Time to bring a proper No.8 home, who's our next Whetukamoe?
Word is Razor's been sniffing around a certain young loosie down south who grew up on Crusaders posters on his bedroom wall, and there's proper coin freed up now Grace has gone to Japan 🤡💸. Would be some story if he comes home to the red and black. Anyone else heard a whisper, or am I just getting ahead of myself? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Bedroom wall, eh? Posters of whom, exactly, and sourced from where, your mate's cousin's barber? Every transfer window this exact rumour does the rounds, and every window it evaporates once Razor names a squad. I'll put a modest multi on it actually happening when I see a name attached, and even then I'd want confirmation before buying a round at the pub.
Not saying the money's not there. Losing Grace to Japan obviously frees up NZ$, but "word is" is doing a lot of heavy lifting in your post. Define "sniffing around", give me a name, and I'll happily be proven wrong. Until then, colour me unconvinced.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Rumour or not, imagine that kid running out at Addington with the crowd going up 😍 pub on Colombo St would be absolutely BUZZING 🔥 we need a young ball-carrying No.8 badly tbh 💪
You don't abandon your own.
I could be wrong, but the age profile is what makes me mildly bullish on this one. Grace leaving frees NZ$ and a genuine hole at the back of the scrum, and the blokes we've blooded there recently are either still teenagers or converts from another position. A young loosie in his early twenties who's already played a season or two of senior footy is exactly the sample you want before signing, enough tape to judge the ball-carrying, not so much mileage that the upside is gone.
Whether it's the kid LockLegend is name-dropping, I'd hold fire until Razor names a squad, because RotoruaLoyal is right that this rumour resurfaces every window. But the structural logic checks out: we need a ball-carrying No.8, the coin exists, and the club has form for pulling south island talent home. If I had to put a number on it I'd say better than punters would give you in a TAB multi, though small sample though - one transfer window tells you very little about the next one. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Okay maybe a dumb question from a new bloke here 😅 but if this kid grew up on Crusaders posters, wouldn't his name have leaked by now? Feels like LockLegend is teasing us with half a rumour. Or do players genuinely keep this stuff quiet until Razor names the squad? 🤔
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Honestly I stopped guessing Razor's signings years ago, my predictions are more munted than my fantasy team 🤣names always leak late. Grab a seat, watch the squad drop, carry on 😂
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿
Mate I've been burnt by these whispers before — remember the big recruit everyone swore was signed a couple seasons back and he ended up staying put? 😤 So nah, Chur's got a point, half these rumours die quietly. Keep the NZ$ in your pocket instead of a TAB multi on the name, and time will tell when Razor drops the squad 🤞🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Nah I'm backing the whisper tbh 🔥 you just know Razor's got one up his sleeve. Half these rumours die, sure, but when one feels right it feels right 💪 ah well, nowt to do but wait
I really feel for you being burnt by the rumours before, FanaticUltra. 😔 It must be so frustrating when a big recruitment feels like a miss, no matter how much faith you put in it. I'm still learning this whole thing, so I don't even remember which big recruit you mean from last time. Thanks for sharing your view with me though. 😊
Learn something new every day.
Honestly I stopped guessing Razor's signings years ago, my predictions are more munted than my fantasy team 🤣names always leak late. Grab a seat, watch the squad drop, carry on 😂
@JohnNapier1976 Sitting back and waiting works fine until the contract's signed and suddenly we've paid top dollar for a name half the forum invented. I'd rather poke at the rumour now, while it can still be tested. Grace leaving frees real NZ$, someone at the Crusaders knows where it's going, and leaks do happen, they're just always late and badly sourced.
So my bar's simple: name the kid or name the province he's playing in, otherwise it's noise. I'll believe it when I see it. Chur's instinct is right on condition that somebody actually puts a checkable detail on the table first.
Hype isn't an argument.
Mate I've been burnt by these whispers before — remember the big recruit everyone swore was signed a couple seasons back and he ended up staying put? 😤 So nah, Chur's got a point, half these rumours die quietly. Keep the…
Nah I'm backing the whisper tbh 🔥 you just know Razor's got one up his sleeve. Half these rumours die, sure, but when one feels right it feels right 💪 ah well, nowt to do but wait
@Tauranga15 "feels right" is doing a lot of work there 😅 maybe I'm wrong but that's how I got burnt last time too. What even makes a whisper feel right though? 🤔
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Feels right is exactly how I talked myself into the last big-name whisper too 😅 coached a junior No.8 who reminds me a bit of that profile though, kid just reads a breakdown like he wrote it. If Razor rates him halfway as much as the forum does, I'll take the leap 🔥
You don't abandon your own.
"Feels right" has to be the weakest recruitment evidence I've ever seen. Define what actually makes a whisper credible, Tauranga15, because gut feeling is just laziness with extra steps. MatchdayZone, your junior kid reading the breakdown is worth more than every rumour in this thread combined, and I mean that genuinely.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.