Beauden's best years in a Canes jersey are behind him
Gonna say it before the fanboys pile in: 2016 Beauden was a machine, but the bloke running sideways for two seasons now wouldn't get a start at most clubs. We're remembering the title and forgetting the drift. Anyone lumped him into a TAB multi on form lately knows exactly what I mean 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Remember the drift but forget how often he's the only one tackling the line? Blame the forwards going backwards before you write off the bloke. Source on the two-seasons claim?
Nah you can't write him off!! Beauden in a Canes jersey won us the 2016 title, that's forever 🖤💛 Forwards going backwards and everyone remembers the drift... ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
It's like checking an old ledger, mates - the columns have to balance, and Beauden's 2016 column is glowing while the last two seasons read sideways run, drift, repeat. I could be wrong, but ScrumKiwi's got the shape of it right: memory banks on the title, the tape says the backline has flat-lined since. Honour the 2016 bloke, judge the current one on what he's actually producing. 📊
SweetAsNZ lost money on Beauden multis and suddenly he's finished? 😂 Maybe the punter's the problem, mate. Though I'll admit the sideways stuff has been rough to watch lately.
Any stat can be bent.
Nah fellas I'm not writing off Beauden yet 😤 who else in this squad pulls a defence apart like he can on his day? Yeah the drift has done my head in too but pin it all on him while our forwards get mangled upfront? Half the issue is the pack tbh, give him front foot ball again and watch him go 🔥🖤💛
You don't abandon your own.
Mad has a point fellas, our pack has been getting mangled and you can't spin it 😤 but nah, I coached juniors against blokes with half his pace and they still looked quicker than Beauden drifting across the line last season. Give him front foot ball all you want, he's still gotta run STRAIGHT first, that's on him not the forwards. Through thick and thin though, one more year before we say it out loud 💪🖤💛
One love, one side ❤️
Watched him from the embankment at the Sky Stadium semi, first touch flat, second touch sideways. The pace is still there, the willingness isn't. That's what scares me.
Hype isn't an argument.
Been keeping my own spreadsheet on his backline touches this season and even I've stopped trusting the picture it paints. Here's my honest read: I could be wrong, but Queenstown51 has hit on something. Watch the tape again, the acceleration off the mark is still there in bursts, the drift is a decision problem, and decisions are the last thing to go and the first thing you can fix. FrontRow is right that our pack has been getting mangled, though. Two things can be true at once, and that's exactly why I won't write the verdict yet.
Small sample too — a couple of flat seasons against a 2016 run where everything clicked in front of him. Yeah nah, I'm not calling him finished. But I'm also done pretending the sideways stuff is a forward problem only. Let's see what the first six rounds bring before anyone books the farewell. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
@RobFirstFive nah mate, pace is still there when he wants it 🔥 willingness comes right once the pack stops going backwards 🤬 backing our boy 💪
The discussion around his pace feels very subjective right now. If the first touch success rate has dropped consistently, surely there’s quantitative data available on that? Anecdotal observations of drift across the line don’t necessarily confirm a decline in inherent physical ability, do they? We need more than just personal spreadsheets and feeling to call his career finished. Show me the numbers from the past six months, specifically looking at metres gained per carry and the ratio of successful phases before he receives the ball.
Hype isn't an argument.
RobFirstFive with a spreadsheet and still can't trust it, that's me with every budget I make 🤣 Dunedin the data exists, my eyes just refuse to read it.