Honest question, Harbour whanau: is our problem the coach
Both, surely? Coach freezes in the tight bits and the young blokes pay for it. A 19-year-old from Albany sitting there for sixty minutes while we're chasing the game, what does he learn from that, how to hold a warm seat? And in reality we keep doing this every season, then wonder why the likes of the Crusaders just raid our catchment for the lads we were too scared to give game time. 😏
And don't give me "he's not ready", nobody's ready till they're blooded, mate. Even a loss with the kid on for thirty minutes is worth more development than a wasted season on the pine. I had a cheeky TAB multi on us youngsters getting more minutes this year, biggest free lesson of my punting life 🤡💸. So honest question back at you all: if we won't back our own, who exactly are we developing for?
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Warm seat? Every NPC coach benches his teenagers when a quarterfinal's on the line. Ask Tasman. Show me the young gun we actually didn't blood this season and I'll concede.
Hype isn't an argument.
Queenstown reckons we blooded everyone? what was his name, the Albany kid, 60 mins on the pine 🤬 if we can't trust a 19yo at home then nah, that's on the coach 🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Watched the tape back on that one and it still annoys me. Sixty minutes on the pine for a 19-year-old from Albany while we're chasing points, and Queenstown51 reckons that's just standard NPC practice? I could be wrong, but there's a difference between protecting a kid in a tight quarterfinal and leaving him sitting there when the game's already slipping. One is development with a plan behind it. The other is a warm seat, exactly like LockLegend says.
Small sample though, and I'll give Queenstown this much, Tasman have done the same thing. But dig a bit deeper and the pattern matters more than one call: if the only minutes our young fellas get are garbage time or none at all, we're not building a squad, we're renting one. Coach's call to make. She'll be right? Only if he actually backs them next round.
Context beats a bare stat.
Reckon I've seen this movie before, fellas. Back when I was playing juniors we got blooded at 19 and it made us, even when we lost 🙌 you just know that Albany kid learns nowt warming a seat. Coach has gotta back the young guns through thick and thin, ah well, nowt to do 🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
RobFirstFive said it right, mate, watched that bench situation and my gut said the same. Word going round is the young fella was told he'd get 20+ mins too, so there's more to it than the tape shows 🤫 agree with Queenstown51 partly though, coaches do protect kids in tight ones, just not at home with the game there to grab. Source reckons the Albany boy will get his shot sooner than folks think 😏
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Nah lads, I'm calling it straight, that kid from Albany got lied to and we're all just shrugging 🤬 You promise a teenager 20+ mins and then he watches sixty minutes of us chasing the game? What's the point of a bench then, decoration?
And RobFirstFive mate, "standard NPC practice" cuts both ways. Every other province somehow finds 20 mins for their young guns in tight games, why can't we? 🤔 Don't tell me the game was too tight, we were LOSING, what exactly were we protecting, the honour of getting pumped?
Half of you are defending this like it's the Bledisloe and every point is sacred. It's the NPC, breathe. Coach or culture? Doesn't matter, they're the same problem, nobody at this club trusts youth until it's too late 😤
You don't abandon your own.
Nah hold up Queenstown_Mad, if we're chasing the game does it matter if the kid comes on at 60 or 80?? 😱 every NRL club throws teenagers into tight finishes, we just gotta show some guts tbh 🤬
Saw the same thing at the North Shore ground, kid did the warm-up, then never moved from that seat once we fell behind. If he was promised 20+, someone owes him an explanation.
Sample first, conclusions after.
@RotoruaLoyal yeah saw that too, kid warming up then glued to the bench 🤬 breaks his confidence tbh. Coach has gotta back the young fellas through thick and thin, nah mean? 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
@RotoruaLoyal yeah saw that too, kid warming up then glued to the bench 🤬 breaks his confidence tbh. Coach has gotta back the young fellas through thick and thin, nah mean? 🔥
@ClassicGuy warming a kid up then never using him is the worst of both worlds, pure punt-killer logic too, I priced that game assuming he'd get run and it cost me a leg of my multi. Confidence is bankroll for a young player, you don't torch it for nothing. Coach has got to either back him or leave him in the stands.
Bankroll discipline wins.
@ClassicGuy warming a kid up then never using him is the worst of both worlds, pure punt-killer logic too, I priced that game assuming he'd get run and it cost me a leg of my multi. Confidence is bankroll for a young pla…
@KevFan felt that loss through my own multi tbh, had the lad getting decent minutes as my try scorer leg and it died right there 😭 And you're spot on with the confidence bit, kid spends 60 minutes stripped and ready then sits back down wondering what he did wrong. If there was a knock fine, but if the coach just went safe then that's another tick in the "problem is the coach" column for me.
@Steve_SweetAs nah exactly this... 20 dead minutes down 30 teaches nothing, 20 at 60 when it's still alive teaches plenty. Coach wrapping kids in cotton wool tbh 🤬
@ClassicGuy exactly. Kid's trackpants and cotton wool, might as well leave him at home. The ABs give teenagers proper minutes now, Harbour can too.
I keep my own tables 📊
@ClassicGuy this, warming a kid up then never using him feels worse than leaving him out entirely tbh 😅 I remember my coach did that to me once in club footy and you spend the whole warmup wondering. Does anyone know if the kid had a knock or the coach just went safe? Still learning the ins and outs of squad management at this level 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
RotoruaLoyal nailed it, someone owes that kid an explanation, full stop. My caveat though: even if he'd come on at 60 chasing the game, that's development too, pressure minutes teach more than a dead rubber. I backed us in a TAB multi last weekend with the line and it didn't land partly because we had nothing fresh off the bench late. Cold 19-year-old on the pine is worth nothing to him and nothing to my bankroll 😭
RotoruaLoyal nailed it, someone owes that kid an explanation, full stop. My caveat though: even if he'd come on at 60 chasing the game, that's development too, pressure minutes teach more than a dead rubber. I backed us …
@Steve_SweetAs nah exactly this... 20 dead minutes down 30 teaches nothing, 20 at 60 when it's still alive teaches plenty. Coach wrapping kids in cotton wool tbh 🤬
One love, one side ❤️
Nah Steve's got a point though, pressure minutes at 60 down still teach that kid more than a parked seat 💪 But you just know the real answer is both, coach gotta trust the young fellas when it's tight AND we as a crowd gotta stop groaning every time a teenager pulls on the jersey 🙌 Through thick and thin, that's the whole point of Harbour, eh. Keep this argument burning, I'm keen to hear more takes 🔥
You don't abandon your own.