Don't laugh, but what actually is a scrum and why do they restart
Don't laugh please π but I got confused watching the weekend footy with my flatmates. When someone knocks the ball on, why do eight fellas from each side get in a huddle and shove each other instead of just giving the ball back? And how does anyone actually "win" a scrum, do they just push harder? Maybe I'm wrong but it looks like chaos to me π
New here, soaking it up.
Okay wait, so if your pack shoves the other one backwards, do you get to put the ball in next time too? π
New here, soaking it up.
Nah, the side that wins the scrum keeps the ball from that restart, it doesn't carry over to feeding the next one, the feed alternates or goes to whoever's owed it after each stoppage. Think of it like a old-school tug of war with a ball fed in the middle, the hooker strikes it back once your pack shoves them off the ball. Seen worse ways to decide possession I suppose, and trust me the young lot never saw the mudheap scrums we used to get down at the park, eight blokes and a referee praying nobody's neck got silly π
Seen it all, trust me.
Nah Robbed, John's right, no carry-over. The feed goes to whoever's owed it after the knock-on or forward pass, and winning the push just decides whether you actually keep that ball or get shunted off it. Simple punter lesson from my own tab slips: first scrum penalties after a knock-on are gold for a tight line, front row dominance wins you the momentum before the backs even touch it. π₯
This thread is helping me too, cheers π
So if I've got it right, winning the shove just means you keep the ball from that scrum and get to play it out the back? My old man tried explaining it at halftime once and I still nodded along clueless. Feeling less munted about it now, thanks John π
Learn something new every day.
Breakdown mate I did the exact same nod-along for years, my old man gave up explaining and just handed me a pie at halftime π€£ You've got it right though, win the shove, keep the ball, off you go. Took me watching replays properly to actually get it, no shame in it haha πΏ
Memes are analysis too.
Breakdown mate I did the exact same nod-along for years, my old man gave up explaining and just handed me a pie at halftime π€£ You've got it right though, win the shove, keep the ball, off you go. Took me watching replaysβ¦
@LauraFaithful the pie at halftime is peak rugby dad honestly π€£ I coach the juniors here in Nelson and half of them nod along exactly the same way until they actually get to shove in a scrum themselves, then it clicks in one session. Front row's where you really learn what "win the shove" means, eh πͺ
You don't abandon your own.