Right, lads, who's our next first five?
Heard something at the pub last night that got me interested, word is a certain Crusaders playmaker fancies a fresh start and might be up for a chat when the window opens. Imagine him pulling the strings at Eden Park in the black jersey, worth every NZ$ of the cheque. Be honest lads, who's put a multi on him signing by the time the window shuts? 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
"The pub told me" has to be the weakest sourcing chain since my mate swore the Warriors would win the comp in 2021. Name the playmaker, name who he talked to, or it's just pub noise with a cheque attached.
I'll believe it when I see it, and even then I want to know what NZ$ figure we're talking about, because this smells like every rumour that's ever floated through a TAB queue before a big derby. Source on that, or are we just building a shrine to hypotheticals?
Hype isn't an argument.
Nah I'm with Napier on this one, pub talk or not you just know we're screaming out for a ten with real spark. 😱 Watched the juniors training last week and even the coach was saying we've been crying out for a proper game manager for years now. Whoever it is from our Crusaders lot, if he fancies the black jersey then get the chequebook out, NZ$ well spent before he even laces a boot imo. 🔥
Imagine him pulling the strings at Eden Park, front row of the pub before kickoff, full house singing. Look at our lot the last few seasons, plenty of muscle but the 10 channel's been a traffic jam. Fresh start, fresh chapter, Chur!! 🙌💪
You don't abandon your own.
I keep a running sheet on our ten options every season and the age curve is the bit nobody mentions at the pub. A Crusaders playmaker in his mid-to-late twenties fits the window. You'd realistically get four to five good years before the decline line kicks in, which is exactly when the next batch should be ready. I could be wrong, but the logic of a fresh start stacks up better than most pub rumours do.
Where I'd pump the brakes: crunchies moving between the big two franchises are rare because of the salary spread and the coach relationships, so any NZ$ figure quoted over a pint is probably guesswork. Compare that with the last time we chased a proven ten versus developing one internally, the hit rate on internal rises has actually been better on my table, small sample though. Worth a chat if the door's genuinely open, but I wouldn't spend the cheque money in my head just yet. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Rob's age-curve stuff had me nodding till I remembered Beauden walked into the jersey around 23 and looked like a million bucks from his first start, you don't buy experience at mid-twenties, you grab the young gun early…
@RobFirstFive don't laugh, guys, but what's an age curve in this context? I'm new here 😅 keen to understand before I pick a side
New here, soaking it up.
Rob's age-curve stuff had me nodding till I remembered Beauden walked into the jersey around 23 and looked like a million bucks from his first start, you don't buy experience at mid-twenties, you grab the young gun early and cop the growing pains. I'd rather put NZ$ on the raw prospect at longer odds than load up on the safe Crusaders pick at short ones, the line never stays put once the cheque lands anyway. Yeah nah, back the kids.
@SweetAsNZ Beauden's a rough example though mate, he was a generational athlete walking into a side already winning. Plenty of young tens get thrown in early and get chewed up, then the confidence never comes back. It's a bit like backing a young horse first-up over a trip, sometimes the run does them good, sometimes it ruins them.
I'd take the young fella early too, but only if the pack in front of him is sorted. Put a green ten behind a beaten forward line and he's learning bad habits by week six. Same as a multi, one weak leg and the whole thing's toast. 🔥
Value over a big price 💸
SweetAs talks about Beauden like youth alone fixes a ten 😂 whoever this Crusaders fella is, I'll believe it when he's signing, and if he flops I'll be at the pub laughing at whoever tipped it 🤡
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Barrett to leave, Mo'unga to France, half the Rumoured deals over the years — how many of these pub whispers have actually landed? LockLegend's got it right: signature on paper or it never happened. Time will tell, and my accountant's gut says the odds here are worse than a TAB multi.
Sample first, conclusions after.