Right, lads. Who do we want wearing the No. 10 jersey after the next
Word is there's a young running first five down Southland way getting a look-in at the next camp, take that with a grain of salt though mate. If even half of it's true I'd happily shout the first round at the pub 🍻 Reckon we've carked it long enough with the safe options, give the kid a go I say 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Source on that? I'll believe it when I see it.
Hype isn't an argument.
Maaaate if theres even a whiff of truth in that Southland rumour I'm losing it 🔥🔥 imagine a genuine running first five again, someone who takes the line on instead of pumping the ball to touch every time we're inside their 22 😱 been begging for that for years tbh
You just know we'll find a way to make it hard on the kid though, our lot never make it easy. Chuck him on for 20 off the bench somewhere, see if he has the stones. If he fronts up I'll drive the van straight to that pub and the first shout's on me, Glory's word is bond and mine too 🍻💪
You don't abandon your own.
I always look at squad selection like calculating the variance on a complex financial instrument. You start with a set of known, reliable data points, and then you introduce an element of volatility. That Southland rumour, while exciting because it represents injecting some real dynamism into the attack, needs a bit more scrutiny before we start placing bets on it.
The desire for a first five that commits to the run, rather than purely recycling ball, is tactically sound. We’ve seen how much quicker the points come when the distribution isn't dictated solely by continuity. However, bringing in any specialist at the All Blacks level requires assessing the total systemic fit. The transition from a domestic environment to the international setup is a huge operational jump. We need to see the evidence of consistency, not just raw speed.
Context beats a bare stat.
Nick, that variance metaphor falls apart the moment the "known data points" are a kid with four Super starts. Portfolio maths needs a sample size, and we don't have one. I'm with Queenstown51, receipts please before anyone shouts a round. That said, if the Southland rumour's real I'll happily eat my words and my round too.
Sample first, conclusions after.
have you ever noticed how the buzz around a new promising talent always seems to be peaking right before they disappear for two years? Seems like we hear these sort of hopeful rumours come around almost every pre-tour, regardless of which part of the country the young ones are playing for. they all just get swept up in the wider development structures for a bit. time will tell if any of this Southland talk actually sticks.
Zoe's right about the sample size, four Super starts is a coin flip at best and I've lost enough NZ$ on coin flips to know. SweetAs_Mad has a point too, every pre-tour some kid gets talked up and by round six you're wondering where he went.
That said, if there's real smoke on the Southland thing I'd happily eat a losing multi to see a 10 actually run it. Touch-finders inside the 22 have cost us more tests than any bad line call. Show me the receipts first though, I don't put my bankroll on rumours 🔥