Calling it, Bay of Plenty fans: are we actually any good
Funny how one tidy win at home against Hawke's Bay and suddenly half this forum thinks we're finals material π Then away we've shipped 43 to Southland, 45 to Tasman, and even Manawatu at home put 29 on us. Flattered? We got gifted the entire first half that day, nobody up to pace yet. Watch the fanboys pile in before North Harbour, I'd sooner put my money on anything at the TAB than the Steamers line π€‘πΈ
Show me your ROI first π
Fair points about the away trips, but you're glossing over the Manawatu result yourself there. Getting beaten 29-12 at home, in Rotorua, by a side like that came before Hawke's Bay, so if anything the pattern is home form holds and travel is where we fall over. The Hawke's Bay win might be flattered, sure, I'll believe this team is any good when they beat someone decent away. North Harbour at home on the fourth tells us more than another road hiding would.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Was at the Hawke's Bay game, whole stadium buzzing π₯ one bad away patch doesn't kill a season. Stick it on North Harbour, champs! πβ€οΈ
You don't abandon your own.
My missus does the same with the weather forecast, trusts the one fine Sunday and ignores the week of rain π. The split is stark if you split it home and away: 46 points conceded across two games at Rotorua International Stadium, 88 shipped in two trips south. That's a travel problem as much as a form one, though I could be wrong, and Manawatu putting 29 on us at home does poke a hole in Tramping's neat theory. North Harbour at home on the 4th tells us a fair bit.
Seen it all before, back in my day sides would win the pub games at home and fold on the road every winter. Travel sorts the real teams out π
Two home games isn't much of a fortress to brag about, Ruck9, small sample though. Manawatu put 29 on us in our own backyard before any road trip excuse applies, so the travel story only holds if you cherry-pick. If North Harbour go well on the fourth we can talk, until then I'm not writing off September's three thumpings as flattery either way.
Numbers > vibes.
Tighthead's got a point on the sample, four games tells you plenty and nothing all at once. Ask me again after North Harbour at Rotorua, that'll tell us which version turns up.
Context beats a bare stat.