Right, lads. Who do we beg Clayton to sign at loosehead before we
Watched the Waikato Stadium scrum from the pub and nearly chucked my drink at the screen, we got folded back like a cheap deck chair every time they had a put-in. One proper Tighthead-prop-buster on the loosehead side and the whole forward pack changes shape, no exaggeration.
Word is Clayton's already been sniffing around someone in the NPC ranks. Heard a bloke at work (shearing sheds hear everything, believe me) say a big name's off contract and the chats are further along than anyone admits. No names from me yet, don't want to burn my source before it lands. And in reality? If we wait till injuries bite again, we'll be begging mid-season like last year. Anyone else heard anything, or do I just trust my guy and start printing the jersey? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Folded back like a deck chair - every scrum thread on here ends with that line and one magic signing, and yet we said the same about the hooker spot two seasons ago. Funny how the shopping trolley only rolls backwards when the bench is empty in the last twenty, eh.
I'll believe the loosehead messiah exists when I see him in a Chiefs jersey, not in a rumour. One prop doesn't fix a scrum where the binding and timing fall over by the second derby of the season. Clayton can sign whoever you lot chant for at the pub, until someone shows me the actual scrum stats against the Crusaders and Brumbies pack, I'm calling it wishful thinking with a pint in hand. Source on the Tighthead-buster part, by the way? I've watched the footage twice and I saw eight blokes losing shape, not one weak link.
Hype isn't an argument.
Queenstown51's got a point re the bench but nah, one proper scrummager starting changes everything 😤 we just know what happens when our pack gets front foot... ah well, nowt to do, sign someone Clayton! 🏉
In the stands since I was a kid.
Been keeping my own scrum tally this season and the pattern is real: we lose the most ground in the last quarter, which actually backs up Queenstown51's bench point. I could be wrong, but starting prop vs finishing prop are two different problems and we've been treating them as one.
On the transfer itself. Temper expectations a bit. A proven Tighthead-buster loosehead in his prime is the scarcest position on the market, and anyone decent is either locked up long-term or commands silly money we can't justify under the cap. Realistically we're looking at a mid-twenties project with good raw scrummaging numbers, small sample though it may be, plus a veteran finisher off the bench. Depends how you count it, but that combo probably fixes 70% of the shopping trolley problem without breaking the bank. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
RobFirstFive's tally sounds like the first useful thing in this thread - I'll believe it when I see the actual numbers, mind, but the split between starter and finisher rings true from my seat at Waikato. My caveat: we signed a "proper scrummager" three years back and he spent half the season in the physio room, so Clayton can beg whoever he likes, the fitness record matters more than the name. Happy to be wrong on condition that the bloke can actually scrum for 80 minutes, not 40.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Rob's split makes sense to me tbh, but even a fresh starter means nothing if he's gassed by minute 60 🔥 sign TWO lads Clayton, one to start one to finish, simples 💪
You don't abandon your own.
Nah Queenstown, TWO props? Clayton's wallet won't stretch that far 😅 get one proper buster first, worry about the finisher later 💪
Heart with the team, head on pause.
We've been burned before lads. Remember the big overseas prop rumour two seasons back? Contract signed elsewhere a week later. Sign who you like on paper, time will tell 😭💸
Value over a big price 💸
Chur, honestly the difference is simple enough: your starter scrums against their best tight-head fresh, your finisher comes on when everyone's rooted and just needs to hold the ship. Different jobs, different bodies.
On the two-props idea, FanaticUltra's probably right about the wallet, but I'd argue the finisher is where you get value over a big price, blokes like that come cheaper and often deliver more minutes than the marquee name. And Paul's burned-before point is fair, though if we're talking odds here I still rate the Chiefs' scrum futures as worth a punt once the signing lands. Loaded up on them plenty of seasons, can't stop now 🍺
Value over a big price 💸
Gidday Chur, Cantab nailed it tbh 😅 I propped till my knees gave out, trust me the last 15 minutes at loosehead is pure survival, scrums turn into a warzone. FanaticUltra's right tho, get ONE proper starter first, we've been crying out for a buster for ages 🤬 Paul's got me spooked tho, been burned too many times lads 💸
Paul's got a point, we've all seen how those "done deal" props turn out 😏 heard word going round about a certain name doing the rounds down at the pub though, those who know, know 🤫 wallet stretching is Clayton's problem, scrumholding is mine to worry about
Solid source, details in the DMs.
The last 15 minutes thing makes sense to me now, never thought about scrums turning into a warzone late on 😅 maybe I'm wrong but surely you just want someone young and keen who can learn off the older boys, rather than a big-name signing? What does a loosehead actually need to be good at apart from the scrum? 🤔
New here, soaking it up.
Gidday Chur, Cantab nailed it tbh 😅 I propped till my knees gave out, trust me the last 15 minutes at loosehead is pure survival, scrums turn into a warzone. FanaticUltra's right tho, get ONE proper starter first, we've …
@Nick_Tauranga nah young fellas get folded like a deck chair in a late scrum, learned that the hard way 😂 keen is good, but keen doesn't hold a maul 🤣
Hold my pint.
@Nick_Tauranga nah young fellas get folded like a deck chair in a late scrum, learned that the hard way 😂 keen is good, but keen doesn't hold a maul 🤣
@Jess23 spot on tbh 😂 coached a young prop last season, first 15 mins he was keen as, by the 70th he was folded like laundry 💪 need a hardened head tbh
Heart with the team, head on pause.