Five straight losses yet still fourth
Five losses on the bounce and somehow sitting fourth - that's not a footy side, that's a lottery ticket that hadn't been scratched yet π The 456-412 diff screams average, not top four. Anyone actually putting money on this mob at the TAB deserves to lose it π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
Scrum10 gets it π₯ you bank 8 wins early you've earned the right to slump a bit. Form column's ugly but the table never lies tbh. Backing them all day πͺ ah well, nowt to do.
Been keeping my own table this season and the split is stark: eight wins banked in the first stretch versus six losses now, and that +44 diff sits exactly where a 8-6 side should. The form column looks worse than the underlying record because a slump resets perception, not the ledger. I could be wrong, but the table isn't lagging, the recent sample is just smaller and louder. Five straight is a worry, though, no argument there.
Context beats a bare stat.
Napier's clown joke ages badly every season, seen it before, sides have limped into the top four off an early bank and gone deep in the finals. That +44 diff tells me they're a 8-6 team, nothing more, so I price them accordingly: took the Blues +line last weekend and it didn't land, lesson banked. Table position is earned, but form is what pays out. π₯
Sorry if this is dumb π
but if they were that good wouldn't the ledger still be winning? Five losses running feels more than a slump to me π€·
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Rob, a ledger that stops winning five weeks running is telling you something π I'd happily take the Blues 4th at the TAB if anyone's silly enough to back them. Sure thing, mate.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Steve's got a point tbh π€ five on the bounce isn't a slump, that's a slide. Only +44 across 14 games? Fourth place is doing a lot of heavy lifting π₯
π€£ This thread is better than the Blues' last month. Five straight L's and everyone still arguing maths. The form column doesn't lie, lads, the table's just on a slow curtain call π
Only serious one here β barely.
π€£ This thread is better than the Blues' last month. Five straight L's and everyone still arguing maths. The form column doesn't lie, lads, the table's just on a slow curtain call π
@JohnBlues funny thing, my spreadsheet updates on a Sunday with a coffee, and the spreadsheet's been whispering the same thing for a month now. Form column and table disagreeing this hard usually means the table is running on old information.
Wellington_15, good question actually, and both things can be true at once. Eight wins got those 38 points banked when things were humming, that's real, not luck. But the +44 across 14 games tells you the margin for error was always thin. One or two of those wins were probably tighter than the table remembers. Form is the newer data point, and five straight is a big enough sample of "right now" that I'd weight it heavier than season aggregates. Whether they get found out in finals depends who they draw, so I wouldn't write the obituary yet, but the trend line isn't doing them any favours. π
Do the math before you argue.
Steve asking the real question and everyone dancing round it π
nah LockLegend, I ain't taking that TAB line, five straight L's says it all tbh. 456-412 in 14 games is just a side treading water, the table's flattered them big time π₯ they gonna get found out come finals.
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Genuine question from someone still learning this: eight wins got them 38 points, so the table can't be all luck, right? π
But five L's on the bounce with only +44 makes me think you blokes are right that they're treading water. Maybe both things are true at once? keen to see if they turn it around before finals π€
Dumb questions are my specialty.
@Wellington_15 both things being true at once is exactly the point, actually. Eight wins got them 38 points because the wins came early and the draws/losses came late. The table doesn't care about order, the form column does. FrontRowArmy's spreadsheet and a basic glance at the results agree, so I don't know why we're still debating it.
Where I'd push back slightly is "+44 means treading water". Differential is a lazy read on its own, you need to know when those points were scored. A side that pumps a bottom club in round 3 and loses tight since then looks identical on the diff to one that's been grinding even results all year. Been burned before trusting that column over my own eyes. So my question to you would be, define "treading water", because if you mean the table's flattering them right now, fine, I'm with you. If you mean they're a bad side, not convinced yet.
Sample first, conclusions after.
This is all so confusing to me π
do we really have to worry about the form part too, thanks for answering, JohnBlues?