Right, lads, who's our next big bopper at lock?
Word is doing the rounds that a certain towering Canterbury lock might be off-contract after the Bunnings NPC, and I'd happily punt a few NZ$ on him ending up south if someone up top grows a spine. 2.02m of nothing but trouble for the rest of the conference, in blue gold and maroon at Forsyth Barr? Yes please. If we let the Cantabs keep him I'll laugh all the way to the TAB 🤡😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
"Word is doing the rounds", whose word, exactly? Your mate's cousin's barber? Because I've heard this exact whisper about three different locks in the last two seasons and precisely none of them turned up south.
I'll take the dream seriously when someone shows me a contract date or a quote. Until then I'm not putting a cent at the TAB on it, and neither should you. Pub debate material for tonight, sure. But let's call it what it is: hoping, not reporting.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Nah Scrum10 let us dream FFS 😤 we've been screaming for a genuine lineout target for seasons, imagine 2.02m of him towering over every throw at Forsyth Barr 🔥💪 pub debate tonight's gonna be lively, you just know. Ah well, nowt to do but pour another and hope someone up top grows a spine 🙌
In the stands since I was a kid.
Fair question from Scrum10 actually, even if he's sucking the joy out of it. I keep my own spreadsheet on this stuff, and here's the sober read: a Canterbury lock going off-contract after the NPC is exactly the profile we've chased before, and the sourcing on these whispers is usually a mate of a mate. Small sample though. Last two seasons isn't much to judge a pattern by.
The logic part I can defend a bit better. A 2.02m lineout target is precisely what our derby record against the Crusaders and the likes has been screaming for, and if he's off-contract post-NPC, the timing does line up with Super recruitment windows. I could be wrong, but I'd say it's maybe a 30% shout rather than fantasy. Depends how you count it, and whether the Sader influence still tugs him north. I'll happily wear the munted optimism tag at the pub tonight, but I want a contract date before I punt any NZ$ on it.
Context beats a bare stat.
Rob, your own spreadsheet proves my point more than yours. You say the "profile" is exactly what we've chased before. Right, and how many of those chases landed a signing? That's the counter-example sitting right there in your own data. Every winter we get the same rumour mill about some tall Canterbury forward, someone gets on their spreadsheet, and by round one we're still throwing to a flanker at two.
Define "off-contract" before anyone gets carried away, because it doesn't mean "leaves". It means his province gets first crack, NZR gets a say, and a bloke from Masterton like me has watched this club lose that race more times than I can count. If GloryDays247 wants to put NZ$ on it at the TAB, good luck to him, I'll believe it when I see a signature on a page, same as Scrum10 says. Until then it's pub talk, and pub talk is fine, just don't dress it up as scouting.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Mate I've been burned by this exact whisper before... remember the big Southland lad everyone swore was coming south two seasons back? Signed elsewhere before we'd finished our first pint 😅 lovely to dream about a 2.02m lineout bopper, and tbh watching him in Canterbury colors I'd take him in a heartbeat, but time will tell ah well, nowt to do till the contract news drops 🍻
In the stands since I was a kid.
Mate I've been burned by this exact whisper before... remember the big Southland lad everyone swore was coming south two seasons back? Signed elsewhere before we'd finished our first pint 😅 lovely to dream about a 2.02m …
@DiehardFaithful ha don't remind me, I was one of the pints at that table 😭 reckon we've got juniors coming through though, seen a big fella at the under-20s coaching who'd fill a lineout jersey proper. Our lot never make it easy but backing them all day 🙌
Heart with the team, head on pause.
New to following this stuff closely so sorry if it's daft 🙏 but what actually made the Southland lad fall through? Wondering how we spot the real whispers from the pub ones 😅
Dumb questions are my specialty.
New to following this stuff closely so sorry if it's daft 🙏 but what actually made the Southland lad fall through? Wondering how we spot the real whispers from the pub ones 😅
@Wellington_15 nah not daft at all mate 😅 the trick is simple really — if it's coming from the player's actual clubmates or his agent chatting in the pub, ears up... if it's "my cousin reckons" from three forums away, pour a pint and forget it. That Southland lad had NO smoke till he was basically gone, which tells you how quiet real ones are. Ah well, nowt to do but keep dreaming about a 2 💪🔥
One love, one side ❤️
Mate I've been burned by this exact whisper before... remember the big Southland lad everyone swore was coming south two seasons back? Signed elsewhere before we'd finished our first pint 😅 lovely to dream about a 2.02m …
@DiehardFaithful still sour about that one, had him in a same-week multi with another signing punt and both legs folded 😭 same rule I use on the TAB applies here, short price on a rumour means no value, wait till it's landed before you load up. Anyone actually seen this fella play or are we all just drooling over 2.02m again?
Value over a big price 💸
Pub whispers over cousin reckons any day 🤣 the cousin reckons network moves faster than any signing announcement though lol
Memes are analysis too.