Moana Pasifika's heart is our superpower
Heart's carried us all season but mana doesn't defend a ten-point lead with eight minutes left π Anyone who backed us on the line at Mt Smart knew exactly how that last quarter was going to fold. I did, and my wallet's still crying. When do we actually learn to kill a game off, or is closing out tight ones just a lottery for us now? π€‘πΈ
Show me your ROI first π
Backing us on the line and then crying about it? That's on you, mate. One blown last quarter isn't a pattern, show me it happening repeatedly before writing off the squad.
Hype isn't an argument.
Queenstown51's got a point, one bad quarter doesn't mean a crisis π€ How many tight ones have our boys closed out this season? Exactly. Heart gets us to the hill, finishing's just the next lesson πͺπ
Heart with the team, head on pause.
I keep my own table every round, so I went back through it before joining this argument. Small sample though, the honest answer is that Queenstown51 and StandsGuyLoyal are both half right. We've been competitive in most tight finishes this season, which is genuinely new for this club, but the Mt Smart one stings precisely because we led by ten with eight to go and still lost by three. That's a closing-out failure, and once is a lesson, twice is a trend.
Where I'd push back on the provocateur: mana isn't the variable failing us, game management is - substitutions, territory off the kickoff, who takes the ball into the corner. I could be wrong, but fixing the last quarter is a coaching problem far more than a heart problem. I'd rather back us to learn it by finals time than write the squad off after one fold. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Back in my day we weren't even in the comp, we were just hoping Moana Pasifika would get a team at all, so honestly every tight loss still beats the years of nothing π€£ But I do remember watching us blow close ones before, and Queenstown51's "one bad quarter" take is getting a bit generous, eh. Feels like we've seen this movie, I just can't remember how it ended. Spoiler: badly π
Still, mate, that Mt Smart heart in the first 70 minutes? Worth the ticket price every time. RobFirstFive's table probably says it proper, but my gut says the last ten minutes are where we keep donating games. Fix that and I might even win a multi for once πΏ
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
JohnNapier1976, fair point about the years of nothing, but nostalgia's doing a lot of heavy lifting there. What I actually noticed at Mt Smart wasn't one blown quarter, it was the same shape as earlier tight games: we stop playing when we're ahead, kill the tempo, kick possession away, and then act surprised when the other side comes back at us. That's a habit, and habits repeat.
So Queenstown51, you're right that one quarter isn't proof. But watch the last ten minutes of our close games again and tell me the pattern isn't there. Heart gets us into the fight; game management is what we keep failing at. I'll believe we've learned it when I see us hold the ball for a full set with the clock ticking, not before.
Sample first, conclusions after.
RotoruaLoyal is spot on about the tempo dying when we're in front. That's exactly where my TAB ticket went to die at Mt Smart, had us on the line and it landed for everyone but me π Only caveat I'd add is the bench: we seem to make changes around the 60th and lose all shape, which kills the game management more than any lack of heart. Until the coach fixes that closing combo, I'm done loading up on us in tight ones. πΈ
SweetAsNZ nails it with the bench comment. We get comfy at 60' and start celebrating before the whistle π Mana's lovely but you still gotta play the last ten, mates. π€‘πΈ
Show me your ROI first π
Honestly everyone's acting like this is some big mystery when the blokes on the park ran out of legs, not heart. Bench at 60' loses shape? Nah, the bench is there cos the starters are rooted by then... we've been chasing carries all game and there's nothing left for the last ten. Blaming the subs is having a laugh tbh π
And SweetAsNZ, sorry about the TAB ticket mate but if you're putting money on us closing out a tight one you already knew the risk π Yeah nah, we do go quiet when we're in front, I'll give you that. But one tight quarter at Mt Smart doesn't make us chokers... ah well, nowt to do, big derby coming and I'll still be there πΌπΈπ₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
Diehard, legs don't forget how to hold a ball π
We made soft errors with fresh blokes on, that's a game-management thing, cheers for the debate though π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
@SteveAuckland soft errors from fresh legs? word going round the conditioning block was never rebuilt properly over summer, take that how you want π€« a source close to training reckons the last ten issues run deeper than the bench card. those who know, know.
Word isβ¦ but you didn't hear it here π€«
@SteveAuckland soft errors from fresh legs? word going round the conditioning block was never rebuilt properly over summer, take that how you want π€« a source close to training reckons the last ten issues run deeper than β¦
@Invercargill_NZ that sounds a bit iffy honestly, some mate of a mate reckons stuff π
but if true, would explain soft hands on tired bodies. Anyone got actual proof or just word going round?
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
@Invercargill_NZ mate of a mate sources are worth nothing tbh π
every club has "conditioning dramas" gossip every preseason. Show me tired blokes dropping cold ball in the last ten and I'll believe the legs story πͺ
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Fair points both ends of this one. I've paid the TAB enough to know the last ten minutes are where tickets die. Lost count of my multis that landed everywhere else and folded at Mt Smart. But I keep flip-flopping between blaming the 60' bench shuffle and blokes simply running on empty. Until we actually close one out with ten to go, nobody here can prove which it is. Next tight finish sorts the argument out πΊ
Bankroll discipline wins.