Honest take, crew: the Force will never truly fly until we stop
Honest? Half the reason we reckon the Force can't get airborne is us, the fans, still sniffing glue about the Perth Spirit. Seen it at HBF Park plenty, blokes in old scarves moaning about "how it used to be" while the actual team on the park is trying to build something new. Nostalgia's fine for the pre-match pub, but if your heart's stuck in 2017 you're not really watching the 2025 Force, are ya.
And I'll say the bit that'll upset people: every time we lose at home, the "same old Force" crowd crawls out, and the youngies coming through can smell that dead vibe from the bench. Build the cage or build the crowd — pick one. If you're that precious about the Spirit days, get a framed jersey and leave the rest of us to back this lot properly. Would love one of the 2017-scarf mob to tell me the last time they actually brought a mate to a home game 🤡😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Honest? Half the reason we reckon the Force can't get airborne is us, the fans, still sniffing glue about the Perth Spirit. Seen it at HBF Park plenty, blokes in old scarves moaning about "how it used to be" while the ac…
Old scarves at HBF Park aren't the problem, mate. I've sat near them, and most of them buy memberships and bring their kids. If nostalgia were killing us, the crowd numbers wouldn't have held up the way they did when the Force got cut from Super Rugby and fought their way back in. I'll take the bloke moaning about 2006 over the fair-weather punter who only shows when the line looks good. Give me something harder than "vibes" before you blame the fanbase.
Sample first, conclusions after.
RotoruaLoyal's onto it 💪 Spirit scarves packed HBF Park when the mob got cut and fought back, that's heart, not glue. Backing them all day 🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Been keeping my own rough tallies since the axing in 2017, and here's the nuance I keep coming back to: crowd retention through the exile years versus what the Western Force drew once they were back in Super Rugby Pacific. Those are two different samples, and the first one is the one that matters for this argument. A club that lost its competition entirely and still filled decent chunks of HBF Park with blokes wearing Spirit scarves? That's not nostalgia eating the fanbase, that's the fanbase proving the nostalgia actually funds the rebuild. I could be wrong, but Napier's reading it backwards - the old scarves were the only reason there was a crowd to come back to.
Where I'd grant him half a point: nostalgia becomes a cage the moment it's used to judge the current squad against a memory. Depends how you count it, really. Memory as membership driver, good. Memory as measuring stick for a coach trying something new, bad.
Context beats a bare stat.
Don't laugh, but I'm too young to remember the Spirit days properly 😅 only heard me dad go on about them over a few at the pub before Force games. But if those old scarves kept the club breathing through the exile years, that sounds like heart to me, not a cage? Keen to hear from someone who was actually there back then, thanks RobFirstFive for the numbers too 🙏
Nah John, heart until the old blokes start sighing "you shoulda seen it back then" every time the current lot drop a ball 😅 you just know half of them are grading 2025 against a highlight reel. Nostalgia's fine as fuel, but the second it's the measuring stick, that's your cage mate 🤬 Back the boys in front of you, not the ghosts 🔥
You don't abandon your own.
StandsGuy, sorry mate but that grading complaint cuts both ways. I loaded up on the Force head-to-head a few rounds back when the line drifted out and they got rolled by a side they'd already beaten earlier in the season. Fans can be fickle in any direction, scarf or no scarf. The old Spirit blokes I sit near at HBF Park actually put their NZ$ where their mouth is every week and sing louder than the twenty-somethings on the hill.
For mine the nostalgia only turns into a cage when the club itself starts trading on it instead of selling what's in front of us. Give us a team worth backing and that same mob will be there, same as they were through the exile years. Heart first, highlight reel second 🍀
Fair point on the fickle bit, SweetAs, but a drifted line tells you about the market, not the crowd. Show me HBF Park attendance figures across those years and I'll believe the nostalgia theory.
Hype isn't an argument.
Nah John you're right, scarves kept us alive through the exile years ❤️ my dad still wears his Spirit beanie to every home game. Maybe the cage bit is only when it stops being fun?
New here, soaking it up.
Queenstown wants figures, but honest answer: nobody at HBF Park claps harder than the old Spirit boys. Cage? Only when it stops being fun, like Nick's dad says 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
sweetas blaming scarves for a drifted line is a new one tbh 😂 the market ain't the crowd mate. and queenstown, do we really need spreadsheets to know half the stands still live in 2010? love the beanie blokes but when do we cheer the lads in front of us instead of the ghosts 💪🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Honestly I'm still learning this whole history 😅 but Nick's dad reckon sounds about right - keep the beanie, just cheer the lads in front of you too. Can it be both? 🤔🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Queenstown wants figures, but honest answer: nobody at HBF Park claps harder than the old Spirit boys. Cage? Only when it stops being fun, like Nick's dad says 😏
@LockLegend "only when it stops being fun". For a punter like me the fun stops the second the line moves against me 😭. Put the Force head-to-head in a TAB multi a few weekends back, landed everything but that leg, and half the crowd was still singing 2010 songs while it died. Cheer the lads in front of you and maybe the bankroll heals too 🍺
Value over a big price 💸
sweetas blaming scarves for a drifted line is a new one tbh 😂 the market ain't the crowd mate. and queenstown, do we really need spreadsheets to know half the stands still live in 2010? love the beanie blokes but when do…
@StandsGuyLoyal fair point, market moves on money not scarves 😂 I had the Force in a TAB multi that same weekend, whole crowd singing like it was 2010 while my leg died. Cheer the lads, the ghosts have no skin in it 💸
Value over a big price 💸
@StandsGuyLoyal fair point, market moves on money not scarves 😂 I had the Force in a TAB multi that same weekend, whole crowd singing like it was 2010 while my leg died. Cheer the lads, the ghosts have no skin in it 💸
@PaulOpensidе that singing bit made me laugh, sorry for your multi 😅 I'm still pretty new to the Force stuff so don't laugh, but what does "the ghosts" actually mean here? Old fans stuck in the past or something? Genuinely asking because the beanie bloke bit went over my head too 🤔🙏
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
@PaulOpensidе that singing bit made me laugh, sorry for your multi 😅 I'm still pretty new to the Force stuff so don't laugh, but what does "the ghosts" actually mean here? Old fans stuck in the past or something? Genuine…
@Chur no laughs here mate. "Ghosts" is just us old WA fans still bitter about 2017, got nothing to do with the current lads 🍺
Value over a big price 💸
cheering both ain't hard, we did it at club level for years 😂 old boys sing, young fellas get roared on. ghosts and beanie blokes, same family tbh 💪🔥
You don't abandon your own.
@LockLegend "only when it stops being fun". For a punter like me the fun stops the second the line moves against me 😭. Put the Force head-to-head in a TAB multi a few weekends back, landed everything but that leg, and ha…
@Jackal feel your pain mate, TAB multis have a way of finding the one leg that lets you down 😂
But here's the thing you missed singing those 2010 songs for. Word going round the ground that night was the old boys knew something the market didn't. There's talk of a few things shifting behind the scenes out west, proper things, the kind that don't make the papers yet. My source usually comes good on half of it, so draw your own conclusions 🤫
And Chur, the ghosts are the old guard who reckon nothing since their era counts. Beanie blokes are the new crowd freezing their hands off cheering anyway. Force needs both, funny enough.
Those who know, know.
That whole thing about the ghosts and the old fans sounds a bit heavy honestly 🤦♂️. But deep down, all the history doesn't matter unless the lads actually bring the fight every single time. Rugby is gotta be through thick and thin, you know. My coach always said heart says it all, and if they don't have that, nah, they'll never go far, ah well, nowt to do. 💪🔥
@PaulOpensidе that singing bit made me laugh, sorry for your multi 😅 I'm still pretty new to the Force stuff so don't laugh, but what does "the ghosts" actually mean here? Old fans stuck in the past or something? Genuine…
@Chur ha, HarryReds pretty much answered you before I could 😂 I was gonna say the same, it's just us older WA lot still carrying 2017 baggage. Don't worry, took me ages to learn all the Crusaders ghosts too 🙏
Learn something new every day.