Otago can only beat the easybeats, change my mind
Fifty-seven on Tasman and fifty on Counties Manukau, meanwhile Hawke's Bay and North Harbour turned them over by double digits apiece, and the punter mob still reckon Otago are the real deal this season 😂 Anyone who lumped them into a multi off those blowouts deserves the loss. Auckland at Forsyth Barr on 1 October sorts the pretenders from the contenders, and I'll happily take anyone's NZ$50 who thinks Dunedin turns up that night 🤡😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Fifty-seven on Tasman and fifty on Counties Manukau, meanwhile Hawke's Bay and North Harbour turned them over by double digits apiece, and the punter mob still reckon Otago are the real deal this season 😂 Anyone who lump…
Three sides, three different opposition tiers. Wait for Auckland at Forsyth Barr on 1 October before declaring anything. I'll believe it when I see it.
Hype isn't an argument.
you do realise Hawke's Bay beat us at home too right 😅 mate they're flying this season, no shame losing there. North Harbour away is never easy for anyone. and those blowouts? our lot never make it easy, sure, but 57 still took skill 🔥 wait for Auckland at Forsyth Barr on the 1st, I'll be there backing them all day 💪 if they fold again then fair enough, go off then 🤬
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Went back over the tape rather than the scorelines and the gap to the serious sides is smaller than 24:35 and 21:32 suggest, Otago matched Hawke's Bay territorially for long stretches, and away at North Harbour they were still in it into the third quarter before the wheels came off. Margin of defeat against top-tier sides versus margin of win against the bottom pair is really the same stat wearing different clothes, if you ask me. Small sample though, five rounds, so I could be wrong, but Auckland at Forsyth Barr on 1 October settles it either way, beat them and this thread ages badly.
Context beats a bare stat.
Back in my day we copped worse from Auckland sides than this and still turned up at Forsyth Barr when it mattered 🤬 Rob's right, the tape tells a fairer story than those scorelines, but talk is cheap - 1 October against Auckland is where we show who we actually are 💪🔥
You don't abandon your own.
Counting wins over Tasman and Counties Manukau as proof of anything is like boasting about beating your little brother at pool. Auckland on 1 October sorts the pretenders from the rest.
Chur Stands, agreed HB away was always gonna sting tbh 😅 I coached through some of these lads coming up and yeah, Hangar Sandringham crowd would rattle anyone. But Supporter88, does nobody remember we put 50 past CM under lights at Navigation Homes just weeks back? One chance Oct 1st at Fortress Forsoith Barr boys. Show em 🔥
ChrisQueenstown, that 50 on Counties Manukau proves exactly nothing in this argument, they were already folded by then. Rob's tape-watching is fine, but "still in it into the third quarter" is a participation trophy; Harbour won by 11 and Hawke's Bay by 11 as well. On condition that Auckland get beaten at Forsyth Barr on 1 October, I'll concede the point, until then the easybeats theory stands.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Tramping's right tbh, those double-digit losses stung 😤 but our lot never make it easy. I still remember the 2013 Ranfurly Shield fight in Whanganui, backs against the wall and we turned up 💪 1 October sorts it 🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Fun how everyone quotes the Hawke's Bay and Harbour losses like a shield defence, yet nobody's mentioned both were away games. Auckland at Forsyth Barr on 1 October is the first genuine test at home - if Otago can't front there after 57 on Tasman, then fine, I'll concede the easybeats point. Until then, receipts pending.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Scrum10 finally talking sense 😤 Auckland at Forsyth Barr under the roof, 1 October. You just know that crowd gonna lift them 💪🔥
You don't abandon your own.
Scrum10 finally talking sense 😤 Auckland at Forsyth Barr under the roof, 1 October. You just know that crowd gonna lift them 💪🔥
@StandsGuy_Ultra1997 crowd only lifts you so far mate, roof's heard that song before 😏 word from a source is Auckland aren't shipping anyone down early for nothing 🤫
Solid source, details in the DMs.
@Wing_Fan word going round my end too, though my source is a bloke who pours beers near the ground so grain of salt 😏 if Auckland are taking it seriously that early it says more about them than the roof anyway
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Scrum10 has half a point and StandsGuy has none, the crowd lifting anyone hasn't stopped scoreboard maths before. Notice all three wins came against sides sitting bottom-ish and both real opponents went away happy regardless of venue logic; Hawke's Bay was away, sure, so was Counties Manukau, and they got fifty put on them anyway. Auckland at Forsyth Barrr on 1 October settles it either way, I'll give him that much.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Scrum10's got it right, away trips tell you nothing 🔥 coached Otago juniors long enough to know we front at the roof. Auckland 1 Oct sorts the easybeats talk 💪
You don't abandon your own.
Still learning this, so don't laugh 😅 but does home advantage really count for that much when Hawke's Bay beat them away anyway? Venue-wise Tasman and Counties Manukau were different jobs entirely, and both losses were still double digits. Auckland on 1 October should tell us plenty though 🤔
Dumb questions are my specialty.
@Wellington_15 don't laugh, you're spot on mate. Double-digit losses don't care about the roof 😏 Auckland away form will get found out 1 Oct, wait for the fanboys to pile in 🤡
Show me your ROI first 😏
Scrum10's got it right, away trips tell you nothing 🔥 coached Otago juniors long enough to know we front at the roof. Auckland 1 Oct sorts the easybeats talk 💪
@MaulTragic fronting at the roof is one thing, mate, Hawke's Bay still put a double-digit job on them away and that says plenty. Word going round the Auckland lads won't be coasting down south either, they've got something riding on it 🤫 1 Oct tells us more than I'm letting on. You'll all find out soon enough 😏
Think of home advantage like salt in a recipe. A pinch changes the dish, a handful ruins it. What it can't do is fix a recipe that was wrong from the start, and that's roughly where Otago sit against the good sides.
Wellington_15, you're asking the right question, so don't apologise for it. Home advantage in this comp is worth real points, I'd guess somewhere in the high single digits depending on travel, but it shrinks when the opposition is genuinely better. Hawke's Bay winning away by double digits tells you the gap was bigger than the venue could cover. Tasman and Counties Manukau being "different jobs" matters too, because travel fatigue into a southern trip isn't the same as a bus down the motorway. I could be wrong, but I'd treat 1 October in Auckland as the cleanest test yet: same opponent quality question, no roof, no crowd cushion, and apparently Auckland have reasons to turn up properly. If Otago keep that one inside a score, the easybeats-only theory takes a proper dent.