Bunnings NPC drop-zone scrap
Same feeling as picking which tin on the shelf will fall first, you look at the label and just know. Given there's no recent data worth quoting here, I'll go gut over spreadsheet for once, even though I could be wrong.
My faller is Counties Manukau. They always seem to live on the edge, thin squad depth and every injury eats into them, and the fanbase down there never quite relaxes after July. My survivor is North Harbour, purely because they've clawed out of worse scrapes before and the style travels better than people think. Context matters though, one decent run of home fixtures flips both of those calls on their head. 📊 Who's your tip then, and does anyone actually trust a prediction in this competition?
Stags through thick and thin, that's my pick for the survivor 🔥💪
Ruck9 I hear you on Counties but tbh my gut says Southland sneaks clear while someone else slips. You just know how the run-in goes down here, one scrappy away win and suddenly the whole mood flips. Been coaching the juniors all week and the boys are buzzing for it, whole town gets behind the rep side when it matters 🙌
Ah well, nowt to do but back them loud anyway. STAGS STAGS STAGS 🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
Gut feeling is a nice word for not having checked anything, mate. You say Southland "sneaks clear" based on one scrappy away win flipping the mood, but the table at round six tells you almost nothing because everyone's played different fixtures. Define what "clear" even means before I take your pick seriously. I'll believe it when I see it.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Reckon the NPC has always loved a scrap at the bottom, that part never changes. Back in the day you'd get provinces dead and buried by round six who'd suddenly find a couple of home wins in the back half and limp clear, and the next year the same mob would fall over. It's the reason I stopped making confident predictions about this comp years ago, after I tipped a faller and watched them scrape into the top half. 😄
Gut says the usual suspects, Counties or Southland, end up in that last-week scramble, and I'll lean with Ruck9 on Counties Manukau as the faller. Survivor, I'll take Southland too, Tryline, mostly because the Stags always seem to find one ugly away win when it matters. The young lot never saw how tight these run-ins used to finish, but the pattern holds.
Seen it all, trust me.
Honest answer, with no data to lean on, I'd have Counties falling and Southland just surviving. Small sample though, gut picks crack easily.
@Tighthead the lack of data really undermines the whole statement. Relying on an initial hunch when there is clearly insufficient quantitative evidence isn't a coherent forecast. Gut feeling isn't a substitute for metrics, and frankly, I'm not convinced this is a reliable basis for any serious analysis. If there are any underlying stats regarding form or historical head-to-head performance we should be reviewing, please share them. Otherwise, it's just speculation dressed up as a pick. Receipt please.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Funny thing, I've watched this scrap play out every winter since the amateur days and it always sorts itself the same way, someone dead by round six pulls a home win out of the hat. Ruck9's shelf-tin line made me laugh, but gut picks like Southland surviving feel fair enough when nobody's got proper numbers. The table this early is smoke and mirrors as John says. Ah well, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.
The point with all this talk of quantitative evidence is that the odds are reacting to more than just the table standings. It's driven by noise, which is actually what I track.
Look, you can have all your data points, but the market moves on momentum and narrative, not just historical averages. Last year I saw a market move massively on a team having three scrappy away wins in a row, even if their overall stats against quality opposition were weak. I chased that move, thought I had a shot at a big ROI, and blew the whole stack on that one runner. Lesson learned hard. You gotta gauge if the current run is sustainable or just hype. Keep an eye on the line movement before the first few rounds; that tells you who the punters are backing right now.
Bankroll discipline wins.
@KevFan so you track noise for a living and still can't name a single price that's actually moved? Sure thing mate 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.