Time to buy a proper tight-head prop before our scrum keeps folding
Word is there's a Fijian-born tight-head stuck on some NZ franchise's bench who might be loose for about NZ$150k a season. Apparently he'd jump at proper game time back home. Saw a couple of lads muttering about it at the pub in Nadi before kick-off, so treat it as pub talk for now 😏 If our scrum folds like a deck chair at Churchill Park one more week, I'm putting my TAB money on the front row getting subbed by the 20th minute.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
A mate of a mate of a mate heard it at the pub, eh? NZ$150k and he's just sitting there waiting for our call? I'll believe it when I see the contract. Name the player, name the franchise, then we'll talk.
Hype isn't an argument.
Happy to be proven wrong here, but a Super Rugby squad prop going for NZ$150k screams "near the end, third in the depth chart". Bench props in NZ franchises tend to be either young development projects or blokes over 30 the coach is easing out. If he's Fijian-born and keen to come home, that part makes sense. The age and game time question is where this rumour needs a closer look before anyone signs anything.
Context beats a bare stat.
i dunno why the fella in the analysis side wouldn't believe that NZ$150k could mean something worthwhile. i've seen plenty of talented blokes sitting on those benches whose true value you don't see in some neat ranking chart. sometimes the best deal is finding that raw quality you can mold, regardless of how much the rest of the league thinks they're worth.
Watched our scrum feed off the back foot all season so even a bench prop at NZ$150k beats what we've got, eh? Sign him and let the pub talk sort itself 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Watched our scrum feed off the back foot all season so even a bench prop at NZ$150k beats what we've got, eh? Sign him and let the pub talk sort itself 😏
Seems like that loose timing in the Tighthead scrum has been rattling everyone lately, which is understandable given how much the forwards are carrying on the pitch. It’s frustrating when the foundations feel wobbly, whether that’s the scrum holding up or the team structure.
I could be wrong, but locking in a bench-level prop for NZ$150k is less about providing an immediate fix for what we've seen, and more of a speculative gamble on untapped potential. The value of that salary, as NickBreakdown1982 was pointing out, usually reflects a developing player or someone winding down their contract, meaning the immediate quality bump may not be as significant as the supporters hope. What does that figure tell us about the current roster health? That bench strength isn't necessarily translating into the sustained front-row power needed against top-tier opposition like the Wallabies.
Seen this movie before, boys. Few years back there was talk of a similarly priced lock from an Australian franchise coming over, everyone up the pub had him in the starting XV before his agent even picked up the phone. Never happened. NZ$150k for a tight-head would be lovely, but until the pen hits paper I'll believe it when I see him at training. Time will tell 😉
Seen it all, trust me.
i dunno why the fella in the analysis side wouldn't believe that NZ$150k could mean something worthwhile. i've seen plenty of talented blokes sitting on those benches whose true value you don't see in some neat ranking c…
@SweetAs_Mad nah spot on mate, bench props are hidden gems half the time 💪 coached a fella at juniors who never started a rep game but scrummaged blokes twice his size all day. 150k for that? cheap as. our scrum folding every week anyway, what have we got to lose 🔥
One love, one side ❤️