Right, lads, who do we bribe to get a proper enforcer at openside
Heard from a bloke at the pub last night that there's a bit of whisper about Swinton possibly being squeezed out over east, and apparently we've still got roughly NZ$400k sitting spare under the cap. Half the joint reckons he'd fill Hooper's old spot with some proper mongrel. Sure thing, mate, but what happens the first time he punches someone and costs us a penalty in the last five? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
A pub whisper and a round figure that suspiciously rounds to a headline number - LockLegend, I'll believe it when I see it on an official contract page. Swinton's manager would have a queue of suitors if he were genuinely squeezed out, so where's the source? Get me a name or a photo of the paperwork and I'll happily eat my words.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Screw the source, imagine the bloke hitting rucks like a wrecking ball next to our backrow 🔥 we've been soft at the breakdown for ages and everyone knows it. 400k NZ$ buys you exactly one enforcer and I'd rather spend it on mongrel than another tidy ball-runner. RotoruaLoyal, mate, let me dream till the contract page says otherwise 😤
I keep my own little table on these things, so let me put a few rows under the Swinton idea. He's what, 29 now? For an openside that's fine, but the wrecking-ball version of him was always a blindside/lock type, he's played bugger all genuine 7. You'd be buying mongrel and hoping it converts to breakdown craft, and the tape says the conversion rate there is poor. The NZ$400k figure is also doing a lot of heavy lifting: cap space that rounds that neatly usually comes with a second-tier contract attached somewhere.
I could be wrong, but I'd reckon if he's genuinely squeezed out over east, Waratahs-adjacent clubs and a Japanese deal both beat us on money, so we'd need him to want Brumbies footy specifically. Small sample though. One pub whisper. If he were three years younger I'd be at the front of the queue with you, ChrisQueenstown. Right now? I'd rather see that cap space kept dry for a proper 7 who actually contests at the ruck. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Bloke played his best footy with a bit of chaos around him, that's the whole point 🔥 sign him and let him loose, worry about the number 7 pedigree later mate 💪
Heart with the team, head on pause.
@FanaticUltra chaos worked for him up north, word going round a couple of clubs quietly tested the waters already 🤫 whether the cap stretches that far, that's another story eh
Those who know, know.
@FanaticUltra chaos worked for him up north, word going round a couple of clubs quietly tested the waters already 🤫 whether the cap stretches that far, that's another story eh
@FullbackMate the cap part is what worries me too eh. Don't laugh but I barely understand how the cap works yet 😅 so if a couple of clubs tested the waters, does that mean his price only goes up from here? Feels like we'd be paying overs for mongrel 🤔
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
@FanaticUltra chaos worked for him up north, word going round a couple of clubs quietly tested the waters already 🤫 whether the cap stretches that far, that's another story eh
@FullbackMate depends how you count it, but every club "testing the waters" doesn't automatically mean the price balloons. Most of that quiet contact is clubs checking whether the player is even gettable before anyone talks money. Two nos and one maybe doesn't create an auction.
The cap question is the real one though. If he's been on decent coin up north and we're already tight in the back row, we'd be paying a premium for a name rather than mongrel. I'd rather see the Brumbies find a young bloke on a development deal who plays angry for nothing. Swinton at the right number, sure. Swinton at overs because two clubs rang his manager? That's how you end up with a squad lopsided for three years. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
That makes sense, @NickBreakdown1982. So those quiet chats are just them checking if the player is even gettable first, I guess? 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
One yellow card beats getting rolled at every ruck all season tbh 😤 we've been crying out for mongrel for years, when's that ever won us a game?
You don't abandon your own.
SweetAs mate you weren't here when we all swore the last "done deal" signing was locked in either 😏 heard that whisper months before it died quietly. Swinton talk's been circling for a while now, take it with a grain of salt. Time will tell, you'll all find out soon enough 🤫
Solid source, details in the DMs.
@ChrisFullback ah that explains a bit, don't laugh but I'm new here 😅 so "done deal" whispers can die quietly? Thanks, I'll hold my excitement then 🙏
@FullbackMate depends how you count it, but every club "testing the waters" doesn't automatically mean the price balloons. Most of that quiet contact is clubs checking whether the player is even gettable before anyone ta…
@NickBreakdown1982 this is why I don't panic at "tested the waters" whispers 😂 two nos and a maybe, sounds like my dating life tbh 🤣