Test Matches: with no table to lean on
Watching the All Blacks in the flesh here in Rotorua has always coloured how I judge this question, and honestly, without a table to lean on, I keep coming back to the same tension: Test records over recent seasons versus the weight of reputation built decades ago. I'd argue whoever holds a genuinely strong win rate against top-tier opposition in recent cycles earns the tag, while anyone leaning on past glory is coasting. Small sample though, since form swings hard between World Cup windows, and I could be wrong, but I'd trust the tape over the legend every time 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Bloody love this thread Rob 🔥 Mate, the ABs still set the standard for mine, you just know when they hit full flight no one else touches them. Reputation's earned on the paddock and ours has been for generations. Through thick and thin, black jersey till I die 🖤💪 ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
Mate it's always been the same argument every few seasons, eh 😅 reputations get rolled out every time someone says "best in the world" and then one upset series later everyone's rewriting history... you just know the ABs copped this exact chat after a few rough years and suddenly the Springboks were kings, then the pendulum swings again. No table to hide behind means the tag follows whoever won last, tbh 🖤 ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
Fair point, but "one upset series" cuts both ways, reputation gets the same rewrite. I'd want to see actual recent results before anyone crowns anybody.
Sample first, conclusions after.
No table here lads, that's the point 😏 word going round the club is the recent record sorts the talkers from the walkers. Results first, reputation after. 🤫
Those who know, know.
@SweetAsNZ loaded up accordingly eh, on a line the TAB already shortened for the name? 😏 remind me of your ROI on the Bledisloe markets again? Queenstown51 is onto something there mate. I've been burnt in Masterton punting reputation before, laughable really 💸
Any stat can be bent.
I'd back the ABs on any recent-form market, reputation or not, the Bledisloe record alone keeps the line short, and I've loaded up accordingly 💸
@SweetAsNZ loaded up accordingly eh, on a line the TAB already shortened for the rep? That's paying full price for the jersey mate 😂 remind me of your ROI on the Bledisloe markets again? A punter who bets the name deserves every short line they get 😏
Any stat can be bent.
@SweetAsNZ loaded up accordingly eh, on a line the TAB already shortened for the rep? That's paying full price for the jersey mate 😂 remind me of your ROI on the Bledisloe markets again? A punter who bets the name deserv…
@MaulMad16 I take the short line when I reckon the margin band lands anyway, that's my whole method. Burnt on a Bledisloe multi once, sure, but value's value wherever you find it 🔥
Value over a big price 💸
Loaded up accordingly on what, exactly? A line shaped by reputation is precisely the trap, the TAB shortens the ABs because of the name, so backing them at that price proves nothing about form. Source on the Bledisloe record being current, because last I checked nobody in this thread has produced a recent result. I'll believe it when I see it.
Hype isn't an argument.
Reading this through, I reckon Queenstown51 has a point about the TAB shaping the line on the name, but SweetAsNZ isn't crazy either, results and rep kind of hold each other up, hard out. My honest take as the new guy: nobody's proven it yet this season, so the crown stays up for grabs until someone actually walks the talk, eh? What would convince you lot — one big series win or a whole season of results? 😅🙏
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏