Be honest, Brumbies family
Yeah nah, hard agree with the title. Since Rory Arnold walked off to Japan we've been running a second row by hope and vibes, and it shows every time we hit a proper forward battle. Half of yous reckon some kid at Uni-Norths training is the answer, the other half wants to torch half a mil NZ$ on a Kiwi journeyman who couldn't crack his own Super side. Laughable really. Neither camp has watched a single 80 minutes with actual eyes.
Developing our own lock takes three seasons minimum and you all want the fix by round five. It's a lottery, not sport, this transfer market business. Anyone who tells you they've spotted the next Test lock at club training is the same punter tipping a six-leg multi every Friday and losing every week. 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Every time someone says "it shows every time we hit a proper forward battle", I want the actual game and the actual scrum count, because I can name plenty of nights our pack held up fine. Arnold leaving hurt, sure, but one bloke doesn't make a production line. Show me which match broke us and I'll concede, otherwise that's just pub talk with extra steps.
Sample first, conclusions after.
One bloke doesn't make a production line? Rorts, we've been patching the second row for years since Arnold went to Japan 😤 Half the pub's right tbh, whatever the Uni-Norths boys are eating at training, put him in the jumper and see what happens. Throwing NZ$500k at some Kiwi journeyman? nah 🔥
You don't abandon your own.
StandsGuy has it right. I keep my own lineout stats every round, and our lock steal rate since Arnold left has dropped off a cliff. Small sample though on the Uni-Norths bloke, but worth a look before NZ$500k on a journeyman. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Back in my day the Brumbies second row grew its own timber, we didn't shop for it. Young ones forget Arnold himself was a kid nobody rated until someone backed him. Keep the NZ$500k in the pocket, give the Uni-Norths lad a full season and see what grows 😄
Funny how a pub argument and my spreadsheet ended up pointing the same direction this week. I went back over my lineout numbers after SweetAsLocal's post and yeah, the steal rate has dipped since Arnold headed to Japan, though I'd want another season of data before calling it a production-line collapse. One bloke leaving leaves a hole, context matters, but it doesn't prove the whole pipeline is dry.
Where I land, sort of: the Uni-Norths lad costs us nothing but patience, and the NZ$500k journeyman costs us money we could spend on a prop. The catch is that patience only works if the kid actually gets game time, and we all know how coaches treat young locks. So maybe the honest answer is neither half of the pub is fully right. Give the local a proper run, keep the chequebook shut for now, and revisit it if the lineout numbers keep sliding. Happy to be argued out of it over a pint before the next home game.
Do the math before you argue.
Sorry if this is a dumb one, still learning the Brumbies academy side of things 😅 but how does a Uni-Norths bloke even get noticed for the squad? Is there trials or do scouts just show up at club games? Only asking because back home our NPC clubs have guys plucked straight out of club footy all the time and it works out fine half the time.
If the choice is NZ$500k on a Kiwi journeyman or giving a young fella a full season, I know which one sounds more fun to watch honestly 😄 you'd back yourself harder if the jumper was earned 🏉
Learn something new every day.