Right, lads, who's our dream signing at fly-half
Word from a mate who does the cricket at HBF Park is we've been sniffing around a NZ-based No. 10 with cap room to spare next season π€‘ won't name names, half of it's pub talk anyway. But if the club's serious and the NZ$ figure's real, who'd you blokes actually take? π
Show me your ROI first π
A mate who "does the cricket" is your source? That's two pub links in a chain and zero names. I'll believe it when I see the actual NZ$ number and a signed contract, and until then this rumour's worth about as much as a TAB multi on Force winning the Super Rugby Pacific title. Source on that, or just banter?
Hype isn't an argument.
Forget the pub talk for a sec. Even if it's half made up, imagine a proper Kiwi 10 pulling the strings at HBF Park π We've been crying out for someone to take the line on and get our outside backs ball with a bit of space, haven't we? If the cap room's real then splash the NZ$, get it done π₯ backing them all day either way, ah well, nowt to do but dream big πͺ
Been tracking the No. 10 market across the ditch for a couple of seasons now in my own little spreadsheet π, and I'll be blunt: a genuine Kiwi test-capped playmaker moving to Perth is the rarest signing in the comp. If we're talking someone in that 28-32 age bracket with 60-odd Super caps, NZ Rugby usually finds the NZ$ to keep them, and if they don't, it's Japan or Europe that outbids us, rarely a Western Force offer.
The realistic lane is the next tier down - a 23-25 year old stuck behind an incumbent at one of the five NZ franchises, someone with maybe 15-30 starts who's sick of waiting. That's the guy who'd actually take the money and a guaranteed jersey. Small sample though, since we've only pulled off this sort of raid once or twice in the professional era, and I could be wrong about how NZR handles the current contract window. Depends how you count it, but I'd put the odds of a big-name 10 at closer to a long TAB multi than a straight up single.
Context beats a bare stat.
Rob, your spreadsheet reckons it's rare, but doesn't NZ Rugby let heaps of good 10s slip offshore anyway? π
Or am I missing something, happy to be corrected!
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Steve, they let one or two slip, sure, but the top shelf 10s get re-signed before you can blink, NZ Rugby throws everything at keeping them. You'd have better odds on a Force title multi landing than a test-capped Kiwi 10 rocking up at HBF Park π Put my TAB money where the spreadsheet says and I'd be skint by round five πΈ
I was at the shearing shed yarning with a bloke whose cousin does gear for one of the Super clubs, and even he reckons the Kiwi unions lock their good 10s down before they hit the open market. So the ones you'd actually want at HBF Park are the ones nobody's letting go, and in reality? We're shopping in the bargain bin and hoping π Wouldn't put a multi on it, mate, but a bloke can dream.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Rob's spreadsheet and SweetAsNZ are basically on the money here. The good Kiwi 10s get re-signed years out. NZ Rugby learned that lesson the hard way and now they throw the chequebook around early. What actually crosses the ditch is the second tier: blokes stuck behind an All Black at their franchise, mid-twenties, hungry, cheap. Which, honestly, might suit us better than a marquee name anyway.
One caveat though, "cheap" only works if the coaching is right. I watched a young five-eighth come through the Taranaki development side a few years back, decent hands, decent boot, and he went offshore and just drifted. Talent without someone actually building a game plan around you is wasted money, even at NZ$400k a season. So sure, chase the overlooked Kiwi 10, but the real question is whether we've got the structures at HBF Park to make him worth having. Otherwise we've just bought a nicer seat-warmer.
Gotta laugh at the pub talk tbh π
anyone who's watched how NZ Rugby operates knows the re-sign window is the whole game, they lock the 10s in before they've even nailed down the starting spot, so by the time a name's floating round the tabloids the paperwork's done. If we've got cap room to burn, spend it on a gun Aussie journeyman or a convert from league, that's where the actual value sits πͺ through thick and thin with our lot but I ain't holding my breath for a Kiwi 10 at HBF Park π€¬
You don't abandon your own.
Fair enough about the re-sign windows, but surely someone's contract is up every year? π
There's always one fellas loses patience, keen to hear what Steve thinks still learning this stuff
Dumb questions are my specialty.
π€£ Reminds me of that No. 10 rumour a few years back, we all planned our season around him and he re-signed by Friday. Time will tell, fellas π
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
Fair enough about the re-sign windows, but surely someone's contract is up every year? π
There's always one fellas loses patience, keen to hear what Steve thinks still learning this stuff
@Wellington_15 yeah contracts do roll over every year bro, but the ones worth chasing never even hit the open market π
someone always loses patience, sure, but are they ever the 10 you actually want? I coached a junior 10 who got locked in at 19 before he'd started a single proper game, that's how it works here π₯
You don't abandon your own.
@Wellington_15 yeah contracts do roll over every year bro, but the ones worth chasing never even hit the open market π
someone always loses patience, sure, but are they ever the 10 you actually want? I coached a junior 1β¦
100% this π
the good 10s get locked away quiet, we only hear about the leftovers. Force chasing patience cases? nah, dream on πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
Queenstown_Mad has it right. The "patience cases" are leftovers by definition. Define dream signing first, then we can argue about who's realistically available. Not convinced anyone qualifies on both counts.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Queenstown_Mad has it right. The "patience cases" are leftovers by definition. Define dream signing first, then we can argue about who's realistically available. Not convinced anyone qualifies on both counts.
@RotoruaLoyal I'd say a dream signing is any 10 who makes you shorten your expectations from "hide behind the pack" to "control the game", availability comes second at Force prices. Punter in me says I'd rather back a leftover with a boot than a dream that never lands. Struck out chasing the dream before, line moved and I paid for it π
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Dream signing's a funny old word, isn't it. Back in the day every club had one name they chased all winter and half of them never got on the plane anyway. Force have always been shopping in the leftovers bin, that's just how it goes. Ah well, we'll see who slips through this time π
Been here longer than some have followed.
And who decides "control the game", the coach or the fan base? Maul's happy backing leftovers, but I'd want a source that any decent 10 was even offered to Perth.
Hype isn't an argument.