Forget Bledisloe heartbreak
Blaming the team for Suncorp going quiet is cope of the highest order π€‘ 50-odd thousand of us screamed the joint down in 2011, same concrete, same club, so what changed? Us. We turned into spectators who turn up for a wine and clap politely, then wonder why the boys fold at home. I've got NZ$20 with a punter mate that if we actually made noise for once, we'd pinch a semi. Sure thing, mate, keep sitting on your hands and keep losing πΈ
Show me your ROI first π
Funny how you cherry-pick 2011 and skip the part where that crowd had a winning team worth screaming for. Last season's semi, the boys went 20 minutes without holding onto the ball and the noise died with them, crowds react to what's on the pitch. Give us something to roar about again and Suncorp will shake on its own.
Nah Sam, the noise died cos WE let it die π€ I was in the Bay Corner for that semi and after 20 mins of dropped ball half the joint was checking their phones like it was a TAB multi gone belly up... 2011 crowd didn't wait for perfect footy to lift the roof, we sang through the shite. Fortress starts with us, ah well, nowt to do but fix it next season π₯πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
Watching my old match notes from that semi, the noise drop tracked the error count almost minute for minute, which honestly supports both of you. But StandsGuy's point about 2011 stands: we sang through plenty of shite spells that year too, and the boys fed off it. Depends how you count it, but a crowd that stays loud through 20 bad minutes is worth a few points on its own, and we stopped paying that tax.
Do the math before you argue.
Seen this argument before, and back in the day the old Ballymore crowd made noise no matter what was happening on the pitch, that was just what you did. The semi crowd last year? Quiet as your nan's lounge room the second things went crooked. Crowd feeds the team, simples, always has. Ah well, we'll see what this season brings π
Been here longer than some have followed.
Read FrontRowArmy's notes again and both camps actually win a point each, if I'm honest. The noise tracking the error count minute for minute says the crowd reacts, sure. But 2011 is the counterproof: we sang through some genuinely ugly spells that year and the boys came out the other side of them anyway. Same concrete, same club, different behaviour in the stands.
I could be wrong, but I suspect it cuts both ways and neither side will enjoy hearing that. A crowd that only roars when the footy's clean is a fair-weather crowd, no way around it. A team that needs the roof lifted every minute to hold structure at home has a problem of its own too. Small sample though, one semi versus a whole golden season, so I'm keeping my tables open on this one π See you all at the pub before the next home game and we can settle it over a jug.
I keep my own tables π