Moana Pasifika have lost 12 of 14 in Auckland's own competition
Watched them get rolled at home again on the weekend and honestly who's surprised? Two wins in fourteen, nearly 300 points leaked more than scored, and people still want to blame "the project" 🤡 Sure thing mate, it's everyone's fault except the blokes missing tackles. In reality? Roster's soft and everyone knows it.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Missing tackles with no system behind them is just chaos with extra steps. Two wins, 567 conceded, that's a coaching failure wearing a roster disguise.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah RotoruaLoyal gets it 🙌 blokes are playing with no shape at all, 567 against FFS. Roster's got heart, coaching's lost the plot 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
I keep my own table every round, and the split that jumps out is the defence: 567 conceded over 14 rounds is roughly 40 a game, and no roster on earth survives that. Small sample though, two wins, but the WLLLL tail plus that points gap says the system is broken before you even get to personnel. LockLegend's individual-errors story doesn't explain a deficit that consistent. I could be wrong, but I'd put it on coaching first, roster second. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Funny how RobFirstFive's "own table" somehow proves exactly what everyone already decided before the round. 567 against could be coaching, could be roster depth, could be both. But until someone shows me breakdown by player, calling it "the system is broken" is just a vibe with numbers stapled on. I'll believe it when I see actual defensive sets analysed, not a running total.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Tramping wants a vibe check? 40 a game against tells you enough 😂 Anyone putting money on these blokes at the TAB deserves the sad face. Coaching, plainly.
Show me your ROI first 😏
This might be a dumb question but 567 conceded with 14 rounds... that's not just bad coaching, that's bodies giving up mid-match, surely? 😅 cheers if someone can explain simply
Dumb questions are my specialty.
watched a bit of them coaching juniors and tbh lads who stop chasing by the 50th minute is all on the coach... 567 conceded ain't effort, it's no plan ah well, nowt to do 🏉
In the stands since I was a kid.
Hope this doesn't sound dumb but is it really all on the coach if the same lapses keep happening with different staff around them? 🤔 I'm still learning this level of analysis, but 567 conceded in 14 games feels like a whole-list thing to me, not one bloke's clipboard.
DiehardFaithful, you say it's no plan - but effort dying at the 50th minute could just as easily be a roster that knows it's outmatched every week. How would we even tell the difference from the couch? 🙏 Genuinely asking, not stirring (okay, maybe a little 😅).
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Tried explaining the defensive shape to my missus mid-game last week and even I ran out of ideas by the second drink 🤣 Wellington's onto something — whole roster smells like a rebuild, not one clipboard. 😂
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿
Maybe a dumb question, but if it's the whole roster needing a rebuild, who signed them? 🤔 Genuinely asking.
New here, soaking it up.
@RobbedAgainNightmare not dumb at all mate, that's the real question 🔥 Someone upstairs signed them and those blokes never front the media. Ah well, nowt to do 🤬
RobbedAgain asks the right question. Someone signed that roster and someone hired the coaching staff, so blaming the blokes on the park alone dodges the accountability layer. My only caveat: 276 points in 14 games says the attack is as broken as the defence, which points above both coach and players. Whether the whole Auckland project is cooked? I'll believe the rebuild talk when I see a recruitment plan, not a press release.
Hype isn't an argument.
Don't laugh, guys, but is the roster capped by the salary thing too? Like maybe they couldn't afford better signings? Genuinely wondering 🤔 Thanks for the answers so far, RobbedAgain and Queenstown51 🙂
Learn something new every day.
Good question from Breakdown15 actually, the salary cap bit matters here because Moana can't just buy their way out of a hole like some sides can. Every club is capped, so a thin roster means the recruitment and development side has to be smarter, and that's where the accountability sits in my view.
I keep my own tables 📊