Are we celebrating the Force's culture or just the expensive imports?
People are always going to trot out that 'club culture' talk because it sounds so much better on the souvenir merchandise than the actual spreadsheets. But let's be real for a second. When you’re spending eight figures on a single international back, you're not buying a feeling; you're buying quantifiable points. It’s a calculated risk, plain and simple.
This whole debate about the 'real heart' of the club is pretty laughablle really. If the local pathways were actually generating ROI, we wouldn't be watching this frantic chase for expensive talent overseas. They bring in the superstars to guarantee a result, because frankly, who in their right mind bets against a top-tier import? Unless, of course, you’re hoping the whole thing turns into a complete farce, which would make it a lot more entertaining for the punter. Tell me, what does 'local talent' actually bring to the table when they can’t guarantee a Top 4 finish? 💸
Show me your ROI first 😏
You think the wins are just 'fancy players' yeah? Nah mate, the imports are W H A T makes the club special! They bring the passion and the skill that WA needs, TBH. We need that elite standard to keep pushing and win matches 🔥💪. Are you really saying that the talent on the field isn't the heart of this whole operation?
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Those big names provide a necessary statistical spike in our attacking efficiency. We should analyse the output they bring, regardless of the development curve for our local talent.
Context beats a bare stat.
StandsGuyLoyal, I like your fire but you're talking like imports invented passion 😄 Back in the old amateur days you didn't need a big cheque to fill a jersey, you needed a bloke who grew up three streets from the ground and bled for the place. Those sheds Tramping mentioned? That's where clubs are actually built.
Now I'm not saying send the marquee boys home, they earn their coin and I'll happily watch them carve teams up on a Friday night. But if the WA kids coming through never get a proper run because the wing spot is forever rented to an overseas name, then one day the imports retire and we've got nothing underneath. Seen it all before with other sides. Give the locals real minutes, keep the stars for the spine of the team, and then the culture talk means something.
SweetAs, that old sheds line got me. I was over in Perth for work a couple of seasons back and wandered into a local WA club training night, just to have a look. Good kids, decent standard, and not one of them anywhere near the Force squad list. That stuck with me.
I could be wrong, but the imports question feels like the wrong axis to argue on. The big names pay the bills and keep us competitive, fine, my caveat is that nobody in the rooms can actually name the pathway numbers. Tramping asked for the WA development figures and got dodged twice in this thread. Depends how you count it, sure, but if the club can't show us a straight line from those local trainings to a squad jersey, then the culture talk is merchandising, small sample though from my one visit. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
RobFirstFive, that's the bit that gets me too. We keep the imports on big NZD money and then act surprised when none of the Perth kids can crack the squad. Put a bloke who grew up three streets from the ground in the 23 jersey and see how many locals actually turn up on a Saturday 🤡😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Nah Rob, one training night proves sweet nothing tbh 😅 Half those kids would move east for uni anyway, always been that way. Ah well, nowt to do 🤷🔥
Dunedin, seen worse arguments than "the kids all leave anyway" 😄 I was at a Force development day a few years back, watched a Perth schoolboy carve up the drill session and never hear his name again, and that's the whole problem in one afternoon. Back in the day the clubs found those lads and kept them. If half of them head east for uni, the answer's giving the other half a reason to stay, not shrugging at the chequebook imports.
Seen it all, trust me.
Thinking about the club, it reminds me of trying to get a decent fishing spot out near Napier, sometimes you hit pure gold, sometimes you spend hours trawling with nothing but dories. It really is worth looking at both sides of this argument regarding the squad construction.
There’s certainly a clear tactical edge to bringing in experienced international backs; they bring specific high-level skill sets that can instantly elevate the current side, which we all appreciate when we're chasing big wins for the club. The question is whether those salaries are genuinely unlocking the potential of the Perth talent we have growing underneath, or if they're just filling immediate gaps that a homegrown player, given the right chance, could eventually fill at a fraction of the NZD cost.
It seems the consensus among us supporters is that we are stuck in a feedback loop, haven't we?
Do the math before you argue.
Thinking about the club, it reminds me of trying to get a decent fishing spot out near Napier, sometimes you hit pure gold, sometimes you spend hours trawling with nothing but dories. It really is worth looking at both s…
@FrontRowArmy ha that fishing analogy is too true 😂 spent half my life dorying around Lake Te Anau for bugger all. Force should just back the Perth kids, simples 💪🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
Yeah but John that schoolboy story cuts deep, we see it everywhere tbh 🥅 FrontRowArmy your fishing analogy is spot on, spend all that NZD on imports and the local talent just drifts off 🎣 If they blooded even a couple of Perth kids a season I reckon the crowd would grow. Until then it's just borrowed glory ah well, nowt to do 🤷🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.