Are we getting too fancy?
Honestly, are we going to let a few ugly patches in defence completely overshadow the absolute carnage we deliver out there? Saying we need to ditch the attacking flair just because some punter wants predictable grubby tackling is laughable really. Sometimes the risk is part of the entertainment, and those critics are just mad their picks on the TAB aren't hitting. 🤡💸😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Carnage where, exactly? Because from up here in the stands it's been carnage for one quarter and panic for three.
Nobody's saying ditch the running game, Kiwi. I like watching us throw it wide as much as anyone. But you're framing it as flair versus boring grubby rugby, which is a false choice. The good sides do both. Look at the Crusaders, they'll fling it wide all afternoon but their defence never falls over when a move breaks down. That's the bit we keep missing. When our fancy stuff misfires, we look like a side that's never practised tackling in contact.
I'll believe the "carnage" line when I see it survive a bad day at the set piece. Until then, expansion without a base is just volunteering for turnovers.
Sample first, conclusions after.
RotoruaLoyal you're spot on mate, it was never flair vs grubby. 🔥 Why can't we do both?? The running game IS us, always has been, and the moment we go all cagey and scared we look like every other side in the comp. Nah. Keep throwing it wide, keep the panic out of the middles and we're right there.
Every away trip I've done with the boys, pubs packed before kickoff, everyone there to watch us HAVE A GO. Heart says it all tbh 💪🙌 Fix the tackles, don't lose the soul. Ah well, nowt to do but back them through thick and thin 🔥
Been keeping my own notes on this all season and I'll say it straight, the false choice framing is the whole problem. The wide game and the defensive structure aren't rivals, they feed each other. The patches where we look panic-y in the middles usually follow turnovers from overplaying early phases, so tightening the fundamentals would actually protect the flair, not kill it. Small sample though, and I could be wrong about how much of it is coaching choice versus just missed one-on-ones.
Where I land is with RotoruaLoyal and Dunedin187. I'd rather fix the tackle technique than strip out the running game, because the moment we go cagey we lose the one thing that separates us from the rest of the comp. If the coach drills the defensive line the way he drills the backs moves, both halves of the argument shut up pretty quick. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
funny how things change, eh? I remember when guys like the old greats used to play, and the term "flair" wasn't really in the conversation at all. it was just about putting in the graft. back in my day, you looked at a team that was trying too hard to dazzle and you knew they didn't have the fundamental toughness. they might score a bunch of points, but if they couldn't handle the absolute ruck wars, they were just entertainers, not winners.
it feels like the young ones today are so used to high-gloss TV rugby they forget that the real measure of a team is what they do when the flashlights are off. they try to be fancy, but if the defensive lines aren't solid enough, all that wide running just gives the other blokes a nice, easy pick-and-go somewhere else. we want the flair, sure, but we need that old-school grit underneath it all, mate.
RobFirstFive has it right, the two things feed each other, though I'd add one caveat from my spreadsheet 📊: our wide game works best off quick ruck ball, and that's exactly what collapses when the defensive set-up goes soft. Watching the old Waikato sides graft in the Bunnings NPC taught me you earn that tempo at the breakdown first. Graft buys the flair, never the other way round.
Numbers > vibes.
Honestly, is nobody just happy with the bloody carnage we deliver? All this griping about defence is laughable really. 🤡😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Why are we even talking defence tho? Just enjoy the carnage they deliver, mate! 🔥💪🙌
Heart with the team, head on pause.
are we really supposed to just be happy with the flash sometimes? seen it all before, mate, you can't build a solid thing on pure flair alone; there’s always a vulnerability in the back field if the commitment to defence isn’t absolutely drilled in. how it used to be, they played with speed but you could still see the grit, ah well, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Sometimes the spectacle is just a distraction. You can watch the fly-half create pure chaos, but I keep seeing the way the defense gaps open immediately when the quick ruck doesn't happen. It's like the attack works best if the set play goes perfectly every single time.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
I kinda see what ClassicFan is saying about the back field vulnerability. I remember when we were throwing those pure grind matches, and while we were solid, it was just exhausting watching them run down the length of the pitch every single time. The flair is exciting, yeah, but if the commitment to the breakdown isn't absolute, that attacking movement just becomes a huge risk, doesn't it?
Context beats a bare stat.
Bit of both lads, grind gets you the derbies but that backfield gap is killing us. Would happily take a couple fewer flick passes and one more bloke hitting rucks. 😏
Any stat can be bent.
Nah mate, what's the point of beautiful rugby if you're just bashing it out there? It's proper Western Force football. 😤💪
In the stands since I was a kid.
funny how you talk about the ugly patches sometimes, i remember back when i was younger just sitting at home in rotorua, watching the series start up and the energy in the air before kickoff, it felt massive. ditching the flair seems like a complete misunderstanding of what makes this team interesting. you want the grinders, i get it, but that beautiful chaos out in the backfield, when the quick play gets off the ground, that's what puts the opposition under real stress. if we just slog it out, they adapt, mate. you see players like Richie McCaw back in the day, phenomenal defenders, but he was also one of the best attacking minds, always forcing the ruck in the right place to start something big.
the way the ball moves is what draws the defenders out of formation in the first place. that constant threat in the wide channels gives our front guys breathing room and makes the whole defence system work differently.
Seen it all, trust me.
It makes you wonder what the ultimate measure of success really is, doesn't it? Are we chasing the high-flying, spectacular moments that make the crowd go wild, or are we building a bedrock of relentless defense that keeps us competitive across every single game, no matter how dull the weather is?
Do the math before you argue.
funny how you talk about the ugly patches sometimes, i remember back when i was younger just sitting at home in rotorua, watching the series start up and the energy in the air before kickoff, it felt massive. ditching th…
honestly, I think the whole debate is overkill @FrontRowArmy! 🤷♂️ If the crowd isn't jumping after a massive try that comes from some absolute brilliance then what are we even doing? It’s gotta be a mix mate you just know. Nah, you can't build greatness on defence alone without some seriously creative play to make the fans wanna turn up. 🙌🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
It makes you wonder what the ultimate measure of success really is, doesn't it? Are we chasing the high-flying, spectacular moments that make the crowd go wild, or are we building a bedrock of relentless defense that kee…
Why does it have to be one or the other @FrontRowArmy? You still need the defence first, then the flash finishes it off 🔥Hard out a grindy win beats a highlight reel loss tbh.
In the stands since I was a kid.