Bunnings NPC title race: is the Premiership table honestly a
Seen this debate kick off every season and it always smells the same. Three-horse race? Could be wrong, but I reckon the Premiership table flatters the top few early because the heartland provinces carry the deepest squads, so when All Blacks-eligible blokes get rested or injured, the gap tightens fast. Availability beats paper talent more often than we admit, yeah nah, cop-out or not, that's the real variable.
Nah it's a cop-out tbh 😤 fitness of the ABs matters sure, but the best side on paper wins it more often than not. Get in!! 🔥💪
Seen plenty of these races go down to the last round, and often it's the hungrier pack, not the fancy squad, that lifts the log at the end. 😉
Seen plenty of these races go down to the last round, and often it's the hungrier pack, not the fancy squad, that lifts the log at the end. 😉
SweetAs_Mad, "hungrier pack" is doing a lot of work in that sentence. Hunger doesn't show up on the ladder, fixtures do. Mid-season the table's mostly a reflection of who's played the softer run, and every year some side sitting fourth in August gets pencilled in as the plucky dark horse, then fades once they hit the heartland provinces away. Ruck9's got the mechanism right, squad depth and ABs availability decide who's still standing in the semis.
So no, I don't buy the romantic version. If your title pick rests on a gut feel about hunger rather than who's actually available in late September, that's just a lazy prediction dressed up. Convince me with rotation policies and injury lists, otherwise I'll stay sceptical.
Sample first, conclusions after.
RotoruaLoyal's got it right, I keep my own table every round and the bottom six is compressed enough that one September slip rewrites it. Nobody's safe, nobody's dead yet 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
@NickBreakdown1982 same tbh, seen plenty of September collapses from our lot 😅 keep the faith though, backing them all day 🔥💪
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Funny how every winter I reckon I've got the NPC figured out, and every spring it laughs at me.
I'll side with RotoruaLoyal and Nick here. The table early doors always flatters someone, usually a heartland mob with the deeper bench, and the young lot never saw those seasons where Canterbury sat pretty in July then got turned over twice in September. Squad depth and keeping your ABs-eligible fellas on the park matters, no argument there, but I've seen hungrier sides with half the names pinch a title all the same. If I was throwing a few dollars on a TAB multi I'd want to see who copped injuries and who's got the away trips left, not just who looks good on paper.
So aye, believable table, but nobody down to eighth is dead yet. Ah well, we'll see. 😉
Been here longer than some have followed.