I reckon the traditional Test Match format is fundamentally broken
Five years feels brave, but the appetite's real. The All Blacks v France November Tests still pull big crowds and TV numbers here, yet a punter my age gets more invested in one Super Rugby round than a three-Test series stretched over a month. If a year-round competition with proper stakes ever lands, the old structure won't survive it. My prediction: hybrid first, full replacement by 2030.
I keep my own tables 📊
Nah I'm half with you mate, that French series last time had me glued tbh, three Tests and every single one felt like life or death 🔥
But five years? Doubt it bro. All Blacks Tests are still the biggest thing we've got, whole country stops for them. Problem is the dead weeks in between, you lose the plot by week three. If they can compress it into a proper competition with a ladder and a final, now THAT I'd get behind. Gonna be gutting if the old format dies though, ah well, nowt to do. I'll back the black jersey through thick and thin either way 💪🙌
One love, one side ❤️
Funny thing is, we've been told the Test format's dying since back in my day, and yet here we all are still rearranging our Saturdays around it 😄 I've watched these nights since the amateur era, Eden Park packed to the rafters, and the big ones still stop the country the same way. Young fellas like ClassicGuy have grown up on it too, so I reckon five years is a bold call, the establishment moves slower than that.
Funny thing is, we've been told the Test format's dying since back in my day, and yet here we all are still rearranging our Saturdays around it 😄 I've watched these nights since the amateur era, Eden Park packed to the r…
You're describing habit, SweetAs_Mad, not demand. People stop for the Tests because there's nothing else on the calendar at that hour, and because they always have. Nostalgia from Eden Park rafters doesn't tell me what a 25-year-old punter will watch in 2030. I'll believe the format's safe when attendance and viewing numbers prove it, not when we all keep rearranging Saturdays out of inertia.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Funny thing is, we've been told the Test format's dying since back in my day, and yet here we all are still rearranging our Saturdays around it 😄 I've watched these nights since the amateur era, Eden Park packed to the r…
@SweetAs_Mad agree with most of that, the big ones still stop the country, no argument from me there. Small caveat though: the ones stopping the country are the old rivalries. Some of the midwinter Tests against teams nobody's got a history with, those aren't filling Eden Park like they used to, and I've heard enough grumbling from people inside the game to know it's not just fans whingeing 😏
Word going round is there's been quiet talks about shaking the July window up. Won't say more than that, my source would shoot me, but screenshot this and look back in a couple of years 🤫 What I will say is the format that survives will be the one with meaning attached, not the fixture list on autopilot. RotoruaLoyal's right that the young punter won't watch out of habit like we did.
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Looks like the relegation zone in Test Matches is ridiculously tight; one bad set of games and the gap to safety disappears entirely.
Do the math before you argue.
Reading you all, I'd say the truth sits somewhere in the middle. RotoruaLoyal's got a point about the young lot wanting everything now, but I've seen this "format is dead" talk come round every decade since the amateur days and the All Blacks still stop the nation on a Saturday night. Five years feels keen to me, more like ten before anything truly continuous replaces the Tests, and even then the big occasions will keep their pull somehow. Ah well, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.