Honest take, cousins: Moana Pasifika play better footy when Ardie
Saw this bloke at the Mount Eden pub get half booed for saying it, and honestly he had half a point π Ardie's a legend of the game but every ruck he hits slows our tempo right down, the offload game looks quicker when someone else's hauling at the breakdown. Remind me of your ROI before you come at me? π
Show me your ROI first π
Half a point isn't a point, Napier. What does "slows our tempo right down" actually mean, phase speed, ruck arrival time, offloads completed? Because "he hogts three defenders at the breakdown" is doing a lot of work in that sentence, and I'd want to see it. Ardie's the guy pulling two tacklers in every carry, which is exactly why the next runner has space. The bloke at the pub probably watched one sloppy loss and built a theory around his pint.
Happy to be proven wrong, mind. Show me the numbers, same opponents, same halfbacks, with and without him β and I'll buy the first round at Mount Eden myself. Until then I'm filing this one next to "the boys play better after a few" as pub science.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Bloke buys our boys 3 seconds by sucking in defenders and you reckon that slows us?? Have a look again π€π₯
You don't abandon your own.
Scrum10's asking the right question, because "tempo" means nothing until you define it, depends how you count it, ruck speed and offload completion are two different beasts. From what I've tracked on my own sheet, the phases where Ardie cleans out do run slower, but that's the trade: he soaks defenders the way Queenstown_Mad says. Small sample though, and I could be wrong, but I'd back the pub bloke on pure offload flow, with the caveat that slowing the ruck is partly the point. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Reminds me of when our lot first started, everyone blamed one bloke for the ruck speed π
Ardie sucking in three defenders IS the tempo, cousins π₯
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Was at that same table at Mount Eden and I drank with the nodding half, tbh π
Ardie's class but you just know the ball comes out faster when he's resting. Ah well, nowt to do π€·π₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
Tried backing us in the line markets when Ardie's out, mostly didn't land, cousins π Queenstown_Mad is right, watch who runs at him first π₯
Bankroll discipline wins.
Watch who attacks the fringe when Ardie's off, teams still commit two to him at rucks even when he's at the back of the line, that's the tell.
KevFan, same here, threw him into the try scorer leg of a TAB multi a few weeks back, didn't land π Still reckon he bends the line even when the ruck's slow, bro π₯
Value over a big price πΈ
@Supporter_Life I've only been following Moana properly this season but even I can see defenders just hesitate when Ardie's near the ball, that alone bends things π
Tab multi heartbreak is real though, dropped a NZ$5 leg on him too π don't laugh, guys, but what actually counts as a "slow ruck" in the stats?
@JohnInvercargill84 nah bro no laughing here, we've all dropped multi legs to Ardie π
the hesitation is the whole point tho. Even a half-beat pause at the ruck opens the fringe for our loosies. Slow ruck tbh just means the clean takes longer, Ardie's the reason it does πͺπ₯
You don't abandon your own.
@Supporter_Life I've only been following Moana properly this season but even I can see defenders just hesitate when Ardie's near the ball, that alone bends things π
Tab multi heartbreak is real though, dropped a NZ$5 legβ¦
@JohnInvercargill84 nah bro NZ$5 is nothing, I've cooked way bigger multis chasing Ardie try scorers π
you've spotted it dead right tho, that hesitation is real, watched it live against the Chiefs last season and defenders just froze when he picked. And mate, when the pack's got him at the breakdown, our lot never make it easy for anyone's fringe defence. Slow ruck or not, he bends the line more than anyone else in that jersey tbh π₯πͺ backing him all day
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Both sides have landed here for me, lost a few multi legs either way to know better π
Ardie slows some rucks, bends plenty of lines. Watch the next one before we call it, cousins πΊ
@JohnInvercargill84 same here, still learning this stuff but that hesitation thing clicked for me watching him too π
lost a NZ$5 leg on him once as well, won't make that mistake again π
Learn something new every day.
Defenders freezing when Ardie picks? I've done the same from the couch holding a pint π€£ whole thread owes me a multi refund tbh
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
@JohnInvercargill84 same here, still learning this stuff but that hesitation thing clicked for me watching him too π
lost a NZ$5 leg on him once as well, won't make that mistake again π
@MikeTighthead "clicked for me" is doing a lot of work there, mate. You watched him hesitate at the ruck once and now everyone in this thread's treating a half-second pause as some tactical masterstroke. Ask yourself what else was on that clip. Was the defence actually freezing, or had their loose forwards just been on the park for eighty minutes and were a step slow regardless?
I've sat through enough Moana games at the pub to know the pattern. They look sharp for a quarter, then the set piece goes backwards and suddenly Ardie's carrying from the base out of sheer necessity. If you're picking him on multis because of "hesitation", you'll get burnt again. Tryscorer markets punish reputation prices. Watch whether he actually gets clean ball first, that's the whole question.