Right, lads, who's our dream lock to partner Tupou Vaa'i
Word is a certain big Canterbury lock's management has been sniffing around, and word is we've got actual NZ$ space in the cap to make it happen. Sure thing, mate, second row sorted till the end of days alongside Vaa'i. And in reality? Probably pub talk from the same bloke who reckons we're signing Beauden every off-season 😏
Still, name your wishlist lads. Anyone got a lock or centre they'd chuck the money at? Punters of the thread, was your TAB multi the one thing that lost on the Brumbies game, or just mine? 😂
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Sniffing around, aye? And whose word is that, exactly, your mate's cousin at the pub? Every transfer window some Canterbury lad is "available" and somehow nobody ever signs. I'll believe it when I see actual NZ$ cap figures with a source on that, otherwise it's just pub talk we're building a second row on.
Hype isn't an argument.
😂 imagine Vaa'i with a proper second row alongside him, we've been crying out for a lineout enforcer for years. Reminds me of crying into my pint after that semi a few seasons back, no punch in the tight five. If there's real NZ$ cap space then go HARD, they'd be scary 🔥💪 backing them all day tbh
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Kept my own little table on this over a few pints last night, so bear with me 📊 The catch with any big Canterbury lock is sample size: one strong NPC campaign tells you far less than people assume, and I could be wrong, but the last three second-rowers we poached south were all 25-plus on arrival, by the time they settled into our system you were counting down their contract, not building on it. If the lad in question is early twenties and genuinely stuck behind a logjam of All Blacks locks in red and black, then the cap maths actually stack up for us; pay a bit over for a four or five-year window and Vaa'i gets a proper partner through his prime years. If he's nearer the wrong side of 26, I'd rather we spent the NZ$ on a lineout caller already bedded in elsewhere. Small sample though, and half the pub rumours never even make it to the table. LockLegend, name the player, then we'll argue properly at the local before the Hamilton fixture.
Context beats a bare stat.
Watched the big fella dominate the lineout at the NPC semi live, and honest to god he was the best forward on the park that night, Canterbury won practically everything off his throw. Mate of mine who's around the club reckons he's keen to stay in NZ too, which says a lot with the overseas coin floating about. Anyway Rob, remind me of your ROI on that little table of yours before you start lecturing us on sample size 😏 pints at the local before the next home fixture, first round's on whoever calls the lineout calls right.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Napier, fair enough on the semi, one live sighting carries more weight than a pub rumour, I'll give you that. My caveat stands though: one monster night at the lineout is a good evening, a career of them is a signing. I sat through enough of our tight five going soft in Hamilton to want proof across a full season before anyone spends the cap space. Show me that, and I'll believe it when I see it.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Keen as 🔥 coached juniors long enough to know - a lad who owns a lineout in the NPC has actual mongrel, and you can't teach that. Sign him, coach him, done 💪
You don't abandon your own.
Heard this exact pub whisper about a Canterbury lad a couple of seasons back too, and that went quiet sharpish 🤫 The source won't hold. Time will tell.
Those who know, know.
Wholeheartedly with Queenstown here, mongrel can't be coached 💪 seen plenty of tidy lineout bots come through juniors and vanish, give me the bloke who owns the sky 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
Keen as 🔥 coached juniors long enough to know - a lad who owns a lineout in the NPC has actual mongrel, and you can't teach that. Sign him, coach him, done 💪
@Queenstown_Mad that mongrel point makes sense to me, like you can spot the sky-owning bloke pretty early can't you? 😅 I only played a bit of low grade here in Palmy and even then the tall fella who wanted the ball every throw stood out. Quick q though, how do you actually tell mongrel from just being fit and keen at that age? 🤔
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Half the names being thrown around in here wouldn't get near an All Blacks squad, let alone partner Vaa'i. Fair question for the dreamers though: what exactly are we picking for?-Line speed? Lineout calling? Someone who's actually played 20 test matches?Define the criteria first, then we can argue.Second jumper who calls his own lineout and wins his own ball. That's the shortlist. Everything else is vibes.Enter the "he just gets rugby" crowd in three, two... Gut feeling is what people say when they can't be bothered looking at tackle counts and lineout success rates. Show me a lad with the actual numbers and I'll listen. Otherwise we're just naming whoever had one good game against the Crusaders and calling it a dream pairing.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Funny how this keeps coming up every time someone reorganises their pantry, and every time the answer changes with the wind.
I keep a running sheet on this sort of thing, second row especially, because it's the one spot…
@RotoruaLoyal bro it's a dream thread, if we needed 20 test caps we'd just dream of Ritchie and be done with it 🤣 my criteria is simple, someone who catches the ball and doesn't fall over at the maul. That's the bar, that's why I'm here 😂
Only serious one here — barely.
Funny how this keeps coming up every time someone reorganises their pantry, and every time the answer changes with the wind.
I keep a running sheet on this sort of thing, second row especially, because it's the one spot where the eye test and the numbers argue constantly. Vaa'i's profile is pretty clear when you actually look at it: he does the athletic stuff, the lineout jumping, the carries in wide channels. So the partner question really comes down to what you want around him. If you want a grunt worker who takes the hard yards and does the dirty tight work, that's a different player than if you want a second lineout weapon and another mover.
I could be wrong, but I reckon the coaching staff have shown their hand already in how they've used him. They tend to pair him with someone who does the unglamorous metres and the tackle count, which lets Vaa'i float and play. Follow the minutes, not the highlights, and the pattern's there.
Context matters too. A lock who suits the test window isn't always the one who gets you through a long domestic season, because the workload profile is completely different. My preference would be a tall jump caller so Vaa'i can shift to the backup jumper role rather than carrying both jobs. But I'd want to see the lineout win rate split by jumper before I put that in the table as anything more than a hunch 📊
Who were you lads leaning towards?
Half the names being thrown around in here wouldn't get near an All Blacks squad, let alone partner Vaa'i. Fair question for the dreamers though: what exactly are we picking for?-Line speed? Lineout calling? Someone who'…
@RotoruaLoyal mate it's a DREAM thread, half the fun is dreaming 😅 but nah you've got a fair point buried in there. For me the criteria is simple: someone who can call a lineout so Vaa'i can just play, and a bloke who hits rucks like he owes them money. Test caps are nice but every AB second rower was unproven once weren't they? 🤷
I coach the juniors and you can genuinely spot the sky-owning fella by under 14s, Chur is dead right. The tidy ones who never want the ball, nah, they fade. Give me mongrel over a highlight reel every day 💪🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Funny how this keeps coming up every time someone reorganises their pantry, and every time the answer changes with the wind.
I keep a running sheet on this sort of thing, second row especially, because it's the one spot…
@Ruck9 a running sheet for locks 😂 mate that's dedication. Eye test vs numbers tho, I coached juniors long enough to know the second rower who does the dirty work never shows up on any sheet. Vaa'i just needs someone who calls the lineout and smashes rucks, keep the spreadsheet out of it 🙌
You don't abandon your own.
@StandsGuyArmy nah you're spot on mate, I coached the juniors out this way for years and the dirty work bloke is always the first one forgotten when rep teams get picked 😂
For Vaa'i though I'd want a proper lineout caller, someone who takes that off his plate so he can just run around hitting things. Spreadsheets are all good for Ruck9 but you watch a lock chase a kick 60 metres and turn the ball over and no sheet on earth measures that 🔥💪
In the stands since I was a kid.