round-by-round spreadsheet this arvo and this thread basically mirrors the columns in it. Ruck9's pattern holds in my own numbers too, Test-window blokes eat most of the starts and the academy minutes cluster in garbage time. Small sample though, one or two seasons of minutes data can flatter either argument depending on where you squint.
SweetAs_Mad has a point buried in the grumbling though, the 2017 and 2022 sides mixed homegrown lads with the big names and nobody called that coasting. So the real question I keep circling is whether the current balance is a genuine funnel problem or just a hard competition where established All Blacks block the pathway by being genuinely better right now. Both can be true at once, and until someone shows me a junior we clearly rushed or clearly ruined, I'm keeping both columns open in the sheet.
Numbers > vibes.
The problem isn't the kids leaving, not really. There’s something going on with the bigger picture, though. Just details in the DMs, maybe. Some things aren't about the score on the day, you know? 😏🤫
Those who know, know.