What is a penalty kick in simple terms?
Just started watching club rugby properly this season and there's a thing confusing me π
what is a penalty kick in simple terms, and how is it different from a normal kick? Don't laugh, I genuinely don't get when the ref gives one. Keen to finally understand it π cheers!
Dumb questions are my specialty.
No laughs here mate, half the fellas at the club bar still argue about this one π
A penalty kick is what the ref awards when a team commits a serious infringement, things like offside, a high tackle, collapsing a maul, that sort of thing. The wronged side then gets a choice: kick at the posts for 3 points, kick for touch to set up an attacking lineout, or tap and go / take a scrum if they fancy running it. A normal kick is just part of open play, nobody's done anything wrong.
The "serious" bit is the grey area that winds everyone up. Knock-on or a forward pass? Scrum, no penalty. Rucking the bloke on the ground, offside from the kick, or pulling down a maul? That's penalty territory. Refs have got stricter on high tackles in recent years, so you'll see plenty given these days. The choice of options is the fun part, some sides always take the 3 points, others point to the corner and back their lineout drive.
@SweetAs_Mad nah you pretty much nailed it mate πͺ only thing I'd add is the team can kick for goal, kick for touch or tap and go, their choice. Tried explaining that to the juniors last training and one of em asked why anyone would ever tap, told him watch the games and see how often a tap catches the defence asleep π
ah well, nowt to do.
Cheers Rob, that example helped heaps π But what if the defender kills the ball by accident, like he's just falling over? Does the ref still give a penalty, or is that a scrum thing? Maybe I'm wrong but that seems harsh π
New here, soaking it up.
One example that stuck with me: a Chiefs v Crusaders derby a few seasons back, last ten minutes, a defender comes in off his feet at the breakdown and kills the ball. Ref whistles it straight away, and because the offence happened right in front of the posts, the captain has a sit-down decision on his hands.
That's the difference SteveAuckland is asking about. The referee doesn't choose the outcome, the offending team's opponents do. Three points via the shot at goal if the scores are tight, or a lineout throw five metres out if they smell a try. Or the quick tap if the defence is still back-pedalling, which is the cheeky option. What makes it "serious" compared to a free kick is essentially intent or danger: high tackles, offside from a kick, collapsing a maul, playing the man without the ball. Free kicks get given for the smaller technical stuff at the scrum. Small sample though, but I'd say most confusion at the pub comes from that exact line between the two.
Context beats a bare stat.
accidents are tough to judge, aren't they? i've seen a few close calls over the years out here where the referee just has to decide if it was genuine contact or just a bit of a fall. serious infringements give the attacking side a choice of outcomes depending on where the foul happens on the pitch, which is what determines the end result. in short: a penalty kick awards the non-offending team a choice of actions, scoring three points at the goal, taking a lineout, or reforming the scrum, following a serious breach of play.
Been here longer than some have followed.