Honest question, Magpies, is McLean Park still our fortress
Fortress? Sure thing, mate. If the fortress is the pub across the road, because that's the only thing at McLean Park that's been holding its line lately. Three of the last five gone and you lot are still singing about the Heretaunga wind like it's a player. And in reality? Any punter taking the Magpies at the Park on nostalgia alone deserves to lose their NZ$. 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Three of five, and you're calling it a mausoleum already? Ask any Wellington side that's come in on a June afternoon whether that wind is folklore. Sides don't fear the scoreboard, they fear the last twenty minutes into that southerly. One bad stretch of results doesn't close a fortress, you'd know that if you'd actually sat through a few of them instead of reading them on your phone.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Was at McLean Park when that southerly wrecked Wellington's lineout, you just know the wind still counts 🔥💪 3 of 5 stings but fortress ain't dead. MAGPIES!! 🙌 ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
Been keeping my own spreadsheet on home results for years, and I'll say this much for RotoruaLoyal's side of the argument: three losses in five reads worse as a raw count than it does once you look at margin and context. A fortress was never about going unbeaten — it was about visiting sides knowing the last twenty minutes into that southerly would cost them. I could be wrong, but I'd want to see whether those three defeats were close games blown late or comfortable losses, because that distinction decides the whole debate. Small sample though, five matches tells you more about the current roster than about the ground itself. LockLegend's pub joke lands nicely, but Wellington teams still hate travelling here in June, and that's worth something even when the scoreboard lets us down. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Word going round the club circles is that visiting sides still ask about the park conditions before they commit their run-on - make of that what you will 🤫
But I'll give you the old-timer view: back when I was a kid on the terrace side, that Heretaunga southerly won us more games than any ten jersey. Wellington sides used to arrive looking at the flags like it was a death sentence. Three of five stings, sure, and Rob's margins point is fair, but fortresses aren't measured in a season, they're measured in whether the fear's still there. Word is, it still is. Details in the DMs if you want more 😏
Those who know, know.
Spreadsheet bloke reckons the losses don't count if you squint at the margins 😂 mate, I was there for a couple of them and the only wind we felt was coming out of our own attack. FullbackMate's gossip about visiting sides asking about conditions? Every ground in the country gets that call, even Eden Park. Keep the faith tho, backing our lot all day, fortress still breathes 💪🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
StandsGuyLoyal, mate, you were at the bad ones, I get it 😤 but I was there the day that southerly turned Wellington's lineout to soup too. Wind like that doesn't just pack up and leave cos we lost a couple 🔥 Teams still hate rocking up to McLean Park, you can see it in their warmup 🙌 Fortress needs defending though, so get behind the boys 💪
One love, one side ❤️
StandsGuyLoyal, mate, you were at the bad ones, I get it 😤 but I was there the day that southerly turned Wellington's lineout to soup too. Wind like that doesn't just pack up and leave cos we lost a couple 🔥 Teams still …
@ClassicGuy spot on mate, southerly days at McLean Park are something else 😱 but Tramping's right, pack has to earn it. Front row fires, that wind becomes a weapon 🔥💪
You don't abandon your own.
Wind or no wind, I'll believe it when I see it against a full-strength visiting pack. Southerly never fixed a scrum that's going backwards.
Hype isn't an argument.
Fair points both ways, but wind's only ever worth something if the pack backs it up, Queenstown51 nailed that. I'll grant the southerly made Wellington's lineout fall apart that day, on condition someone shows me the same happening against a full-strength forward run recently. Three of five gone at the park says the visiting coaches stopped fearing it; I'll believe the fortress is alive when I see a side fold there, not before.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Still learning this stuff so excuse me if I'm off 🙏 but is it really a fortress if we only win there when the wind does the work? Keen to see the pack prove it this season 😊
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Still learning this stuff so excuse me if I'm off 🙏 but is it really a fortress if we only win there when the wind does the work? Keen to see the pack prove it this season 😊
@Wellington_15 nah you're not off mate, fair question tbh 😄 wind only wins you games if the forwards front up, everyone knows that. Watch the scrum and maul early, if the big fellas are going backwards you can forget the southerly doing anything.
I played a bit of club footy into my thirties so trust me, scrummaging into that wind is misery, but the side that keeps its shape usually comes right. Keen to see our pack bash a proper Super derby-level front row this season, then I'll call it a fortress again 🔥 ah well, nowt to do but wait and see
Still learning this stuff so excuse me if I'm off 🙏 but is it really a fortress if we only win there when the wind does the work? Keen to see the pack prove it this season 😊
Nah you're not off at all @Wellington_15, I wondered the same thing 😅 guess a fortress only counts when the forwards win it up front, wind or no wind 🤔
Learn something new every day.