Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:29 pm Log in Sign up
Brumbies

Beauden Barrett's retirement money

club debate Brumbies Supporters Brumbies 21 posts ·179 views ·Posted: 11 Sep 2026, 11:11 pm ·Updated: 13 Nov 2026, 7:50 am
LO LockLegend Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 448 posts 11 Sep 2026, 11:11 pm
Front row wins you comps, full stop. Anyone at GIO who'd rather watch pretty midfield clips while our scrum gets shunted backwards needs their head read. Half this clubhouse calls our centres the best pairing in the comp. Sure thing, mate, and in reality we've gone soft up front since the Hooper-era Wallabies days and everyone's too polite to say it. If Beauden's walking away with $1.5M NZD rattling around Japan somewhere, I know where I'd spend that coin: five more years of an actual tight-five, not another highlight reel. Saddest part? The blokes arguing centres-first have probably never had a tight-head prop buy them a beer at the pub before kickoff 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Reply Quote
SC Scrum10 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 220 posts 12 Sep 2026, 12:00 am
You reckon, LockLegend? Define "best pairing" before I swallow that one. I'll take receipts over vibes at the pub any day.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Reply Quote
ST StandsGuyLoyal Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 542 posts 12 Sep 2026, 3:47 am
Receipts? Watch the tape of the last derby, Scrum10 🔥 our centres carved up all night. Pretty sure a tight five you can rebuild, magic like that doesn't grow on trees 💪
Brumbies team
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Reply Quote
RO RobFirstFive Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 735 posts 12 Sep 2026, 7:43 am
I keep a running sheet every round and the tape keeps backing LockLegend here, whenever our front five gets shunted at scrum time, the centres touch half the ball they normally would, so that "best pairing in the comp" only fires when the tight five is winning its side of the ledger. NZ$1.5M spread across propping up a scrum for five years beats one headline name, I could be wrong, but small sample though it is, the derby tape doesn't flatter the pretty option. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
JE Jess23 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 323 posts 12 Sep 2026, 9:57 am
🤣 fellas I just hold my pint and watch our scrum go backwards like it's 2005 all over again, trust me, pretty centres lose to a shunted pack every time, ask any old punter 🍿
Hold my pint.
Reply Quote
NA Napier_Legend1980 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 457 posts 12 Sep 2026, 12:44 pm
🤡 RobFirstFive's own sheet says the magic midfield only shows up when the pigs up front are winning, yet StandsGuy wants to rebuild the tight five like it's a spare parts bin. I'd take one solid scrum over two highlight reels every Bledisloe, laughable really. What's your ROI on pretty backs, StandsGuy? 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
QU Queenstown_Mad Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 523 posts 12 Sep 2026, 3:52 pm
StandsGuy, mate, "rebuild the tight five"?? Scrumage takes YEARS, that's the whole point 😱 You just know a good centre pairing shows up when the pigs are winning 🔥
Brumbies fans
You don't abandon your own.
Reply Quote
SW SweetAsNZ Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 1015 posts 12 Sep 2026, 11:05 pm
Napier_Legend, you're arguing my point for me and don't even realise it 😄 Nobody's saying scrap the pigs - I'm saying $1.5M on ONE name vs spreading it across the tight five over five years is a no-brainer for the bankroll, same as any multi I put on at the TAB. One leg pays the lot, but stack four solid legs and it lands more often. And the counter-example writes itself: how many comps have we watched where a big-money star arrives on a fat contract while the set piece gets shunted and the whole thing folds? Went down that road a few times, cost me plenty on the line too. You feed the scrum first, the centres eat after, that's RobFirstFive's sheet saying exactly that. Spend the money where the game's won, simple as. 🔥
Reply Quote
RO RotoruaLoyal Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 455 posts 13 Sep 2026, 2:12 am
SweetAsNZ, the "spreading it across five contracts" line sounds good but hold on, tight-five depth is exactly where clubs get stung, because one bloke does a knee in round 6 and your careful NZ$300k-a-year spread means you've got nobody of actual Super Rugby quality to bring on. Ask anyone who's watched a scrum collapse in the back half of a season what thin props look like. I'll side with the front-row mob on one thing though: you can see it from the carpark at GIO when the pack is going backwards. Nobody remembers a lovely 12-13 combination from a game where the set piece was a festival of penalties. Spend where the comp is won, then argue about centres.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Reply Quote
ST SteveAuckland Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 404 posts 13 Sep 2026, 4:31 am
RotoruaLoyal nailed it, I went to school with a bloke who did his knee in round 6 and the whole front row fell apart 😅 Cheers for explaining it so simply, got it now 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Reply Quote
CH Chur Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 360 posts 13 Sep 2026, 5:46 am
Silly question maybe 😅 if one prop does a knee in round 6, does the $1.5M Barrett money even help, or are we stuck either way? Thanks for explaining, makes sense now 🙏
Brumbies goal celebration
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Reply Quote
ST StandsGuy_Ultra1997 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 368 posts 13 Sep 2026, 7:50 am
RotoruaLoyal got you thinking yet, Chur? One knee in round 6 and that clever NZ$300k spread is toast 😅 You just know tight five money beats a punt any day 🔥
You don't abandon your own.
Reply Quote
FA FanaticUltra Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 315 posts 13 Sep 2026, 8:39 am
Nah StandsGuy, one knee in round 6 stings, sure, but I've watched too many seasons die at scrum time to cop "centres first" 😤 Remember the Bledisloe Test where our lot got shoved off their own ball all arvo? Barren night. Barrett money on the tight five, backing them all day 💪🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Reply Quote
QU Queenstown51 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 483 posts 13 Sep 2026, 11:55 am
Source on the "$1.5M better spent" claim? Every thread in here trades that figure around like it's proven economics. Nobody has actually costed what retaining a test-quality tight five costs in this market, or shown me a season where a club with money to spare kept its front row together anyway. I'll believe the tight-five argument when I see it modelled, same as I'd want the centres case modelled. For what it's worth, as an economist I'd note the real constraint: Super Rugby clubs don't pick between one Barrett and five props. They pick between a marquee name and a squad that survives round 6 injuries. That's a depth argument, and depth gets bought across eight positions, not five. Concede you might be right, on condition that someone here shows the actual squad budget split, not gut feeling dressed up as loyalty.
Hype isn't an argument.
Reply Quote
Queenstown51 wrote:
Source on the "$1.5M better spent" claim? Every thread in here trades that figure around like it's proven economics. Nobody has actually costed what retaining a test-quality tight five costs in this market, or shown me a…
KE KevFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 273 posts 6 Oct 2026, 8:30 am
@Queenstown51 fair call, nobody's costed it properly, but I backed a multi last season that died when the front row got smashed, watching the line move after a prop goes down taught me enough 💸
Bankroll discipline wins.
Reply Quote
ME Metric_Lab Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 263 posts 13 Sep 2026, 12:53 pm
Queenstown51 got a point tbh, nobody's actually costed the tight five retention 😅 but I've seen enough scrums fold to know where the money should go 🔥 keep arguing lads 💪
Brumbies stadium
One love, one side ❤️
Reply Quote
WE Wellington_15 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 394 posts 6 Oct 2026, 8:30 am
Dumb question maybe 😅 but what does "retention" actually cost a club? Still learning this side of things, thanks to whoever explains 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Reply Quote
CH ChrisQueenstown Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 283 posts 6 Oct 2026, 8:30 am
@Wellington_15 not a dumb question at all mate, good on ya for asking 🙌 Basically retention = paying to keep your best blokes instead of losing them overseas. So a club has to cough up more NZ$ than they'd like to stop a quality prop or hooker taking a bigger cheque in Europe or Japan. It's not one big number either, it's the top-up on the contract, plus flow-on stuff like how it messes with the cap for everyone else. And here's the kicker: even when you pay up, no guarantee. Prop gets injured and that money's gone just the same 😱 Watched our juniors lose two good forwards to this exact thing, and trust me the scrum never looked the same after 🤬. That's why I reckon KevFan's got a point, fronts win you games even if nobody can put a clean price tag on them 💪
Reply Quote
GL GloryDays247 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 296 posts 26 Oct 2026, 4:46 pm
Yeah, retention payments are a known headache, sure thing, mate. Seems like the rich clubs just drop mountains of NZ$ to keep their props around, but honestly, even if you keep them, it's a total lottery if they can't actually perform on the pitch. It's wild watching these big teams overspend all that cash and still choke when the line finally gets crossed. 💸
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
Wellington_15 wrote:
Dumb question maybe 😅 but what does "retention" actually cost a club? Still learning this side of things, thanks to whoever explains 🙏
SW SweetAs_Mad Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 784 posts 5 Nov 2026, 11:19 am
@Wellington_15 good on ya for asking, young fella, no such thing as a dumb question here 😄 Chris explained it well enough. Truth is nobody outside the club offices knows the exact NZ$ figures, they keep that stuff close to their chest. Back in my day the blokes played for the love of it and a carton of beer, so watching salaries climb has been a sight, but if the money keeps the top props here for the derby nights, I'll wear it 😉
Reply Quote
MI MikeTighthead Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 52 posts 13 Nov 2026, 7:50 am
Thanks Chris, that finally clicked for me 🙌 So clubs pay big NZ$ just to keep blokes here, then might still get nothing back? Rough game 😅
Learn something new every day.
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.