Right now, who is our dream centre to partner the midfield
Righto lads, chucking my NZ$20 on the bar tab early before the smart buggers snake my combo: word is Ioane might be looking at a shift anyway, so don't be so quick to lock the twins debate in the drawer. Heard it off a bloke who knows a bloke, so grain of salt and all that.
Either way, I'll take whoever the selectors pick and still whinge about it at the pub. My combo's going up before kickoff, and if any of you muppets out-pick me I'll want the receipt 😏🤡💸
Show me your ROI first 😏
A bloke who knows a bloke, receipts please, Napier. That rumour has done more laps of the TAB than a Wallabies backline chasing a drifting kick. Shove your NZ$20 on a real line and I'll take it; until then I'll believe a midfield combo when it runs out at Eden Park, not when your mate's mate reckons.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Hard out I'm dreaming of both twins on the park together 🔥 imagine the havey traffic 🤬💪 put me down for that NZ$20, you just know !!!!
You don't abandon your own.
Spent a bit of time on the spreadsheet this arvo, mostly out of curiosity after Napier's rumour. 📊 Here's where the twins-as-a-package maths sits: Rieko turns 28 next season, which by wing standards is prime-now territory rather than buy-low territory, and any club serious about him would be paying for peak years, not upside. Add the currency of sabbaticles we've seen before, and a mid-cycle shift looks tidy on paper but expensive in practice. Small sample though, because contract talk is the one area where my tables go quiet, nobody publishes leverage.
I could be wrong, but positionally the more interesting wrinkle is exactly what Napier nudges at: if the coaches genuinely see Rieko as an inside-centre option for 2027 shape, then the twin debate stops being either/or and becomes a fit question. I'd rank that scenario more likely than an offshore move, frankly.
Context beats a bare stat.
Rob, your spreadsheet assumes the twins question is a contracts problem. Define "dream centre" first, because nothing in those numbers tells me who actually defends at 12 against a heavy midfield.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Saw Rieko carving up midfield channels at training a while back and thought, why's he wasting out wide? 😏 Put my NZ$20 on the twins combo, sure thing mate.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Rotorua's got a point buried in there somewhere, to be fair. Everyone's arguing payroll and I still don't know who tackles at 12. My caveat: a dream centre you can't defend with is just highlight reel material, ask any club that's learned that the hard way.
Slightly off-topic but it fits: watched my old man coach a Taranaki junior side years back, kept picking the flashiest back for centre and got carved up every Saturday until he picked the boring defender instead. Suddenly the whole midfield stopped leaking. So for my NZ$20 on the tab, twins combo only if the other twin covers the channels. Otherwise I want a proper 12 who can actually stop a heavy carrier. Mean, someone tell me what "dream" actually means here before we split the tab on vibes.
Supporter88 hit it on the head tbh, defence is the whole test 😅 but I coached juniors with a bloke who played 12 and he always said the tackle is made BEFORE contact, it's reading the shape. Reiko reads it better than anyone we've got, I've watched him up close 🔥 so my NZ$20's on the twins combo, if he gets it wrong ah well, nowt to do 💪
One love, one side ❤️
😂 "Reading the shape". Mate my reading of the shape is the menu at the pub. My NZ$20's on whoever looks least hungover at kickoff. 🍿
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿
Seen this movie before, bro, same whispers two seasons back and nothing came of it. 🤫 Time will tell. Save your NZ$20.
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Sorry if this is a dumb question but when yous say defence at 12, do you mean the second man in the channel or actually marking the first receiver? 😅 I watched a bit of club footy this season and it seemed like the good 12s were the ones who trusted their 13 to slide across, then just choped the tackle when it came inside. Maybe that's what ClassicGuy's coach meant by reading the shape?
Also John your NZ$20 at the pub sounds like the only reliable predictor in this thread 😂 cheers to whoever explained the defensive thing earlier, got it now I think!
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Sorry if this is a dumb question but when yous say defence at 12, do you mean the second man in the channel or actually marking the first receiver? 😅 I watched a bit of club footy this season and it seemed like the good …
@SteveAuckland not a dumb question mate, good 12s do both honestly 🤔 they mark up on set phases then loosen off as the line slides, reading when to bite is the whole trick. I coach the juniors over here and the lads who struggle are the ones who bite every single time... you end up chasing shadows 💪 ah well, nowt to do but drill it into them.
One love, one side ❤️
Nah it's both Steve, second man in AND the first receiver when the line pushes. Good 12s just know when to bite 🔥 trust me, coached enough juniors to see who's got it 💪
One love, one side ❤️
Nah it's both Steve, second man in AND the first receiver when the line pushes. Good 12s just know when to bite 🔥 trust me, coached enough juniors to see who's got it 💪
@Metric_Lab 100% this, the bite timing is everything 😅 see it every Tuesday with my juniors too, the kids who rush up every phase get carved... reads take years though ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
Seen this movie before, bro, same whispers two seasons back and nothing came of it. 🤫 Time will tell. Save your NZ$20.
@ChrisFullback yeah and two seasons back I burned NZ$40 on that same "whisper" ending in nothing, lesson learned there. Still, if this one firms up before the squad's named, watch the line move, TAB will shorten it quick and then you're paying full price for the same tip. Bankroll is everything, but you only live once too 😅🍺
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
@ChrisFullback yeah and two seasons back I burned NZ$40 on that same "whisper" ending in nothing, lesson learned there. Still, if this one firms up before the squad's named, watch the line move, TAB will shorten it quick…
@Maul_Legend NZ$40 on a whisper that went nowhere, that stings a bit 😅 still learning this stuff myself but that makes sense about the TAB shortening the line quick. So if you hear something good you basically have to get in early or you're just paying full price for the same rumour later? Feels a bit like paying extra for the same coffee just because you queued slower.
Genuine question though, do punters actually trust these squad whispers or is it mostly noise? I'd be too nervous to put money on something that's not announced yet 🙈
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏