Forget the Crusaders rivalry
Mean, some of yous would rather lose pretty than win ugly and it shows π Three offloads from our own 22 in Hamilton, three turnovers, and half this forum still clapped like it was art. I'd take a 3-3 grind every week if it meant four points, but wait for the fanboys to pile in telling me that's boring π€‘π
Show me your ROI first π
The clapping wasn't for the turnovers, mate, it was for the intent. Force teams into that kind of chaos and sometimes it sticks, which is how we've won more than one tight one over the years. Repeatedly doing it from our own 22 with the game on the line? Yeah, that part deserves the criticism. Trade it all for 3-3 grinds and I'd be at the pub less often, not more.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Why you gotta be so brutal about the attack tho? We run that stuff because itβs the Chiefs way and it makes the game *exciting*, ah well, nowt to do. If we only went for 3-3 grind wins then it wouldn't be rugby, mate. Gotta let the ball fly! π€©π
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Zoe's got it right and I'll back her with the actual pattern from my own spreadsheet π. That Hamilton spell wasn't one bad night, it was the third game running where we'd turned it over inside our own 40 off a low-percentage offload. Intent is lovely, but intent from your own 22 against a set defence is just a coin flip, and we kept flipping. Dig a bit deeper and the tight wins Zoe mentioned came when we kicked for territory first and ran it second. I'd trade one highlight for three solid exit phases every time, because a lineout on their 10 metre line creates more chances than a miracle pass ever will. Small sample though, I'll admit, but the trend's ugly.
I keep my own tables π
Back in my day the great sides didn't need to look pretty, they just choked you out and took the points. The Crusaders won plenty of titles that way while we were dazzling folk and coming up short. The flair's lovely when it sticks, young fellas, but I'd trade three of those offloads for one boring cleanout at the breakdown every time π
Seen worse arguments than this one, and I'll tell you what I told my boy at the pub before the Hamilton game. The old Waikato crowds used to cheer a trampling from the goal line just as loud as alength-of-the-field try, because effort was the point. Trade the flair for a few 3-3 grinds? Only if the young lot stop learning the offloads in training first, otherwise we get the worst of both π
Seen it all, trust me.
Funny how the same spell reads two ways. I sit there with my spreadsheet every round and even I felt the itch when that offload out of our own 22 went down in Hamilton. But here's the nuance: those three turnovers weren't boldness, they were habit. The good sides run that ball from deeper positions with numbers aligned, where a turnover costs you nothing much. From our own 22 with the defence set? That's just punt, and the data says we've been punting three games running now.
Do I want us to become a 3-3 grind outfit? Nah, I'd struggle to watch that every week. But there's a big gap between killing the flair and picking the moments. Clever footy knows when the risk is worth it, and right now we're choosing those moments on feel, not on where we are on the park. Maybe that's the actual conversation to have before the next home game. I'm genuinely torn, and I suspect most of you are too once you get past the highlight reels. π
Numbers > vibes.
Seen worse arguments than this one, and I'll tell you what I told my boy at the pub before the Hamilton game. The old Waikato crowds used to cheer a trampling from the goal line just as loud as alength-of-the-field try, β¦
@John_Faithful790 don't laugh, guys, but that actually makes sense to me? Like the crowd cheering a trampling from the goal line just as loud, I've only ever known the flashy stuff so I never thought of it that way π
So would you take a grinding 3-3 win over a lost thriller then? Still learning this, thanks for the story either way π
Learn something new every day.