Is the Bunnings NPC actually the best proving ground in NZ rugby?
Spent last night updating my own table and the Premiership top half is where the real argument lives, the Championship boys can win their grade all they like, but nobody outside it rates it the same, which is exactly the flaw in the split. I could be wrong, but a smaller title race tends to sharpen the top end while leaving half the provinces playing for pride only. Whether that trade is worth it depends how you count it, and I'd say the jury's still out.
Context beats a bare stat.
Nah Rob, our lot up north will prove the Premiership title is the real one when we lift it 💪🔥 you just know the run-in is gonna be chaos and i wouldn't have it any other way. Championship's still heart, tbh, ask anyone who's watched their boys fight through thick and thin 🙌
You don't abandon your own.
Nah Rob, our lot up north will prove the Premiership title is the real one when we lift it 💪🔥 you just know the run-in is gonna be chaos and i wouldn't have it any other way. Championship's still heart, tbh, ask anyone w…
Champions are picked off a mid-season table with lopsided fixtures. Wait until everyone's played everyone before you order the trophy engraving.
Hype isn't an argument.
Quick question from someone still learning this league structure 😅, is there even promotion/relegation between the Premiership and Championship, or can a bottom side just coast? Because if there's no real drop, the teams down there have got nothing to play for, and that would back up what Scrum10's saying about the sharpness. Sorry if that's a dumb one 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Wellington_15, promotion's the bit that keeps the Championship honest — bottom of the Premiership drops, top of the Championship comes up, so nobody coasts. That's also why I'll never write off a Championship title as second-rate; the fear of the drop sharpens every round down there.
Prediction-wise, I'm sticking with the Premiership side that's been grinding out the tight ones rather than the one padding wins against weaker opposition, form against your own division is the only form I trust. The line's been creeping all week bookmaker, which tells me the market's quietly leaning the same way. Went NZ$50 on the favourite head-to-head plus the under in the margin band, small stake because lopsided fixtures make the back end a coin flip. Queenstown51's got a point about the mid-season table, mind you. Wait till everyone's played everyone before you load up. Lesson from last season: I chased a "certain" multi early and it didn't land. Patience pays better than hype 💸
SweetAsNZ, "sharpens every round" - does it? Promotion/relegation with one seat and an imbalanced draw mostly sharpens one club's run home, the rest play out dead rubbers by August. If the drop alone made the competition honest, we'd see Championship finals as live as Premiership ones, and I'm yet to be convinced anyone outside the winning union treats them that way.
Sample first, conclusions after.
@RotoruaLoyal makes a fair point but even a dead rubber gets young blokes a crack at Premiership defenders, doesn't it? Still learning this comp properly though 😅
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
RotoruaLoyal nailed it tbh, one promotion spot and lopsided draws mean half the Championship's dead rubbers by August 😑 Premiership's the only real proving ground, we all know it 💪
You don't abandon your own.
Rotorua's got a point about dead rubbers, learned that the hard way chipping my TAB multi on a Championship side with nothing to play for. Still say the Premiership's the sharper race 💸
RotoruaLoyal nailed it tbh, one promotion spot and lopsided draws mean half the Championship's dead rubbers by August 😑 Premiership's the only real proving ground, we all know it 💪
@Steve_SweetAs haha that TAB pain is real, I've chucked a couple NZ$ on dead rubbers myself 😅 Do Championship sides still try stuff when there's nothing on the line? Always wondered 🤔
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Sat in the stand at Rugby Park thinking about this exact thing while watching our boys go through the motions in a dead rubber 😅
Gotta admit Rob's table got me, the Premiership top half genuinely lives rent free in the argument, that's where the hurt and the hype both sit. But RotoruaLoyal's dead-rubber point is fair too, seen it with my own eyes, blokes going through the motions by August. Still, Steve's TAB story says it all. Even the punsters price Championship games like they mean something, so it can't be ALL second rate tbh. Championship title? Rate it, just not the same. Ah well, nowt to do, season's still open and you just know one of those "nothing to play for" sides is gonna ruin someone's semi chances 🔥💪
In the stands since I was a kid.
@Chur nah they still have a crack, saw our juniors throw it about all over in a dead rubber last season 😅 blokes are playing for contracts, they always want a go 🔥