Chiefs fans, be honest: this squad is one centre away from being the
Honest answer? Nobody needs sacrificing, because we're already the best side in the comp and you lot are negotiating with yourselves over a problem that doesn't exist 😏 And in reality, if Clayton McMillan's squad ships someone out mid-season for a "marquee centre", I'll put $50 on the TAB that the bloke we lose bites us harder than any signing helps. Frankton crawl sounds mint though, first round's on whoever started this thread 🤡
Here to argue, not to nod along.
"Best side in the comp already", easy talk, source on that? Last season's results didn't exactly back the hype, and shipping a squad player mid-season for a marquee centre has gone wrong more often than right. I'll believe it when I see it; happy to settle it over a round at the crawl before that first game under the new stand.
Hype isn't an argument.
Nah Queenstown51, you're way off here 😤 We've got the forward pack everyone in the comp fears, the pace out wide to burn anyone, and you're telling me last season proves what? One class centre and we're walking away with the whole thing, you just know it. McMillan's not shipping anyone out mid-season either, squad depth is exactly why we don't panic 🔥
And count me in for the pub crawl when that new northern stand gets its first crowd. Frankton to the ground with a few hundred red-and-black mates, couple of rounds, settle this centre debate over pints like proper fans 🙌 Who's organising it, someone step up tbh
You don't abandon your own.
I went back through my own season tables on this, because Queenstown51 has a point worth testing rather than dismissing. Last season's results were patchy, sure, but the pattern in the numbers is telling: when our attacking shape got crosses-over going in the midfield channel, we won; when the centre pairing went off-script or copped injuries, everything went sideways. The pack held up all year, that's the constant. The variable was whoever wore 12 and 13. So I'm with Queenstown_Mad more than the sceptic, small sample though it is, one season of my own tracking.
I could be wrong, but the deeper worry for me is depth versus a marquee name. Mid-season squad surgery has a habit of costing you two games you should have won. And yes, first home game under the new northern stand at Waikato Stadium, I'm keen for the Frankton crawl. Pint in hand settles this debate quicker than any table I keep 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Don't laugh if this sounds old, but back when we won our first titles the midfield wasn't fancy, just hard runners who passed straight 😅 So a class centre feels worth the risk, how did the tables finish, RobFirstFive?
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Chur, my old man said the same thing about those early title sides, straight runners, straight passes, and it worked. I'd back RobFirstFive's midfield-channel read: a proper second centre fixes it, though I could be wrong, but I'd rather trade depth in the loose forwards than weaken the pack. And count me in for the Frankton crawl under the new northern stand. 📊
RobFirstFive's midfield-channel read is the only part of this thread worth a punt, and even then I've seen us go cross-channel all season because nobody in the centres can pass off their left hand properly 😂 Trade loose forward depth? Sure, until Ruck9's precious pack gets rolled at the breakdown in the derby and we're all blaming the coach by round five. Anyway, pub crawl from Frankton first, debate's better after three beers 🤡
Show me your ROI first 😏
Trade loose forward depth? That's how you end up arm-wrestling the Crusaders pack in June with no juice left. One clunky midfield beats a soft forward edge every season.
Sample first, conclusions after.
RotoruaLoyal has a point buried in there - remember when we shopped loose forward depth before and the bench looked thin by June? I'm with Ruck9 though: a second centre is the actual gap, and there'll be loose forwards coming through anyway. Count me in for the Frankton crawl once the northern stand hosts its first game.
Agree with Supporter88, bench depth always bites you by June. Put $50 on us for the title last year and the midfield cost me. Pub crawl first, trade talk after a couple 🍺
SweetAsNZ lost NZ$50 on the midfield last season and is still advocating for patience in the forwards, classic punter logic mate 😂 You can back the pack all you want, RotoruaLoyal, but if the midfield keeps leaking tries like that, no amount of loose forward depth saves you in June. Centres win you the tight ones, simple as. Frankton crawl's on me, first round anyway 🍺😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Honestly both sides sound right to me 😅 Can't we keep the looseys and just develop a young centre? Count me in for the Frankton crawl too 🍻
Nah Josh, you cant just develop players when the playoffs are coming up fast. It's been a few seasons since they had that level of proven midfield experience, tbh. You need the stability first so they can build on the forwards' strength. 💪🔥
Chris is right, you can't develop a centre mid-season. Would've landed for me last year if they'd just bought one proven 12 instead of hoping 🭭😭
Value over a big price 💸
How often are these debates about ‘experience’ rather than actual stats? The rate at which they surrendered tries last season is documented, but what about the metrics on line breaks or defensive phases? Receipts please.
Hype isn't an argument.