Be honest, Tahs family: this squad is one decent five-eighth away
Honest take, half of you blokes have been calling our reserve five-eighth the future for three seasons and it's never once looked like future at the jersey. I'd put a lazy NZ$20 on the TAB that our title hopes rest on a bloke we haven't signed yet. Bring your number 10 pick to the pub before the Brumbies game, I'll happily buy the first round for whoever's right 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
A lazy NZ$20 on a bloke who doesn't exist yet, that's a brave multi from someone who called three seasons of development "nothing". Mate, I've watched every minute from the couch in Masterton and the reserve ten hasn't looked like a future anything, agreed. But the roster-blinkers thing cuts both ways. You're assuming the gap is recruitment when half our problem is the forwards shipping penalties in the red zone. Give the current ten clean ball for three phases and then tell me we need to shop.
I'll take part of that wager at the pub near Allianz before the Brumbies game, and I'll bring my pick for the jersey. Bring your TAB slip too, receipts are cheap until kickoff.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Rubbish, we've got the cattle, we just keep chopping the ten jersey around like a pub raffle 🔥 Back the bloke, give him twelve straight starts and watch the whole backline click, I've seen it happen with the juniors a hundred times 💪 I'll be at the pub early doors before the Brumbies with my pick sorted, first schooner's on me if I'm wrong. Ah well, nowt to do 🍻🙌
Watch a bloke get a proper run of starts before you write him off, I keep my own table on this and the sample size argument beats vibes every time. Dunedin's got it right, three starts here, twenty minutes there, then everyone moans the ten jersey never clicks, that's how you count it if you're honest. I'll be at the pub early with my pick anyway.
Context beats a bare stat.
I watched a young ten at Eden Park get three games and a boot up the backside, then he ran Test football for a decade. Give the lad the jersey, I'm at the pub early 😄
Been keeping my own spreadsheet on the ten jersey for three seasons now and the honest answer is the data won't settle this one for us.
Here's what I mean. Nick's right that the sample is thin, I've got the same table and the reserve ten's minutes are scattered so badly you can't separate him from the churn around him. Three starts here, twenty minutes there, different centres outside him every time, that tells you about the coaching more than the bloke. But SweetAs's Eden Park story cuts the other way too, because a genuinely special ten usually shows you something even in garbage sample size. I could be wrong, but I haven't seen that something yet. Compare it to the forward pack, where the quality jumps off the screen no matter how you count it. That gap at ten might be a development problem or a talent problem, and twelve straight starts would tell us which. So I'm keeping my NZ$20 in my pocket until I see the team sheet.
Context beats a bare stat.