Honest debate, fellow Canterbury Faithful
Two decent nights at One NZ and suddenly the pub's handing out jerseys for the all-time pack, classic us π Been burned before, mate, remember when everyone was crowning the scrum a few seasons back? Season was dead by June and we all pretended we never said it.
Look, the tight five's going alright, I'll give you that much. But one cold night in Dunedin or a wet trip up to Auckland sorts the pretenders from the real thing quick smart. I've got a lazy NZ$20 on the TAB says we're all having this exact argument again in Round 9 with very different tones π€‘πΈ It's a lottery this early, not sport. Ask me again after we've won one nobody tipped us to win π
Show me your ROI first π
The June collapse comparison is lazy, mate, that side had injuries in the second row and a rookie hooker by round 8, this pack has been dominant for the whole run and held up against the best scrum opposition we've faced all season. Two good nights? Look at who we beat and how.
I'll happily concede one thing: one bad June and I'll be the first to say the pub got carried away again. On condition that we judge them in July, not now and not off two home games. Recency bias cuts both ways, you're doing it in reverse, remembering one collapse and using it to write off a genuinely different group.
Hype isn't an argument.
Was at both nights and this scrum bossed everyone they met π± Queenstown's right, injuries wrecked that old side. Say it loud: best pack in yonks π₯πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
Queenstown's got it right, I could be wrong but the June collapse side was held together with tape by round 8. Second row gone, rookie hooker throwing crooked ball, and the whole set-piece fell apart with it. This pack has handled the best scrum we've faced all season and kept its shape the whole run. Two good nights at One NZ? Context matters, and the context says this lot earned the praise. π
I played through that June collapse era and you could see it coming, pack was held together by tape πͺ this lot though? you just know π₯π₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
Spent my Friday night doing the depth chart by hand instead of sleeping, and I'll back Queenstown51 here, the set-piece depth is what separates this lot from the June collapse mob, who had nobody coming off the bench once the second row went. I could be wrong, but what I'd flag is that two home nights is a small sample though; away trips are where packs get properly audited, ask anyone who travelled in the golden era. Ask me again after the first long road run. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Depth's the whole scam, isn't it - June mob had starters, this lot has replacements who actually scrum π I've lumped NZ$50 on us top seed, fancy your odds, boys?
Show me your ROI first π
Depth's the whole story now is it? π Two good nights at One NZ and suddenly we're comparing bench options like it's 2008 all over again. Ruck9, mate, you do realise the June mob looked fine in March too. I'll believe this scrum when it survives a derby away from home, not when it Bulks up in front of the home crowd. Keep my NZ$50 in my pocket till then πͺ
Heart with the team, head on pause.
StandsGuy you're talking to the wrong bloke mate, I had money on the June mob back then and got burned π this time I watched the set-piece actually hold when the bench came on and that's the difference. Two home nights don't crown anyone, but the scrum depth is real - I'll happily take Napier's NZ$50 side of that top seed bet. π₯πΈ
SweetAs, that bench holding the scrum late was the first real proof we've had all season. I'll believe it when I see it away from home.
Sample first, conclusions after.
RotoruaLoyal I'm with you, that late scrum hold was the first proper proof we've got honestly π
Maybe I'm wrong but I watched it from the flank at One NZ and the shove on came off the bench without a wobble, gave me shivers. Still not saying anything till we see it away though, don't laugh, but is the next away trip the real test?
New here, soaking it up.
RotoruaLoyal I'm with you, that late scrum hold was the first proper proof we've got honestly π
Maybe I'm wrong but I watched it from the flank at One NZ and the shove on came off the bench without a wobble, gave me shivβ¦
@Nick_Tauranga mate I know exactly that shiver, was up behind the posts when the bench front row came on and the shove just stuck π₯ RotoruaLoyal is right tho, gonna need to see it away from home before I get carried away... seen too many packs go quiet on the road ah well, nowt to do but turn up and see π
One love, one side β€οΈ
Careful lads, every year we get one scrum hold in June and suddenly half the thread's picking finals XVs π I watched that bench shove go in and yep, shivers, but the away trip is where packs get found out. KevFan, before I take that free beer, remind me of your ROI? π
Any stat can be bent.
KevFan dodging the ROI question already π free beer's the only line he's cashed all season, wait for the fanboys to defend him.
Here to argue, not to nod along.