McLean Park on a cold Napier night beats any big-city stadium
Every time some Auckland media type whinges about Eden Park crowds I have a quiet laugh. Took my old man to McLean Park in July a few years back, wind coming straight off the Bay, and the visitors' fullback looked like he wanted to cry every time he copped a spiral ball. That's rugby. Plastic bowl in Auckland can put up a roof and a big screen, it'll never bottle that.
You can keep your Sky Stadium catering and your 4,000 empty seats. Give me a pub on Emerson Street full of Bay boys, three coats and a pie, and 20 grand of us roaring into the gale. Honestly, anyone who'd trade that for a glass-sided city bowl needs their head read 😏
Any stat can be bent.
Beautiful story, but one fullback having a sook isn't data. Bring some receipts on crowd figures or results before we crown McLean Park the mecca of rugby.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Zoe, receipts? Mate, you just know when the wind's up and the visitors stop chasing their own kicks, the game's already won 😱🔥 I stood on the embankment freezing me ears off and I wouldn't trade it for any plastic seat in Auckland. Through thick and thin, that's McLean Park baby 🙌
In the stands since I was a kid.
Zoe asking for receipts is fair, though I'll say upfront I don't have crowd figures or a results table for McLean Park night games on hand, so I won't invent any. Small sample though, and that's sort of the point. The games I keep notes on from my own spreadsheet are the ones where the wind off the Bay was up, and the pattern in those is behavioural: visiting teams stop contesting their own crossfield kicks once they've shanked two or three into the stands. That's observable without a stat sheet.
What I can say is what Tryline described from the embankment is exactly why away sides quietly hate the trip. You can prep for a plastic bowl in Auckland, same conditions every week, roof optional. You can't prep for a boundary that changes every twenty minutes. Until someone digs up the actual figures I'd soften the "mecca" claim, but the argument about conditions never needed numbers in the first place.
Numbers > vibes.
Zoe, love, no receipts from me either, but I've been watching Test footy since before the pros came along and McLean Park on a proper Napier winter night never needed a spreadsheet 😄 Seen visiting sides down the years just boot it long and stop chasing once that wind off the Bay got hold of things. You couldn't buy that at a plastic bowl for all the seats in Auckland.
I keep a table for nearly everything and even I'll admit the wind nights resist the spreadsheet, because how do you quantify a fullback refusing to chase? Zoe's right that a few sooks aren't data, I could be wrong, but you'd want to count the dropped crossfield kicks per hour of that southerly before anyone talks me out of the embankment. Eden Park can keep its tests and its roof-adjacent calm, some arguments don't need closing.
Context beats a bare stat.
I keep a table for nearly everything and even I'll admit the wind nights resist the spreadsheet, because how do you quantify a fullback refusing to chase? Zoe's right that a few sooks aren't data, I could be wrong, but y…
@RobFirstFive spot on mate, you can't put "fullback standing there watching it sail dead" in a column 😂
I coached the juniors down at the Park one frosty Tuesday and even the kids' kicks were getting held up, give you an idea how that wind works. First proper winter night game I remember standing on the embankment I lost feeling in me toes by halftime and still reckon it was the best night out going. Opposing kickers just stop playing... you see it in their eyes 🔥💪
In the stands since I was a kid.