Honest take, fam: this Brumbies backline is the best we've had since
Right, my hot take: this backline would give Mortlock's mob from 2004 a genuine run, the young fellas run the ball with more brains than we ever got mid-decade, and I'm stoked to die on that hill. All the nostalgic uncles in here calling it blasphemy, I'll see you at the pub before kickoff, NZ$5 says this lot scores more tries in a season than the golden boys dreamt of 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Chur, took the words outta my mouth 😤 Tramping mate, you watched the same tapes I did?? The way these young fellas hit the line and STILL pass - 2004 crew were warriors but half their spark came from Mortlock barking at everyone 🔥
Heart says it all tbh, I'll take that NZ$5 at the pub, easy punter money 🙌 We're not saying they'd smash them, we're saying it's a genuine contest, and that alone tells you how far this backline's come. Pub before kickoff, first round's on the loser 💪
You don't abandon your own.
I've got my own spreadsheets going back years, and I'll be honest, the comparisons are closer than Tramping thinks. One nuance: 2004 gets romanticised because of the trophy, but if you dig a bit deeper, the backline of then ran through a different defensive era; teams sat flatter and rushed far less. This lot hit the line against far more organised drift defences and still put the pass away. That's the tape bit Queenstown_Mad is on about. Small sample though on the young fellas, I could be wrong, but nothing in the patterns says Mortlock's crew clears them by anything like 20.
I'll take a slice of that NZ$5 at the pub actually, happy to be on the "genuine run" side of the line with you both. First round before kickoff, my shout of the debate 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Rob's spreadsheet talk takes me back - I was in the old stand the night Mortlock lifted that silverware, mate, and nostalgia does funny things to a man's memory. I could be wrong, but half the 2004 glow comes from the result, and the actual tape of that backline would lose a fair few arguments against how these young fellas move the ball now. Keep your NZ$5 warm at the pub; I'll happily dispute it over the first round. 📊
Rob's spreadsheet talk takes me back - I was in the old stand the night Mortlock lifted that silverware, mate, and nostalgia does funny things to a man's memory. I could be wrong, but half the 2004 glow comes from the re…
@Ruck9 fair call, the result definitely does the remembering for some blokes. But even with beer goggles on, that 2004 backline had width and pace nobody else in the comp matched. From a punter's view, nostalgia teams never pay the line, so I'd want this current lot to beat a couple of proper NZ derbies before I'd put money on "best since". Then I'll start believing 💸
Value over a big price 💸
ScrumKiwi you’re talking like you actually watched that 2004 side run through a different era 😱 Rob just said the same thing in fancier words, defendences sat flat and rushed back then, half those Mortlock breaks don’t happen against a modern rush line, no way nah 🔥
And Ruck9, mate, nostalgia IS the whole argument for the old boys, you said it yourself. Heart says take the young fellas, pub says I’m putting my NZ$5 on it, easy punter life 😤 If this lot get half the go-forward of the 2004 crew AND that passing game, it’s over. See you all at kickoff, I’m buying the first round if I’m wrong, ah well, nowt to do 🙌
One love, one side ❤️
Reckon you're all arguing over nothing til the season actually plays out tbh 😅 Old boys remembering 2004 through beer goggles, young fellas hyping blokes who haven't played a proper finals run yet... both camps having a lend of themselves a bit
Me? I just know the chequebook stays shut til I see this backline do it in the wet, away, when the forward pack is on the back foot. THEN I'll buy a round and tell Rob to bring his spreadsheets to the pub for the weigh-in 🍺 NZ$5's already spoken for anyway, ah well, nowt to do but turn up and see who's crying at halftime
In the stands since I was a kid.
ScrumKiwi you’re talking like you actually watched that 2004 side run through a different era 😱 Rob just said the same thing in fancier words, defendences sat flat and rushed back then, half those Mortlock breaks don’t h…
Honestly, those old backlines must have seen some absolute bangers before they were even famous. Debating whether a modern rush line can stop a 2004 Mortlock break is truly peak forum drama, eh? 😂 Meanwhile, I’m just happy to be cheering for the Brumbies, even if we're all running on nostalgia and cheap drinks. 🤣🍿
Only serious one here — barely.
Honestly, those old backlines must have seen some absolute bangers before they were even famous. Debating whether a modern rush line can stop a 2004 Mortlock break is truly peak forum drama, eh? 😂 Meanwhile, I’m just hap…
@JohnBlues drama or not, the line will settle it. I've already thrown a tenner on the Brumbies topping the Aussie conference, long odds but landed before 🔥
Value over a big price 💸