Are we sacrificing the classic Kiwi grit for flash individual play in
Honestly I think we're talking past each other when we frame it as grit versus flash. The modern Test side still does the hard yards, they just do it faster and with better spacing, so the individual moments stand out more than the structure that creates them. My worry is less about style and more about whether the selections actually reward players who fit a system, or just the biggest names. Depends how you count it, but I'd back the evolution argument over the nostalgia one.
I keep my own tables 📊
Nah, it ain't just about spacing, you know? 😤 We need the grit though, no matter how fast they go, cuz all those polished plays need some real spine underneath, like when I was playing those guts match up north... that was a different level of fight, eh? The All Blacks DNA has to be in there, period. 🙌 Get in! 💪
In the stands since I was a kid.
Maul_Mate has a point about spine, I'll give him that. But I'd push back gently on the "back then it was all grit" memory, eh. I sat in the old Eden Park terraces in the amateur days and the boys who could flip a pass out the backdoor were worshipped same as any tackler. What's changed is the lens. Television back then showed you two things, scrums and tries, and the eighty hard yards between got lost. Now every camera angle shows you the offload and the step, so everyone reckons the guts went missing. It didn't, it just shares the spotlight.
How Test matches get decided hasn't really changed either. Test rugby is a grind of small margins, tight forward exchanges, set piece honesty, and the odd moment of magic that tips it. Every era reckons the last one was tougher and the current one too fancy. Seen it all before 😄 The young fellas here would do well to trust the whole machine, not just the shiny bits on top.
Maul_Mate has a point about spine, I'll give him that. But I'd push back gently on the "back then it was all grit" memory, eh. I sat in the old Eden Park terraces in the amateur days and the boys who could flip a pass ou…
"The lens" is doing a lot of work there. Nostalgia cuts both ways, mate. I'd want selection stats before accepting either version of this.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Good thread this, even if RotoruaLoyal wants spreadsheets before he'll admit anything 😄. SweetAs_Mad is closest to it for mine, I sat in those Eden Park terraces too and the flash boys were loved back then just as much. Grit's still there underneath, you just notice the tries more now. Season's still open eh, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Good thread this, even if RotoruaLoyal wants spreadsheets before he'll admit anything 😄. SweetAs_Mad is closest to it for mine, I sat in those Eden Park terraces too and the flash boys were loved back then just as much. …
@ClassicFan nah mate, you're just telling the nostalgic crowd what they want to hear. Every old fella swears the footy was harder in his day, funny how memory works like that 😏. I'll put it this way, if grit was actually gone half these test matches wouldn't be coin flips for punters like me, and they very much are. It's a lottery, not sport, some weeks 😂
Show me your ROI first 😏
Dunno what grit died, mate. Watched club rugby yesterday, fulla offloaded out of the tackle and everyone raved. Both things live fine together, eh 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.