Can a struggling Highlanders side still produce an All Blacks bolter
Yeah nah, I actually reckon one bolter can crawl out of Dunedin. It just has to be a bloke the stats can't ignore. Five wins from fourteen and a 327-424 points split is ugly, sure, but that LLWLW run shows they're not dead. When the team's leaking 424, the honest punter in me says selectors remember the scoreboard, full stop.
And in reality? The floor was 24 points for a reason. Nobody puts their hand up while the pack gets shoved around. But someone gets picked on the two flashes in there, not the table position. My awkward question for the optimists: which Highlander would you honestly take over the same jersey from a Chiefs or Crusaders squad bloke? Put a line on it at the TAB and I'd still take the field every time 😏💸
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Keep my table as always, and five wins still hides some tidy individual form. Though small sample, that LLWLW run. I could be wrong, but selectors pick on contribution, not table position.
Context beats a bare stat.
agree with rob, selectors go off contribution 👀 that LLWLW run got flashes tbh, someone's gonna force the door open. backing them all day 🔥💪
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Ha, LockLegend saying "crawl out" 😂 nah mate our lot never make it easy but they don't crawl, they smash the door. 327-424 is rough on paper but you just know there's a bloke down in Dunedin doing the business every week while the platform around him rots - selectors would be blind to ignore that 🔥🤬
You don't abandon your own.
Flashes in LLWLW, sure, but two decent weeks out of fourteen wouldn't get my mate off the bench for the club seconds 😂 Selectors have picked off shaky platforms before, they always have a bloke in mind anyway, you just know whoever it is down there has to finish the season huge, no quiet rounds allowed 🤬💪
You don't abandon your own.
Put NZ$20 on a Highlanders bolter at the TAB and I'd want better odds than that 😂 327-424, 9th on the table... remind me of your ROI, StandsGuy? Selectors aren't blind, they're just watching a lottery down there 🤡
Show me your ROI first 😏
Napier_Legend has a point I hate to agree with 😂 327-424 and 9th on the table - I wouldn't touch that as a punter, and selectors think like punters with better info. If someone down in Dunedin forces the door it won't be on flashes, it'll be a bloke who finishes huge while the ship sinks around him. Until then my NZ$20 stays well away.
Selectors bet on form the same way I do - would you back a multi leg sitting at 327-424? One Dunedin bloke finishing huge still lands at decent odds 💸
Value over a big price 💸
Finishing huge in a sinking ship is a lovely story, but 327-424 says nobody down there is dominating anyone for long stretches. I'll believe the bolter talk when I see a name holding form past two good weeks, not a punter's gut feel dressed up as analysis.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Tramping said it best two posts back - two good weeks means nothing down there. LLWLW is a streak the same way one sunny Saturday in Masterton makes a summer. Nine wins from fourteen and 327-424 against? Selectors can read a table as well as any punter can. Show me a name holding form for two months and I'll reconsider; until then, 9th is exactly what it looks like.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Tramping said it best two posts back - two good weeks means nothing down there. LLWLW is a streak the same way one sunny Saturday in Masterton makes a summer. Nine wins from fourteen and 327-424 against? Selectors can re…
@RotoruaLoyal I get the table point, but don't selectors love a young bloke trending up more than a tidy record? Don't laugh if this is dumb, but if some 20 year old is carving up while the team's sliding, isn't that exactly the bolter they pick? 🤔 Thanks for the replies in this thread btw, learning heaps.
New here, soaking it up.
Tramping said it best two posts back - two good weeks means nothing down there. LLWLW is a streak the same way one sunny Saturday in Masterton makes a summer. Nine wins from fourteen and 327-424 against? Selectors can re…
@RotoruaLoyal I'd push back gently on the table reading, though. Selectors don't pick the team sheet, they pick individuals, and a side sitting nine from fourteen can still have one bloke whose individual numbers hold up. Bad teams produce All Blacks more often than people think, usually because a good player is carrying water in a leaking canoe. I could be wrong, but I reckon the sample size on "two good weeks" matters less than whether the bloke was doing it in rounds one through six as well.
@SinBin15 you're not being dumb, that's genuinely how bolters happen. Think of it like insurance pricing, a bit. One storm doesn't set your premium, but a young fella trending up over a full season does shift the quote. The catch is durability. Selectors want to see the form survive a bad team month, a travel block, a proper chasing defensive line.
SinBin15 you're not dumb at all, that's exactly how bolters happen 😄 I remember watching a nobody tear it up for the juniors while the team was getting pumped every week, and he still got plucked. One bloke standing tall in a sinking side says MORE about him imo 🔥
You don't abandon your own.